4.5 Article

Assessing the Performance of EU Nature Legislation in Protecting Target Bird Species in an Era of Climate Change

Journal

CONSERVATION LETTERS
Volume 9, Issue 3, Pages 172-180

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/conl.12196

Keywords

Conservation policy; European Union; bird population trends; climate change; birds directive; migration

Funding

  1. European Commission

Ask authors/readers for more resources

International legislation forms a cornerstone of conservation, yet its efficacy is rarely quantified. We assess whether species listed on Annex I of the European Union (EU) Birds Directive, for which EU Member States are obliged to implement special conservation measures, differ systematically in their short-term (2001-2012) or long-term (1980-2012) population trends from those of non-Annex I species. In both periods, Annex I species had more positive trends than non-Annex I species, particularly in countries that joined the EU earlier. There were additional signatures of climate change and life history strategy in the trends of species in one or both periods. Within Annex I species, long-distance migrants fared significantly worse than other species, suggesting that enhanced protection on the breeding grounds alone may be insufficient for these species. We conclude that the EU's conservation legislation has had a demonstrably positive impact on target species, even during a period in which climate change has significantly affected populations.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Camera trapping with photos and videos: implications for ecology and citizen science

Sian E. Green, Philip A. Stephens, Mark J. Whittingham, Russell A. Hill

Summary: Camera traps are commonly used in wildlife monitoring and citizen science, but concerns over video performance have led to the majority of studies collecting still images. However, a study conducted in the UK found no difference in ecological outputs between video and photo datasets. Additionally, citizen scientists were able to classify videos more accurately and provide more additional information compared to experts. This suggests that using video in camera-trapping projects, especially when combined with citizen science, can yield higher quality data.

REMOTE SENSING IN ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Benefits of protected area networks for breeding bird populations and communities

F. J. Sanderson, J. D. Wilson, S. E. Franks, G. M. Buchanan

Summary: Protected areas are crucial for conservation, and the EU Natura 2000 network is the largest coordinated network of protected areas in the world. A study in Britain found that Natura 2000 protection has positive conservation benefits for birds of higher conservation concern and community specialisation. This highlights the importance of protected areas, especially those with the strictest protection, for maintaining biodiversity.

ANIMAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Ecology

Model selection in occupancy models: Inference versus prediction

Peter S. Stewart, Philip A. Stephens, Russell A. Hill, Mark J. Whittingham, Wayne Dawson

Summary: Occupancy models are commonly used in ecology to study species occurrence, but selecting among models with different sets of covariates can lead to inaccurate parameter estimates. This study investigated the consequences of collider bias in occupancy and detection processes and explored the implications for model selection using information criteria. The results showed that information criteria can accurately select detection covariates regardless of the model's purpose, but caution is needed when selecting occupancy covariates for understanding environmental variables. These findings highlight the importance of distinguishing between parameter inference and prediction tasks in ecological modeling.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ornithology

The phenology and clutch size of UK Blue Tits does not differ with woodland composition

Claire J. J. Branston, Mark J. J. Whittingham, Albert B. B. Phillimore, Dave Leech, Stephen G. G. Willis

Summary: The impacts of climate change on phenology and reproductive investment of birds in woodland habitats with different tree compositions were investigated. The study found that woodland composition did not have a significant effect on the first egg date and clutch size of Blue Tits. However, clutch size has decreased as spring temperatures have increased in recent decades.
Article Biology

Drivers of the changing abundance of European birds at two spatial scales

Richard D. Gregory, Mark A. Eaton, Ian J. Burfield, Philip V. Grice, Christine Howard, Alena Klvanova, David Noble, Eva Silarova, Anna Staneva, Philip A. Stephens, Stephen G. Willis, Ian D. Woodward, Fiona Burns

Summary: This article models temporal change in species' abundance and biomass by using extensive data describing the population sizes and trends of native breeding birds in the United Kingdom (UK) and the European Union (EU). It finds significant change in the bird assemblages of the UK and EU, with overall bird abundance decreasing and losses concentrated in abundant and smaller sized species. The study also highlights the correlation between abundance trends and species' traits, migration strategy, and niche associations linked to diet.

PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2023)

Article Ecology

dynamicSDM: An R package for species geographical distribution and abundance modelling at high spatiotemporal resolution

Rachel Dobson, Andy J. J. Challinor, Robert A. A. Cheke, Stewart Jennings, Stephen G. G. Willis, Martin Dallimer

Summary: Species distribution models (SDM) are widely used to understand species distribution and abundance changes. However, existing SDM tools lack the ability to model species distributions driven by dynamic environmental conditions. dynamicSDM provides novel tools that consider the temporal dimension, allowing for more accurate and detailed modeling. It is flexible, compatible with other SDM tools, and has low computing power and storage needs.

METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Removing Human Bottlenecks in Bird Classification Using Camera Trap Images and Deep Learning

Carl Chalmers, Paul Fergus, Serge Wich, Steven. N. N. Longmore, Naomi Davies Walsh, Philip. A. A. Stephens, Chris Sutherland, Naomi Matthews, Jens Mudde, Amira Nuseibeh

Summary: Birds are crucial for monitoring biodiversity and habitat health, and they play a vital role in ecosystem management. Declining bird populations can lead to reduced ecosystem services such as seed dispersal, pollination, and pest control. While monitoring birds is important for ecologists, it is often time-consuming, expensive, and challenging to manage. This paper proposes using deep learning to overcome the challenges and automate bird monitoring in camera trap data.

REMOTE SENSING (2023)

Article Ecology

A camera trap method for estimating target densities of grey squirrels to inform wildlife management applications

Sarah E. Beatham, Philip A. Stephens, Julia Coats, John Phillips, Giovanna Massei

Summary: Effective wildlife population management requires understanding species abundance. In the United Kingdom, the increase of non-native invasive grey squirrels poses a threat to native red squirrels, tree health, and the forestry industry. A camera trap index was developed to estimate target densities of grey squirrels in woodlands to guide control measures. The index had a strong linear relationship with squirrels removed in trapping operations, and results could be obtained within 6 days.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Ecology

Remote monitoring of short-term body mass variation in savanna ungulates

Nicolas Fuentes-Allende, Philip A. Stephens, Lynne M. MacTavish, Dougal MacTavish, Stephen G. Willis

Summary: Large herbivores in highly seasonal savanna habitats often experience significant changes in body mass due to availability of critical resources and breeding events. However, documentation of this mass variation has been rarely explored. In this study, we developed a method using mineral-baited scales and camera traps to track body mass of three bovid species across wet and dry seasons in a South African savanna ecosystem. The method proved to be effective in monitoring and revealed significant changes in body mass, which were related to factors such as vegetation productivity and rainfall frequency. This non-lethal and non-invasive method has various potential applications, including informing management decisions and assessing ecological states. It may also be valuable for monitoring long-term body condition in animals affected by environmental change in arid systems.

REMOTE SENSING IN ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Ecology

Estimating mesocarnivore abundance on commercial farmland using distance sampling with camera traps

Jamie E. T. McKaughan, Philip A. Stephens, Russell A. Hill

Summary: Mesocarnivores are important in wildlife management, but estimating their densities is challenging. This study used camera trapping to estimate the densities of four carnivores in commercial farmland in South Africa. The study highlights the importance of careful selection of parameters and suggests the need for more studies to increase confidence in accuracy.

ECOLOGICAL SOLUTIONS AND EVIDENCE (2023)

Article Zoology

Integrative taxonomy reveals unrecognised species diversity in African Corypha larks (Aves: Alaudidae)

Per Alstroem, Zeinolabedin Mohammadi, Paul F. Donald, Marianne Nymark, Erik D. Enbody, Martin Irestedt, Emmanuel Barde Elisha, Henry K. Ndithia, B. Irene Tieleman, Derek Engelbrecht, Urban Olsson, Lois Rancilhac, Martin Stervander

Summary: Comprehensive taxonomic analysis of the rufous-naped lark complex in sub-Saharan Africa reveals the need for reclassification, proposing the recognition of nine species instead of five.

ZOOLOGICAL JOURNAL OF THE LINNEAN SOCIETY (2023)

Article Ecology

Factors affecting bait uptake by the grey squirrel (Sciurus carolinensis) and the future delivery of oral contraceptives

Sarah E. Beatham, Julia Coats, Philip A. Stephens, Giovanna Massei

Summary: The study aimed to estimate the efficacy of delivering baits via feeders to grey squirrels and determine the most important factors for bait uptake. The findings showed that baits delivered via feeders can target the majority of grey squirrels in woodland environments. This implies that oral contraceptives could be a cost-effective tool to reduce the population of grey squirrels and mitigate their negative impacts on native wildlife and tree health.

WILDLIFE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

A novel, post-Soviet fire disturbance regime drives bird diversity and abundance on the Eurasian steppe

Tejas Bhagwat, Tobias Kuemmerle, Mahmood Soofi, Paul F. Donald, Norbert Hoelzel, Albert Salemgareev, Ingrid Stirnemann, Ruslan Urazaliyev, Matthias Baumann, Johannes Kamp

Summary: The increase in fire disturbance in post-Soviet Eurasian steppe has resulted in significant declines in bird abundance and changes in community assembly. Restoring wild herbivore populations and traditional domestic ungulate grazing systems are crucial for controlling wildfires and preventing further biodiversity loss.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

No Data Available