4.6 Article

Beyond Rational Decision-Making: Modelling the Influence of Cognitive Biases on the Dynamics of Vaccination Coverage

Journal

PLOS ONE
Volume 10, Issue 11, Pages -

Publisher

PUBLIC LIBRARY SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0142990

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. School of Anthropology and Museum Ethnography at Oxford, UK
  2. Chair Modelisation Mathematique et Biodiversite of Veolia Environnement-Ecole Polytechnique-Museum National d'Histoire Naturelle-Fondation X, France

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background Theoretical studies predict that it is not possible to eradicate a disease under voluntary vaccination because of the emergence of non-vaccinating free-riders when vaccination coverage increases. A central tenet of this approach is that human behaviour follows an economic model of rational choice. Yet, empirical studies reveal that vaccination decisions do not necessarily maximize individual self-interest. Here we investigate the dynamics of vaccination coverage using an approach that dispenses with payoff maximization and assumes that risk perception results from the interaction between epidemiology and cognitive biases. Methods We consider a behaviour-incidence model in which individuals perceive actual epidemiological risks as a function of their opinion of vaccination. As a result of confirmation bias, sceptical individuals (negative opinion) overestimate infection cost while pro-vaccines individuals (positive opinion) overestimate vaccination cost. We considered a feedback between individuals and their environment as individuals could change their opinion, and thus the way they perceive risks, as a function of both the epidemiology and the most common opinion in the population. Results For all parameter values investigated, the infection is never eradicated under voluntary vaccination. For moderately contagious diseases, oscillations in vaccination coverage emerge because individuals process epidemiological information differently depending on their opinion. Conformism does not generate oscillations but slows down the cultural response to epidemiological change. Conclusion Failure to eradicate vaccine preventable disease emerges from the model because of cognitive biases that maintain heterogeneity in how people perceive risks. Thus, assumptions of economic rationality and payoff maximization are not mandatory for predicting commonly observed dynamics of vaccination coverage. This model shows that alternative notions of rationality, such as that of ecological rationality whereby individuals use simple cognitive heuristics, offer promising new avenues for modelling vaccination behaviour.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

On Deleterious Mutations in Perennials: Inbreeding Depression, Mutation Load, and Life-History Evolution

Thomas Lesaffre, Sylvain Billiard

Summary: This study investigates the higher levels of inbreeding depression in perennials compared to annuals in angiosperms. By combining a physiological growth model and multilocus population genetics approaches, the researchers explore the impact of mutations affecting growth or survival on inbreeding depression and mutation load. The study suggests that traits under strong selection, decreasing sharply with increasing life expectancy, may be responsible for generating high inbreeding depression in long-lived species.

AMERICAN NATURALIST (2021)

Article Ecology

Identifying conversion efficiency as a key mechanism underlying food webs adaptive evolution: a step forward, or backward?

Coralie Fritsch, Sylvain Billiard, Nicolas Champagnat

Summary: Body size or mass plays a crucial role in shaping food web structure, and the consideration of biomass conversion efficiency dependent on species size is essential for the adaptive evolution of food webs. The study questions the robustness of evolutionary models for the study of food webs and emphasizes the importance of paying attention to how biomass flows into food webs in models.

OIKOS (2021)

Editorial Material Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The changing climates of global health

Thomas Cousins, Michelle Pentecost, Alexandra Alvergne, Clare Chandler, Simukai Chigudu, Clare Herrick, Ann Kelly, Sabina Leonelli, Javier Lezaun, Jamie Lorimer, David Reubi, Sharifah Sekalala

BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH (2021)

Article Biology

The integrative biology of genetic dominance

Sylvain Billiard, Vincent Castric, Violaine Llaurens

Summary: This study explores the evolution of dominance inheritance, suggesting that the opposing views of Fisher and Wright can be reconciled through models of gene expression and developmental regulation. The article also provides detailed insights from recent empirical studies, revealing the diverse molecular and physiological mechanisms underlying dominance and its evolution. By bridging population genetics and functional biology, the review aims to promote interdisciplinary dialogue in the study of dominance evolution.

BIOLOGICAL REVIEWS (2021)

Article Ecology

Widespread coexistence of self-compatible and self-incompatible phenotypes in a diallelic self-incompatibility system in Ligustrum vulgare (Oleaceae)

Isabelle De Cauwer, Philippe Vernet, Sylvain Billiard, Cecile Gode, Angelique Bourceaux, Chloe Ponitzki, Pierre Saumitou-Laprade

Summary: The breakdown of self-incompatibility is a common evolutionary transition in angiosperms, but stable within-population polymorphism with both inbreeding and outcrossing individuals is rarely observed in natural populations. The study on Ligustrum vulgare L. confirmed the existence of two self-incompatibility groups and the presence of self-compatible individuals in different populations of Western Europe due to a mutation affecting the functioning of the pollen component of SI. The low frequency of self-compatible individuals in natural populations is only compatible with theoretical predictions if inbreeding depression is very high.

HEREDITY (2021)

Article Demography

Anemic Women are More at Risk of Injectable Contraceptive Discontinuation due to Side Effects in Ethiopia

Rose Stevens, Blandine Malbos, Eshetu Gurmu, Jeremie Riou, Alexandra Alvergne

Summary: This study investigates the importance of women's physiological condition and sociocultural factors in predicting the risk of discontinuation of injectable contraceptives due to side effects in Ethiopia. The results suggest that anemia status is associated with discontinuation due to side effects, while religion, wealth, and relationship status are associated with discontinuation due to other reasons.

STUDIES IN FAMILY PLANNING (2022)

Article Ecology

Revisiting the number of self-incompatibility alleles in finite populations: From old models to new results

Peter Czuppon, Sylvain Billiard

Summary: This paper addresses the modeling of allele diversity in gametophytic self-incompatibility. The deterministic dynamics and stationary allele frequency distribution are derived, with results aligning with earlier findings. The study also approximates the invasion probability of new alleles and estimates the population size of a plant population based on allele frequencies.

JOURNAL OF EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

How does the host community structure affect the epidemiological dynamics of emerging infectious diseases?

Marina Voinson, Charline Smadi, Sylvain Billiard

Summary: This study examines the impact of host community structure on epidemics and finds that intermediate hosts can reduce the prevalence of infection, while infections from different sources tend to amplify the epidemic effect. These findings have important implications for the control of emerging infectious diseases.

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING (2022)

Editorial Material Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Why we must fight ignorance about COVID-19 vaccines and menstrual cycles

Alexandra Alvergne

TRENDS IN MOLECULAR MEDICINE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

A retrospective case-control study on menstrual cycle changes following COVID-19 vaccination and disease

Austin Argentieri, Gabriella Kountourides, M. Austin Argentieri, Lisa Agyen, Natalie Rogers, Dawn Knight, Gemma C. Sharp, Jacqueline A. Maybin, Zuzanna Olszewsla

Summary: There has been concern over the potential impact of COVID-19 vaccination on menstrual cycles compared to actual COVID-19 infection. A survey conducted in the UK found that 18% of pre-menopausal vaccinated individuals experienced changes in their menstrual cycles after the first vaccine dose. Smoking, history of COVID-19 infection, and non-use of contraceptives containing estradiol were identified as potential risk factors for reporting menstrual changes.

ISCIENCE (2023)

Article Ecology

Balancing selection and the crossing of fitness valleys in structured populations: diversification in the gametophytic self-incompatibility system

Roman Stetsenko, Thomas Brom, Vincent Castric, Sylvain Billiard

Summary: In this article, numerical simulations were used to investigate the effects of population subdivision on the diversification of self-incompatibility haplotypes in flowering plants. The results showed that population structure slightly reduces the parameter range allowing for haplotype diversification, but it also increases the overall diversity of these haplotypes in the metapopulation. The study suggests that population subdivision can facilitate haplotype diversification, but also increases the risk of losing the self-incompatibility system.

EVOLUTION (2023)

Review Anthropology

Cultural change beyond adoption dynamics: Evolutionary approaches to the discontinuation of contraception

Alexandra Alvergne, Rose Stevens

Summary: This article emphasizes the importance of considering both adoption and discontinuation of contraceptive behavior in understanding fertility dynamics. By integrating behavioral ecology and cultural evolution frameworks, as well as examining the individual impact of contraceptive behavior, a more comprehensive understanding of evolutionary trends in fertility regulation can be achieved.

EVOLUTIONARY HUMAN SCIENCES (2021)

Article Ecology

Inference with selection, varying population size, and evolving population structure: application of ABC to a forward-backward coalescent process with interactions

Clotilde Lepers, Sylvain Billiard, Matthieu Porte, Sylvie Meleard, Viet Chi Tran

Summary: This paper presents a new inferential procedure based on a stochastic birth-death model for analyzing ecological, demographic, and genetic parameters. The effectiveness of the inferential procedure is validated through analyses of simulated and real data, showing that different social organizations may exhibit significantly different fertilities.

HEREDITY (2021)

Article Philosophy

The Universal Grammar of Evolution

Koen Tanghe, Sylvain Billiard

Summary: The evolution of the cosmos can be divided into cosmological, biological, and cultural phases, with similarities in their underlying dynamics. This common grammar can serve as a heuristic template and aid in understanding the future evolution of artificial intelligence and intelligent machines.

PHILOSOPHY AND COSMOLOGY-FILOSOFIYA I KOSMOLOGIYA (2022)

No Data Available