4.7 Article

Using the Concept of Common Pool Resources to Understand Community Perceptions of Diverse Water Sources in Adelaide, South Australia

Journal

WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
Volume 29, Issue 5, Pages 1697-1711

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11269-014-0906-6

Keywords

Common pool resource; Urban water planning; Community perceptions

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Diversification and integration of water supply systems is occurring to advance both water security and environmental sustainability, but research into community perceptions of these changes is in its infancy. In this paper, water user group discussions of the advantages and disadvantages of the diverse water sources used in Adelaide, Australia, are analyzed in terms of the urban water system as a common pool resource: one competitively accessed by numerous users that put it at risk of depletion. The research method was a water planning activity, in which visual cues were utilised to help water users reflect on conditions that they perceived would enable acceptance of seven water source options and one water efficiency option. The key results were that water sources were perceived to be in two categories: bounded sources associated with eco-systems and viewed as common pool resources vulnerable to depletion. Unbounded sources such as rainwater in tanks, stormwater, and wastewater were seen as under-utilised sources to be further exploited if any risks to health could be mitigated. Finally, keys to acceptance were authority to govern, prevention of waste, and community engagement.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

Relocation planning must address voluntary immobility

Carol Farbotko, Olivia Dun, Fanny Thornton, Karen E. McNamara, Celia McMichael

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2020)

Article Geography

Decolonising methodologies: Emergent learning in island research

Carol Farbotko, Phillipa Watson, Taukiei Kitara, Elaine Stratford

Summary: This article documents an attempt to decolonise methodology in order to respect islands and their islanders. It discusses the challenges and complexities of applying methodologies to island research and highlights the importance of permissions, commitments to decolonisation, and deep learning. The article also presents an approach to decolonising an island research project by drawing on the concept of Fale Pili.

GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Demography

Climate mobilities: migration, im/mobilities and mobility regimes in a changing climate

Ingrid Boas, Hanne Wiegel, Carol Farbotko, Jeroen Warner, Mimi Sheller

Summary: This article discusses the concept of climate mobilities and its relationship with human mobility, immobility, and other mobile flows, highlighting the diversity of climate mobilities. It delves into the politics of climate mobilities and calls for attention to acts of resistance against dominant climate mobility regimes.

JOURNAL OF ETHNIC AND MIGRATION STUDIES (2022)

Article Demography

Anti-displacement mobilities and re-emplacements: alternative climate mobilities in Funafala

Carol Farbotko

Summary: This paper explores the concept of anticipated displacement and re-emplacements in low-lying islands, particularly focusing on the case of Funafala in Tuvalu. It highlights the importance of grassroots anti-displacement mobilities and re-emplacements in resisting climate displacement and reclaiming territory and culture.

JOURNAL OF ETHNIC AND MIGRATION STUDIES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Climate change adaptation in agriculture: Learning from an international labour mobility programme in Australia and the Pacific Islands region

Olivia Dun, Natascha Klocker, Carol Farbotko, Celia McMichael

Summary: Climate change is expected to have a serious impact on agriculture and food security in Pacific Island countries. The combination of 'modern' and Indigenous agricultural practices and knowledge is necessary for adaptation. International labour mobility programs, such as Australia's Seasonal Worker Programme (SWP), provide opportunities for knowledge exchange and climate change adaptation in agriculture in the Pacific Islands. The participation in SWP allows workers to gain adaptive knowledge from their experience in Australia and share it with other Pacific Islanders.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Who defines atoll 'uninhabitability'?

Carol Farbotko, John Campbell

Summary: This paper argues that the concept of 'uninhabitability' in the context of sea level rise risk is culturally and socially experienced and open to multiple truth claims. It emphasizes that habitability is not solely defined by material elements of human security, but also involves local knowledges, cosmologies, and place attachments. Furthermore, it highlights the need to recognize habitability and uninhabitability as relational concepts and to consider who has the right to define habitability in specific places. The paper introduces the idea of relational security among climate-exposed populations and advocates for the integration of habitability and uninhabitability in research and policy.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2022)

Article Geography

Islands, the Anthropocene, and Decolonisation

Elaine Stratford, Carol Farbotko, Phillipa Watson, Taukiei Kitara, Juno Berthelsen, Maria Chnaraki aka Maria Hnaraki, Ayano Ginoza, Christopher Cozier, Julie Edel Hardenberg

Summary: The Anthropocene is presented as an unquestionable reality, but its foundations are subject to strong criticism due to the absence, silence, or misrepresentation of certain voices and locations in this framework. Alternative explanations exist for present and future scenarios, including those focused on islands, often seen through an apocalyptic lens. Prioritizing decolonization and addressing historical and contemporary struggles are more impactful ways to secure the futures of island communities than engaging with a reified framework perpetuating colonial-imperial excesses, uneven development, and racial capitalism. This study examines the collaboration between four instigating authors and five collaborating authors to explore academic, activist, and artistic expressions of island life and concerns, aiming to understand the significance of decolonization in shaping the future of island peoples.

ANTIPODE (2023)

Article Geography

Mobilities and Immobilities in Tuvalu: an unexpected pandemic experience?

Carol Farbotko

Summary: Tuvalu, the last country to be affected by Covid-19, had no community transmission until November 2022, but is best known for its vulnerability to climate change. The pandemic offers an opportunity to challenge narratives of displacement and disease risk, and to advance the understanding of justice in terms of mobility. During the pandemic, internal migration of Tuvaluans to cultural lands revitalized a sense of community, strengthened cultural relations, and provided an opportunity to reinvigorate traditional self-sufficiency.

AUSTRALIAN GEOGRAPHER (2023)

Article Area Studies

Agrifood systems knowledge exchange through Australia-Pacific circular migration schemes

Federico Davila, Olivia Dun, Carol Farbotko, Brent Jacobs, Natascha Klocker, Ema Vueti, Lavinia Kaumaitotoya, Angela Birch, Peter Kaoh, Tikai Pitakia, Sinaitakala Tu'itahi

Summary: Pacific Island workers make significant contributions to Australia's agriculture and food security through the Seasonal Worker Programme (SWP). While previous studies have shown the economic benefits of the SWP, there is limited research on the agricultural knowledge exchange enabled by circular migration and the experiences of workers and employers as knowledge holders. With the merger of the SWP into the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility Scheme, this paper presents findings from interviews with 63 workers about agricultural knowledge exchange and highlights opportunities for further research in circular migration.

ASIA & THE PACIFIC POLICY STUDIES (2023)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

Reclaiming open climate adaptation futures

Carol Farbotko, Ingrid Boas, Ruben Dahm, Taukiei Kitara, Tafue Lusama, Tearinaki Tanielu

Summary: The narrative of certain areas becoming uninhabitable due to sea-level rise can silence important debates on alternative climate adaptation futures. It is crucial to centralize the narratives of low-emission and financially disadvantaged populations in adaptation discussions.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

A causal network approach using a community well-being framework for an initial impact assessment of large-scale energy infrastructure projects

Yuwan Malakar, Luk J. M. Peeters, Andrea Walton, Dan O'Sullivan

Summary: Impact assessment as a discipline is evolving and seeking ways to address wicked and unconventional challenges. This paper explores integrating the causal network approach into environmental and social impact assessments, using a hypothetical scenario of a large-scale green hydrogen industry in Australia. The study found that the causal network approach is useful for scoping potential social and environmental impacts and suggested three areas for further strengthening the approach: evaluating causal relationships, involving stakeholders throughout the assessment process, and incorporating ecological frameworks.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Climate mobilities, rights and justice: Complexities and particularities

Carol Farbotko, Fanny Thornton, Monika Mayrhofer, Elfriede Hermann

Summary: Climate mobility is intertwined with issues of justice and human rights. Achieving just outcomes and ensuring rights in the context of climate mobility is a complex and contested space.

FRONTIERS IN CLIMATE (2022)

Article Geography

'We didn't want to leave our island': stories of involuntary resettlement from Gaadhoo Island, Maldives

Aishath Azfa, Guy Jackson, Ross Westoby, Karen E. McNamara, Celia McMichael, Carol Farbotko

Summary: This study explores the experiences of Gaadhoo Islanders in the Maldives who were involuntarily resettled to Fonadhoo Island. The research findings indicate that the resettlement process had both positive and negative outcomes, with greater access to services and employment being positive, but the loss of identity, culture, and community cohesion being negative. The study suggests that transparency, consistency, and open communication should be central to the entire resettlement process.

TERRITORY POLITICS GOVERNANCE (2022)

Article Demography

Rising seas, immobilities, and translocality in small island states: case studies from Fiji and Tuvalu

Celia McMichael, Carol Farbotko, Annah Piggott-McKellar, Teresia Powell, Merineta Kitara

Summary: The study found that many residents affected by emerging coastal changes choose to stay in their residences, expressing concerns about local coastal changes and attributing them to climate change. While some anticipate potential relocation in the future, for now they remain in these sites to maintain livelihoods and traditions.

POPULATION AND ENVIRONMENT (2021)

Article Geography

Making place in virus-free space

Carol Farbotko

Summary: COVID-19 is not biologically present in every country, but it is nevertheless influencing how people interpret and experience different places. In Tuvalu, the government is advising urban residents to voluntarily return to rural islands, which are considered safer. This article provides a cultural geographic analysis of how rural places are being constructed as secure and meaningful during the pandemic.

GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH (2021)

No Data Available