4.5 Review

Comparative analysis of print and multimedia health materials: A review of the literature

Journal

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING
Volume 89, Issue 1, Pages 7-14

Publisher

ELSEVIER IRELAND LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.pec.2012.06.007

Keywords

Print; Multimedia; Health materials; Literature review; Health literacy

Funding

  1. Foundation for Informed Medical Decision Making

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Objective: Evaluate the evidence regarding the relative effectiveness of multimedia and print as modes of dissemination for patient education materials; examine whether development of these materials addressed health literacy. Methods: A structured literature review utilizing Medline, PsycInfo, and the Cumulative Index to the Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), supplemented by reference mining. Results: Of 738 studies screened, 30 effectively compared multimedia and print materials. Studies offered 56 opportunities for assessing the effect of medium on various outcomes (e.g., knowledge). In 30 instances (54%), no difference was noted between multimedia and print in terms of patient outcomes. Multimedia led to better outcomes vs. print in 21 (38%) comparisons vs. 5 (9%) instances for print. Regarding material development, 12 studies (40%) assessed readability and 5 (17%) involved patients in tool development. Conclusions: Multimedia appears to be a promising medium for patient education; however, the majority of studies found that print and multimedia performed equally well in practice. Few studies involved patients in material development, and less than half assessed the readability of materials. Practice implications: Future research should focus on comparing message-equivalent tools and assessing their effect on behavioral outcomes. Material development should include explicit attention to readability and patient input. (C) 2012 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Anesthesiology

Patient-Reported Opioid Pill Consumption After an ED Visit: How Many Pills Are People Using?

Danielle M. McCarthy, Howard S. Kim, Scott Hur, Patrick M. Lank, Christine Arroyo, Lauren A. Opsasnick, Katherine Piserchia, Laura M. Curtis, Michael S. Wolf, D. Mark Courtney

Summary: This study found that patients visiting the emergency department for acute pain were prescribed a median of 12 pills of hydrocodone-acetaminophen and consumed low quantities, with 92.5% having leftover pills after 10 days.

PAIN MEDICINE (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Identifying Behavioral Phenotypes in Chronic Illness: Self-Management of COPD and Comorbid Hypertension

Grace M. Perez-Benzo, Kimberly Muellers, Shiqi Chen, Bian Liu, Emilia Bagiella, Rachel O'Conor, Michael S. Wolf, Juan P. Wisnivesky, Alex D. Federman

Summary: In this study, COPD and hypertension patients were classified into three clusters based on self-management behaviors, with significant differences observed among the clusters in all behaviors except for inhaler technique. Physical activity was found to be the primary distinguishing variable.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2021)

Article Surgery

eHealth literacy and web-based patient portal usage among kidney and liver transplant recipients

Kieran Maroney, Laura M. Curtis, Lauren Opsasnick, Kayla D. Smith, Morgan R. Eifler, Amy Moore, Joel Wedd, Michael S. Wolf, Rachel E. Patzer

Summary: This study found that kidney and liver transplant recipients who routinely use patient portals have higher eHealth literacy scores compared to non-routine users and non-users. The results suggest a positive relationship between routine portal usage and higher eHealth literacy among transplant recipients.

CLINICAL TRANSPLANTATION (2021)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics of Three Different Formulations of Insulin Aspart: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Crossover Study in Men With Type 1 Diabetes

Eva Svehlikova, Ines Mursic, Thomas Augustin, Christoph Magnes, David Gerring, Jan Jezek, Daniela Schwarzenbacher, Maria Ratzer, Michael Wolf, Sarah Howell, Leon Zakrzewski, Martina Urschitz, Bernd Tschapeller, Christina Gatschelhofer, Franz Feichtner, Fiona Lawrence, Thomas R. Pieber

Summary: AT247 exhibited earlier onset, exposure, and offset of insulin compared to IAsp and faster IAsp, leading to enhanced early glucose-lowering effect, making it a promising candidate for improving postprandial glycemic control.

DIABETES CARE (2021)

Letter Geriatrics & Gerontology

Screen-Based Physical Activity Tools: Are the Current Recommendations Causing More Harm Than Good?

Sophia Weiner-Light, Michael S. Wolf

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY (2021)

Article Allergy

Comorbidities and depressive symptoms among older adults with asthma

Irina Mindlis, Juan P. Wisnivesky, Michael S. Wolf, Rachel O'Conor, Alex D. Federman

Summary: Depressive symptoms in older adults with asthma are significantly associated with the overall count of comorbidities, but not with the count of comorbidities with self-management intensive needs. Further evaluation is warranted to understand how comorbid illnesses contribute to depressive symptoms in this population, given the impact of depression on asthma outcomes.

JOURNAL OF ASTHMA (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Health Literacy, Processing Capacity, Illness Knowledge, and Actionable Memory for Medication Taking in Type 2 Diabetes: Cross-Sectional Analysis

Jessie Chin, Huaping Wang, Adam W. Awwad, James F. Graumlich, Michael S. Wolf, Daniel G. Morrow

Summary: This study investigates how patient health literacy, processing capacity, and illness knowledge impact memory for medication purposes among patients with diabetes. The results suggest a relationship between health literacy and processing capacity, as well as health knowledge, with evidence that knowledge can compensate for limited processing capacity. These findings support the process-knowledge model of health literacy.

JOURNAL OF GENERAL INTERNAL MEDICINE (2021)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Transplant regimen adherence for kidney recipients by engaging information technologies (TAKE IT): Rationale and methods for a randomized controlled trial of a strategy to promote medication adherence among transplant recipients

Marina Serper, Daniela P. Ladner, Laura M. Curtis, Sumi S. Nair, Scott Hur, Mary J. Kwasny, Bing Ho, John Friedewald, Peter P. Reese, Michael M. Abecassis, Michael S. Wolf

Summary: The "TAKE IT" strategy aims to monitor and optimize medication adherence among kidney transplant recipients, with the goal of preventing complications resulting from inadequate immunosuppressive medication adherence. The effectiveness and feasibility of this strategy will be evaluated in a patient-randomized controlled trial at two large transplant centers.

CONTEMPORARY CLINICAL TRIALS (2021)

Article Allergy

Patient characteristics associated with retention in an asthma self-management trial for older adults

Dustin Kee, Rachel O'Conor, Juan P. Wisnivesky, Michael S. Wolf, Alex D. Federman

Summary: Concern about non-asthma chronic conditions, but no other illness beliefs or patient characteristics, were associated with retention in an asthma self-management support intervention. Further research is needed to better understand why patients drop out of asthma behavioral intervention studies.

JOURNAL OF ASTHMA (2022)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

Caregiver involvement in managing medications among older adults with multiple chronic conditions

Rachel O'Conor, Morgan Eifler, Andrea M. Russell, Lauren Opsasnick, Marina Arvanitis, Allison Pack, Laura Curtis, Julia Yoshino Benavente, Michael S. Wolf

Summary: Caregivers for older adults with multiple chronic conditions categorized into three types of assistance: Actively Involved, Peripherally Involved, and Not Involved, with a strong preference for autonomy in medication management.

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

A structural equation model of relationships of health literacy, illness and medication beliefs with medication adherence among patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Parul Agarwal, Jenny Lin, Kimberly Muellers, Rachel O'Conor, Michael Wolf, Alex D. Federman, Juan P. Wisnivesky

Summary: In older COPD patients, health literacy and illness and medication beliefs play a role in medication adherence, with medication concerns and necessity mediating the relationship between health literacy and adherence.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2021)

Article Medical Informatics

An Innovative Health Literacy Approach Designed to Improve Patient Understanding of Medication Labeling

Kara L. Jacobson, Juliette Faughnan, Laurie Myers, Amy Dubost, Lisa Courtade, Scott von Lutcken, Christine McCrary Sisk, Suzanne Gregory, Anita Cunningham, Cathryn Gunther, Michael S. Wolf

Summary: This study describes an innovative methodology to optimize user understanding of patient medication labeling by applying evidence-based health literacy principles. The study found that this approach was particularly effective for individuals with limited health literacy.

THERAPEUTIC INNOVATION & REGULATORY SCIENCE (2021)

Article Immunology

COVID-19 Concerns, Vaccine Acceptance and Trusted Sources of Information among Patients Cared for in a Safety-Net Health System

Terry C. Davis, Robbie Beyl, Mohammad A. N. Bhuiyan, Adrienne B. Davis, John A. Vanchiere, Michael S. Wolf, Connie L. Arnold

Summary: This study examined COVID-19 concerns, vaccine acceptance, and trusted information sources among patients in a safety-net health system in Louisiana. The findings showed that participants viewed COVID-19 as a serious threat to public health, with variations among different demographic groups. The majority of participants had received the COVID-19 vaccine, and females were more likely to be vaccinated. Physicians were considered the most trusted source of vaccine information, while social media was the least trusted.

VACCINES (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Remote Cognitive Screening Of Healthy Older Adults for Primary Care With the MyCog Mobile App: Iterative Design and Usability Evaluation

Stephanie Ruth Young, Emily Gardiner Lattie, Andrew B. L. Berry, Lynn Bui, Greg Joseph Byrne, Julia Noelani Yoshino Benavente, Michael Bass, Richard C. Gershon, Michael S. Wolf, Cindy J. Nowinski

Summary: This study described the design and proposed implementation of a remote cognitive screening app called MyCog Mobile, which aims to facilitate cognitive screening before annual wellness visits in primary care settings. The findings suggest that primary care clinicians and clinic administrators are motivated to adopt a remote cognitive screening process if it saves time, and older adult patients are interested in completing screeners on a smartphone, with potential benefits such as time-saving and privacy.

JMIR FORMATIVE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Change in Health Literacy over a Decade in a Prospective Cohort of Community-Dwelling Older Adults

Laura M. Curtis, Mary J. Kwasny, Lauren Opsasnick, Rachel M. O'Conor, Julia Yoshino-Benavente, Morgan Eifler, Alex D. Federman, Drew Altschul, Michael S. Wolf

Summary: A study found a negative relationship between age and health literacy over time, with older adults possibly experiencing declining health literacy as they age, especially when self-care demands increase. Clinicians are recommended to strengthen strategies to assess and respond to limited health literacy, particularly in patients aged 70 and older.

JOURNAL OF GENERAL INTERNAL MEDICINE (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploring health advice by dental professionals in USA: A secondary data analysis of NHANES (2015-2018)

Noora Jawad, Faisal F. Hakeem, Wael Sabbah

Summary: This study aims to examine socioeconomic and ethnic variations in the provision of health advice by dental professionals. The findings indicate the prominent roles of education level, ethnicity, and smoking status in the provision of health advice. The study emphasizes the need for targeted interventions to promote equity and cultural competence in delivering health advice in dental settings.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The 'Kidney' model for optimising feedback in undergraduate clinical communication: A meta-ethnographic systematic review

Katherine Miles, Bernadette O'Neill, Shuangyu Li

Summary: This study conducted a meta-ethnography to identify and synthesize guidance for optimizing feedback interactions in undergraduate clinical communication simulations. The findings led to the development of a new Feedback Kidney Model, which can guide medical education and future research on feedback in promoting learning. Incorporating meta-cognitive training and utilizing the model can help improve students' learning and communication with patients through on-site face-to-face feedback.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Implementing bedside handovers in mental health care: Insights from an experience-based co-design

Ellen Van de Velde, Ann Van Hecke, Kristof Eeckloo, Simon Malfait

Summary: This study investigates the suitability of experience-based co-design as a method for designing bedside handover in mental health care, and finds that it is a suitable method for enhancing patient involvement in nursing handovers in a general hospital's mental healthcare unit.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploring factors to interpretation of targeted nutrition messages for people living with multiple sclerosis

Yasmine Probst, Maddison Luscombe, Marta Hilfischer, Vivienne Guan, Lauren Houston

Summary: This study explores the interpretation of MS-targeted nutrition messages using semi-structured interviews. The findings reveal that dietary changes made by patients with MS after diagnosis are a coping mechanism to address uncertainty, fear of disease progression, and the risk of relapse. The admiration and skepticism towards extremist MS diets depend on individual vulnerability and support from healthcare professionals. The unique MS journey influences the interpretation of the messages, driven by engagement, practicality, and credibility.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Role of digital health communication, sociodemographic factors, and medical conditions on perceived quality of patient-centered communication

Aisha T. Langford, Kerli Orellana, Nancy Buderer, Katerina Andreadis, Stephen K. Williams

Summary: This study examined the associations between digital health, sociodemographic factors, and medical conditions on patient-centered communication (PCC). The results suggested that age, education level, household income, and history of hypertension were related to the quality of PCC.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

'Symptom-free' when inflammatory bowel disease is in remission: Expectations raised by online resources

Danielle Huisman, Taylor Burrows, Louise Sweeney, Kirsty Bannister, Rona Moss-Morris

Summary: This study found limited information on symptoms during remission of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) on readily searchable patient websites, which fails to adequately explain the persistence of symptoms during remission for patients.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Why affiliation matters: A conversation analysis of complaints calls to the NHS

Bethan Benwell, Maria Erofeeva, Catrin S. Rhys

Summary: This study examined how language choices made by call handlers affect the progress of complaint calls and the stance of the callers. The findings showed that displaying affiliation at relevant moments in the conversation helps advance the call and de-escalate the complaint, while the absence or misplacement of affiliation may lead to escalation. Early intervention in establishing affiliation with the caller's concerns and reasoning is crucial for de-escalation.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Race differences in patient trust and distrust from audio-recorded cardiology encounters

Sarah V. Hantzmon, Clemontina A. Davenport, Maya N. Das Gupta, Temi A. Adekunle, Sarah E. Gaither, Maren K. Olsen, Sandro O. Pinheiro, Kimberly S. Johnson, Hannah Mahoney, Allison Falls, Lauren Lloyd, Kathryn I. Pollak

Summary: This study examined the impact of racial differences on patient trust and distrust in physician-patient interactions through audio-recorded cardiologist-patient encounters. The results showed that Black patients had lower expressions of trust and a higher level of guardedness compared to White patients. It suggests that White clinicians can improve communication with Black patients to increase expressions of trust.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Youth perspectives on mobile health adherence interventions: A qualitative study guided by the supportive accountability model

Caitlin S. Sayegh, Ellen Iverson, Karen K. Macdonell, Shinyi Wu, Marvin Belzer

Summary: This study applied a Supportive Accountability Model to examine youth's perception of remote human coaching and automated reminders for medication adherence. The findings indicated that both coaching and automated reminders were effective in improving adherence, with coaching being viewed as more potent and engaging. Phone calls enhanced the sense of supportive accountability, but texts were more convenient and flexible. Individual preferences varied.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Conversation starters: Understanding the facilitators and barriers to physician-initiated secure firearm storage conversations

Jennifer Necci Dineen, Mitchell Doucette, Mekaila Carey, Kerri M. Raissian

Summary: This paper aims to understand the facilitators and barriers perceived by general practice physicians in initiating anticipatory guidance around firearm safety. Qualitative interviews were conducted with 18 GPs to explore their perspectives. Barriers to providing secure firearm storage counseling include inadequate screening mechanisms, limited understanding of who is at risk for firearm injury, time pressures, concerns about patient receptivity, and a need for training. Structural issues need to be addressed before focusing on how to have conversations about firearm safety.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The use of outcome data in patient consultations from the healthcare professionals' and patients' perspectives: A mixed methods study

Henrike J. Westerink, Cato C. Bresser, Mirjam M. Garvelink, Cornelia F. van Udenkraan, Ouisam Zouitni, Hans A. J. Bart, Philip J. van der Wees, Paul B. van der Nat

Summary: This study aims to explore the perspectives and needs of healthcare professionals (HCPs) and patients regarding the use of outcome data in consultations. The findings indicate that HCPs do not routinely use aggregated outcome data in consultations due to various barriers. Patients, however, consider aggregated outcome data important but have different preferences based on their health conditions.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Co-facilitation to foster equity in codesign: Mechanisms underpinning practice

Bronwyn Newman, Mashreka Sarwar, Ashfaq Chauhan, Reema Harrison

Summary: Co-facilitation presents an opportunity to address inequity in codesign, and through our experiences in the CanEngage project, we have identified three mechanisms to promote equity.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Group-based patient education via videoconference: A scoping review

Andre Vaagan, Mette Haaland-Overby, Alison Axisa Eriksen, Kari Fredriksen, Vibeke Stenov, Cecilie Varsi, Brynja Ingadottir, Bryan Richard Cleal, Anita Royneberg Alvheim, Karl Fredrik Westermann, Hilde Stromme, Olof Birna Kristjansdottir

Summary: This study summarizes the recent evidence on the feasibility, acceptability, and effectiveness of videoconference group-based patient and caregiver education. The results suggest that this education approach is highly feasible and acceptable, and may improve health outcomes for participants. However, the evidence of effectiveness is limited and the quality of studies varies. Further research is needed to establish the effectiveness of this education approach for different patient and caregiver groups.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Conversation topics in psychiatric consultations conducted with and without a shared decision-making tool: A qualitative content analysis

Momoka Igarashi, Takayuki Kawaguchi, Takuma Shiozawa, Sosei Yamaguchi

Summary: The study aims to identify conversation topics, who initiated the topics, and differences in topics with and without the use of a shared decision-making (SDM) tool in psychiatric outpatient consultations. The findings show that daily life issues, especially related to work, were the main topics discussed, and the SDM tool seems to facilitate discussion of patients' concerns.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

What's after COVID-19?: Communication pathways influencing future use of telehealth

Qiwei Luna Wu, Grace Ellen Brannon

Summary: This study explores how patient-centered communication, media, and organizational factors influence patients' intentions to use telehealth. The findings suggest that positive healthcare experiences, organizational support, and quality media designs are associated with telehealth adoption.

PATIENT EDUCATION AND COUNSELING (2024)