4.7 Article

Implementing integrated coastal management in a sector-based governance system

Journal

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT
Volume 67, Issue -, Pages 39-53

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2012.06.003

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Over the last four decades the development of frameworks for integrated coastal management (ICM) and models for ICM implementation have received much attention from researchers and practitioners alike. This has resulted in a proliferation of implementation models, many of which embody results-based approaches, with the primary focus being on identifying coastal issues and then addressing these by implementing specific projects or programmes. Despite explicitly recognising the importance of cooperative governance early on. ICM implementation still faces the challenge that governance systems remain largely sector-based. In this paper we explore the implementation of ICM within a sector-based governance system in South Africa. First, we draw on international best practice and situated knowledge to develop a prototype ICM implementation model designed to accommodate sector-based programmes within an overarching ecosystem-based approach. Next, we assess the usability of the prototype and the compatibility with a sector-based governance system using empirical information derived from South Africa's National Programme of Action to protect the marine environment from land-based activities. We conclude that integrated management of the coast is possible in a sector-based governance system and propose the ICM implementation model developed in this paper as a potentially suitable model for countries with similar coastal management milieus to South Africa. (C) 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Civil

May the Odds Be in Your Favor: Why Many Attempts to Reoperate Dams for the Environment Stall

Afua Owusu, Marloes Mul, Pieter van der Zaag, Jill Slinger

Summary: This study explores the impasse narrative of dam reoperation for e-flows implementation and presents four hypotheses for further research. These hypotheses include the supportive role of scientists, reaching consensus with local stakeholders, the enabling environment provided by local legislation and policy, and the potential of consultations and negotiations to overcome obstacles.

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Oceanography

The 'Research for Policy' cycle in Dutch coastal flood risk management: The Coastal Genesis 2 research programme

Quirijn Lodder, Jill Slinger

Summary: This paper describes the development of the Coastal Genesis 2 research programme and its contribution to Dutch coastal policy. It addresses the organization of policy development related to coastal flood risk and erosion in the Netherlands, focusing on the division of responsibilities between the policy and operational directorates of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management. The paper details the conceptual model of the long term sediment budget of the Dutch coast that supports the current Coastal Flood and Erosion Risk Management policy.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

The clam and the dam: A Bayesian belief network approach to environmental flow assessment in a data scarce region

Afua Owusu, Marloes Mul, Michael Strauch, Pieter van der Zaag, Martin Volk, Jill Slinger

Summary: This study explores a designer e-flow approach using the Volta clam as an indicator species, visualizing and quantifying the factors influencing its extent in a Bayesian belief network. The study recommends low flows and annual breaching of the sandbar at the Volta Estuary during specific life stages of the Volta clam. The results demonstrate the potential suitability of a BBN for modeling the linkages between flows, management practices, and ecological indicators for the development of e-flows in data-scarce regions.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

Editorial

Neville Sweijd, Jill Slinger

ENVIRONMENTAL DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Including local knowledge in coastal policy innovation: comparing three Dutch case studies

Floortje M. d'Hont, Jill H. Slinger

Summary: This study compares three collaborative activities aimed at finding innovative coastal policy solutions and finds that local knowledge can support solutions tailored to specific areas. However, integrating high-quality professional inputs into solutions based on local knowledge still poses challenges.

LOCAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Dispersal and coastal geomorphology limit potential for mangrove range expansion under climate change

Jacqueline L. Raw, Tom Van der Stocken, Dustin Carroll, Linda R. Harris, Anusha Rajkaran, Lara Van Niekerk, Janine B. Adams

Summary: This study shows that dispersal limits the distribution of mangroves at the southern African range limit. Under future climate scenarios, 30% of estuaries currently supporting mangroves are predicted to become unsuitable, while six new estuaries beyond the current distribution are predicted to become suitable. There is limited connectivity between these new sites and established forests.

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Implications of the breakdown in the indigenous knowledge system for rangeland management and policy: a case study from the Eastern Cape in South Africa

Andiswa Finca, Suzanne Linnane, Jill Slinger, David Getty, M. Igshaan Samuels

Summary: This study assesses the role of indigenous knowledge in communal rangeland management, explores solutions to incorporate indigenous knowledge into effective land use policies, and evaluates mechanisms for generational transfer of this knowledge. Findings reveal that communal farmers have in-depth knowledge of their land and rangeland management strategies, but the breakdown in the indigenous knowledge system hinders its translation into good management practices. New policy approaches involving local participation are needed.

AFRICAN JOURNAL OF RANGE & FORAGE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Oceanography

The Coastal Genesis 2 research programme: Outputs, Outcomes and Impact

Q. J. Lodder, J. H. Slinger, Z. B. Wang, A. J. F. van der Spek, M. P. Hijma, M. Taal, C. van Gelder-Maas, H. de Loofler, J. Litjens, C. A. Schipper, M. Loffler, A. J. Nolte, C. van Oeveren, J. J. van der Werf, B. T. Grasmeijer, E. P. L. Elias, H. Holzhauer, P. K. Tonnon

Summary: The long-term sediment demand of the Dutch coast is important for the current Dutch Coastal Flood and Erosion Risk Management policy. The Coastal Genesis 2 research programme was initiated to address the sustainability of this policy under sea level rise by focusing on key uncertainties in the conceptual model of the sediment demand. The analysis of this programme's scientific contributions highlights the importance of synthesising new insights into shared conceptual models for impact in policy and practice.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Oceanography

Developing a long-term management strategy to prepare the Dutch coast for the future, editorial of the VSI future Dutch coast

Zheng Bing Wang, Quirijn J. Lodder, Ad J. F. Van der Spek, Jill H. Slinger, Piet Hoekstra

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Water Releases From Dams Improve Ecological Health and Societal Benefits in Downstream Estuaries

Janine B. Adams, Susan Taljaard, Lara Van Niekerk

Summary: This review study investigated the response of low-inflow estuaries (LIEs) to dam releases and found that successful releases can improve ecological health, estuary function, and provide societal benefits. Baseflow inputs and flow pulse releases were important for maintaining estuary water quality gradients and stimulating fish spawning migrations. Holistic and adaptive restoration approaches, as well as community engagement and cooperation between agencies, were key factors for success. However, the management solution for LIEs is threatened by water abstraction, over allocation, competing water uses, and droughts.

ESTUARIES AND COASTS (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Developing the transboundary Long Term Vision of the Scheldt Estuary - an untold story

Jill H. Slinger

Summary: The development of the bilateral Long Term Vision for the Scheldt Estuary between 1999 and 2001 demonstrates the possibility of transitioning from a history of conflict to cooperation in just two years. Through retrospective analysis of the integrated three-layer hybrid modelling, we explore the collaborative eco-morphological modelling activity that served as a boundary object, enhancing communication and contributing to a model-based understanding of the estuary's intrinsic character.

WATER INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Advancing ecosystem accounting in estuaries: Swartkops Estuary case study

Susan Taljaard, Lara van Niekerk, Janine B. Adams, Taryn Riddin

Summary: The study applies the ecosystem accounting approach at the individual estuary level for the first time. Spatially explicit information on ecosystem assets and their services is provided to support resource management. Physical accounts include extent and condition, as well as ecosystem service and pressure accounts. These accounts inform estuary management and restoration at the local governance level.

SOUTH AFRICAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Quantifying the trade-offs in re-operating dams for the environment in the Lower Volta River

Afua Owusu, Jazmin Zatarain Salazar, Marloes Mul, Pieter van der Zaag, Jill Slinger

Summary: The construction of the Akosombo and Kpong dams in Ghana had negative impacts on the downstream riverine ecosystem and the livelihoods of affected communities. Despite this, Ghana benefited economically from hydropower, irrigation, and lake tourism. The study explores trade-offs between water for river ecosystems and human water demands using a policy search method, and suggests opportunities for compromise and strategic provision of environmental flows in the Lower Volta River.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

An indicator-based approach for cross-realm coastal biodiversity assessments

L. R. Harris, A. L. Skowno, K. J. Sink, L. van Niekerk, S. D. Holness, M. Monyeki, P. Majiedt

Summary: This study is the first cross-realm national biodiversity assessment for the South African coast, comparing coastal and non-coastal ecosystem types using three key indicators. The results show that the ecological condition and threat status of coastal ecosystems are higher, but the protection level is relatively good.

AFRICAN JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Investigating the interaction of waves and river discharge during compound flooding at Breede Estuary, South Africa

Sunna Kupfer, Sara Santamaria-Aguilar, Lara van Niekerk, Melanie Luck-Vogel, Athanasios T. Vafeidis

Summary: Recent studies have highlighted the significant dependencies between flood drivers and compound flood events in coastal areas. This study investigates compound flooding from tides, river discharge, and waves at the Breede Estuary in South Africa. The research finds that flood characteristics are more sensitive to river discharge than waves, but waves contribute significantly when interacting with river discharge.

NATURAL HAZARDS AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

Article Oceanography

Ecological impacts of dam construction on epilithic diatom communities in estuaries: A case study of the Korean peninsula

Ha-Kyung Kim, In-Hwan Cho, Eun-A Hwang, Young-Hyo Kim, Jeong-Suk Moon, Bae-Kyung Park, Baik-Ho Kim

Summary: This study investigated the distribution of diatoms in 324 estuaries on the Korean Peninsula from 2016 to 2018, with a focus on the ecological impact of artificial dams. The results highlighted the complex interactions between dams, land use, and diatom communities, providing important data for ecosystem management and biodiversity conservation. Understanding the consequences of artificial dams on diatom distribution is crucial for preserving estuarine health.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

The impact of new western land and sea corridor development on port deep hinterland transport service and route selection

Tianhang Gao, Jia Tian, Chuan Huang, Hongyu Wu, Xing Xu, Changjian Liu

Summary: This study explores the microcontainer transport service and route selection problem within the context of a new transportation corridor. A multiobjective planning model is established to minimize transportation cost, time, and carbon emissions. The findings demonstrate that the New Western Land and Sea Corridor is appealing for time-sensitive cargoes and can enhance economic benefits with supportive policies.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Dynamic relationship between marine fisheries economic development, environmental protection and fisheries technological Progress-A case of coastal provinces in China

Jintao Ma, Zhengjie Wu, Mengqian Guo, Qiuguang Hu

Summary: With the deepening of economic globalization and regional economic integration, marine fisheries are becoming increasingly connected to national strategic interests and economic vitality. It is necessary to explore the synergistic evolution of marine fisheries economic development, environmental protection, and technological progress in order to promote sustainable and healthy development of marine fisheries.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Evolution of marine ecology-industry symbiosis patterns and ecological security assessment: New evidence from coastal areas of China

Wenhan Ren, Yuhan Xu, Jing Ni

Summary: This paper focuses on the key role of human economic activities in the evolution of ecological security from the perspective of eco-industrial symbiosis and constructs a symbiotic system of indicators considering human economic activities and all subsystems. The research findings reveal that in China's coastal areas, the socio-economic development index shows a stable upward trend, the environmental capacity index remains stable, and the ecological impact index shows a fluctuating and undulating trend.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Spatial risk assessment of maritime transportation in offshore waters of China using machine learning and geospatial big data

Xiao Zhou

Summary: This study develops a spatial risk assessment approach for maritime transportation in China using machine learning and geospatial big data. The study identifies wave height, rainfall, and sea surface temperature as the most influential factors affecting navigational safety. It also analyzes the matching relationship between coastal search and rescue resources and maritime transportation risks.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Review Oceanography

Review of risk assessment for navigational safety and supported decisions in arctic waters

X. Yang, Z. Y. Lin, W. J. Zhang, S. Xu, M. Y. Zhang, Z. D. Wu, B. Han

Summary: The study highlights the increasing importance of Arctic navigation safety and identifies gaps in the application of risk assessment methodologies. It calls for decision-oriented modelling techniques and bridging the gap between academic research and practical application.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Potential challenges for the restoration of Biscayne Bay (Florida, USA) in the face of climate change effects revealed with predictive models

Vladimir J. Alarcon, Anna C. Linhoss, Christopher R. Kelble, Paul F. Mickle, Alexandra Fine, Enrique Montes

Summary: Estuaries and coastal areas are undergoing rapid changes due to climate change and sea level rise. This research presents a salinity transport model for Biscayne Bay and investigates the potential impacts of altered precipitation, increased salinity/temperature, and sea level rise on bay salinity. The findings suggest that current restoration plans may not be sufficient to maintain current salinity conditions, and management measures such as urban greening, artificial groundwater recharge, and water consumption reduction should be considered.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

A method to establish marine bio-regions in the pelagic ecosystem based on phytoplanktonic communities. Aplication to the southern Spanish coast

Manuel Vargas-Yanez, Ana Reeves-Bueno, Sara Fernandez-Topham, Francina Moya, Enrique Ballesteros, Cristina Alonso, Teresa Perez-Sanchez, Patricia Romero-Fernandez, Silvia Sanchez-Aguado, Ricardo Felix Sanchez-Leal, M. Carmen Garcia-Martinez

Summary: This study analyzed the phytoplankton communities in the upper 100 m of the Gulf of Cadiz and the Alboran Sea using time series data. The results show that these two regions can be considered as two differentiated bioregions, with the latter having higher productivity.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Spatiotemporal fishing effort simulations and restriction scenarios in Thermaikos Gulf, Greece (northeastern Mediterranean Sea)

Donna Dimarchopoulou, Ioannis Keramidas, Konstantinos Tsagarakis, Vasiliki Markantonatou, Ghassen Halouani, Athanassios C. Tsikliras

Summary: The study shows that spatiotemporal simulation modeling is an effective tool for investigating management options in ecosystem-based fisheries management. It demonstrates that fisheries restricted areas can help rebuild the biomass of exploited stocks, but their effectiveness depends on the size and location of the areas. The study also suggests that a parallel reduction in total fishing effort is necessary to achieve the highest benefits of protection.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

One mesh does not fit all: A dual compartment codend provides flexible selectivity opportunities to manage mixed fisheries

Junita D. Karlsen, Ludvig Ahm Krag, Bent Herrmann

Summary: Fisheries management is transitioning from a single-species approach to an ecosystem-based approach to address the complexities of mixed-species fisheries. A dual compartment codend concept can provide a complex selectivity profile and allow for flexible adjustments at sea, improving compliance with management objectives.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

A comparative study on the measurement of sustainable development of marine fisheries in China

Yi-Zhuo Zhang, Cheng Xue, Na Wang, Gang Chen

Summary: This paper evaluates typical coastal provinces and cities in China, constructing an evaluation indicator system and clarifying the regional differences in the sustainable development capacity of China's marine fisheries industry. The results show that Shandong Province and Fujian Province have advantages in sustainable development, while Tianjin, Hebei Province, and Shanghai have room for improvement.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Yard space allocation of container port based on dual cycle strategy

Caimao Tan, Tiantian Qin, Junliang He, Yu Wang, Hang Yu

Summary: This study addresses the storage space allocation problem of container yards based on the dual-cycle operation mode. A mixed integer programming model is established to optimize container transportation distance. The results show that dual-cycle operation can decrease transportation distance and the space allocation method based on it is more effective than traditional methods. The study also provides management insights for container ports and suggests effective solutions for bottleneck problems.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Setting the stage for decision-making on nature-based solutions for coastal climate adaptation

Haye H. Geukes, Peter M. van Bodegom, Alexander P. E. van Oudenhoven

Summary: This study aims to identify and explore the information requirements at different stages of the decision-making process of coastal nature-based solutions (NbS). The study found substantial differences in information requirements across the decision-making stages, with values and indicators becoming more specific and concrete as the stages progressed. The study also suggests that future changes in the information required for decision-making on coastal NbS can be anticipated and prepared for.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)