4.5 Article

Revealing and quantifying the impaired phonological analysis underpinning impaired comprehension in Wernicke's aphasia

Journal

NEUROPSYCHOLOGIA
Volume 50, Issue 2, Pages 276-288

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2011.11.022

Keywords

Wernicke's Aphasia; Comprehension; Phonology; Semantics; Auditory discrimination

Funding

  1. Stroke Association [TSAB2008/01]
  2. MRC [G0501632, MR/J004146/1]
  3. Medical Research Council [G0501632, MR/J004146/1] Funding Source: researchfish
  4. MRC [MR/J004146/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Wernicke's aphasia is a condition which results in severely disrupted language comprehension following a lesion to the left temporo-parietal region. A phonological analysis deficit has traditionally been held to be at the root of the comprehension impairment in Wernicke's aphasia, a view consistent with current functional neuroimaging which finds areas in the superior temporal cortex responsive to phonological stimuli. However behavioural evidence to support the link between a phonological analysis deficit and auditory comprehension has not been yet shown. This study extends seminal work by Blumstein. Baker, and Goodglass (1977) to investigate the relationship between acoustic-phonological perception, measured through phonological discrimination, and auditory comprehension in a case series of Wernicke's aphasia participants. A novel adaptive phonological discrimination task was used to obtain reliable thresholds of the phonological perceptual distance required between nonwords before they could be discriminated. Wernicke's aphasia participants showed significantly elevated thresholds compared to age and hearing matched control participants. Acoustic-phonological thresholds correlated strongly with auditory comprehension abilities in Wernicke's aphasia. In contrast, nonverbal semantic skills showed no relationship with auditory comprehension. The results are evaluated in the context of recent neurobiological models of language and suggest that impaired acoustic-phonological perception underlies the comprehension impairment in Wernicke's aphasia and favour models of language which propose a leftward asymmetry in phonological analysis. (C) 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Neurosciences

Bipartite functional fractionation within the neural system for social cognition supports the psychological continuity of self versus other

Rocco Chiou, Christopher R. Cox, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph

Summary: Research in social neuroscience has shown that the default-mode network (DN) and semantic network (SN) in the brain play a significant role in socio-cognitive tasks. The study integrates these two areas of research and investigates how these networks encode social concepts, using self versus other as a test case. The findings reveal differences between DN and SN in encoding social categories and highlight the DN's role in representing the distinction between self and other.

CEREBRAL CORTEX (2023)

Article Neurosciences

Distinct but cooperating brain networks supporting semantic cognition

JeYoung Jung, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph

Summary: Semantic cognition is a complex brain function involving multiple processes. This study used independent component analysis to investigate the brain networks that support semantic cognition. The results revealed task-specific and domain-general networks that are crucial for effective semantic cognition.

CEREBRAL CORTEX (2023)

Article Neurosciences

A middle ground where executive control meets semantics: the neural substrates of semantic control are topographically sandwiched between the multiple-demand and default-mode systems

Rocco Chiou, Elizabeth Jefferies, John Duncan, Gina F. Humphreys, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph

Summary: This study investigates the topographical relationship between semantic control areas and the default-mode network and multiple-demand network. The results show that semantic control regions are located in between the default-mode and multi-demand networks, and exhibit hybrid functional responses, indicating a specific preference for difficult operation on meaningful representations.

CEREBRAL CORTEX (2023)

Article Neurosciences

The cross-domain functional organization of posterior lateral temporal cortex: insights from ALE meta-analyses of 7 cognitive domains spanning 12,000 participants

Victoria J. Hodgson, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, Rebecca L. Jackson

Summary: The posterior lateral temporal cortex is involved in various verbal, nonverbal, and social cognitive domains. Through comparing different domains, it is found that some processes engage distinct subregions while others may engage shared neural correlates and processes.

CEREBRAL CORTEX (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Using in vivo functional and structural connectivity to predict chronic stroke aphasia deficits

Ying Zhao, Christopher R. Cox, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, Ajay D. Halai

Summary: Zhao et al. used in vivo structural and functional connectivity to predict various cognitive functions in patients with aphasia. While both types of connectivity can predict these functions, they do not provide additional information beyond the model using lesion information. The results suggest that network-level disorder predicted by lesion alone is sufficient in explaining language impairment.

BRAIN (2023)

Letter Clinical Neurology

Reply: Are recovery of fluency and recovery of phonology antagonistic?

Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, James D. Stefaniak, Ajay D. Halai, Fatemeh Geranmayeh

BRAIN (2023)

Article Behavioral Sciences

Colour perception deficits after posterior stroke: Not so rare after all?

Amalie H. Munk, Elisabeth B. Starup, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, Alex P. Leff, Randi Starrfelt, Ro J. Robotham

Summary: Cerebral achromatopsia is a rare acquired color perception impairment caused by brain injury, with most cases involving bilateral or right hemisphere lesions. It differs from congenital color blindness by affecting perception of all colors. A study on stroke patients with posterior cerebral artery involvement found that 22% of patients showed significant color discrimination problems, with bilateral lesions associated with more severe impairments.

CORTEX (2023)

Article Neurosciences

Distance-dependent distribution thresholding in probabilistic tractography

Ya-Ning Chang, Ajay D. D. Halai, Matthew A. A. Lambon Ralph

Summary: Tractography is widely used in studying human brain connectivity, but the issue of systematically thresholding and comparing connectivity values for different track lengths across studies remains unsolved. This study utilized Monte Carlo derived distance-dependent distributions (DDDs) to generate thresholds for connections of varying lengths. The approach was applied to generate a language connectome, which showed expected structural connectivity. The findings demonstrate the feasibility and applicability of the DDD approach for thresholding probabilistic tracking datasets.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2023)

Article Linguistics

Hippocampal adaptations in Mild Cognitive Impairment patients are modulated by bilingual language experiences

Toms Voits, Jason Rothman, Marco Calabria, Holly Robson, Naiara Aguirre, Gabriele Cattaneo, Victor Costumero, Mireia Hernandez, Montserrat Juncadella Puig, Lidon Marin-Marin, Anna Suades, Albert Costa, Christos Pliatsikas

Summary: Bilingualism has been found to increase resilience against cognitive aging, but its effects on neurocognitive outcomes in individuals with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) are still unclear. This study examines the impact of bilingual language experience on structural brain data in a cohort of bilinguals diagnosed with MCI. The results indicate a non-linear relationship between bilingual language entropy and hippocampal volume, although no significant effect on episodic memory performance or age of MCI diagnosis was found.

BILINGUALISM-LANGUAGE AND COGNITION (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Verbal fluency tests assess global cognitive status but have limited diagnostic differentiation: evidence from a large-scale examination of six neurodegenerative diseases

Shalom K. Henderson, Katie A. Peterson, Karalyn Patterson, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, James B. Rowe

Summary: Verbal fluency is widely used as a clinical test, but its utility in differentiating between different types of dementia and primary progressive aphasia remains unclear. This study found that total word count was the strongest discriminator between patient groups and controls, while word frequency was the strongest discriminator for semantic variant of primary progressive aphasia. Overall, verbal fluency is an efficient test for assessing global brain-cognitive health but has limited utility in differentiating between cognitively and anatomically disparate patient groups.

BRAIN COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Editorial Material Audiology & Speech-Language Pathology

Designing remote synchronous auditory comprehension assessment for severely impaired individuals with aphasia

Holly Robson, Harriet Thomasson, Matthew H. Davis

Summary: The use of telepractice in aphasia research and therapy is increasing, but language comprehension assessments are not always easily translated to an online environment. This project aimed to develop teleassessments for individuals with language comprehension impairments, and found that people with aphasia can engage in teleassessment with limited carer support.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LANGUAGE & COMMUNICATION DISORDERS (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

The cognitive and neural underpinnings of discourse coherence in post-stroke aphasia

Reem S. W. Alyahya, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, Ajay Halai, Paul Hoffman

Summary: This study investigated the cognitive and neural processes involved in discourse coherence in post-stroke aphasia patients. The results showed that impairment in core language components, such as phonological production, fluency, and semantic processing, was related to reduced discourse coherence. The voxel-based lesion-symptom mapping revealed the contribution of the left prefrontal cortex, particularly the inferior frontal gyrus (pars triangularis), to maintaining discourse coherence.

BRAIN COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

Assessing executive functions in post-stroke aphasia-utility of verbally based tests

Rahel Schumacher, Ajay D. Halai, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph

Summary: It is increasingly acknowledged that patients with post-stroke aphasia not only have language impairments, but also deficits in other cognitive domains. This study aimed to explore the performance of patients with aphasia in verbal executive tests, and its relationship with language tests and nonverbal cognitive functions. The study found that the performance in verbal executive tests was related not only to the severity of language impairment, but also to independent behavioral principal components. Additionally, different components were associated with separate neural correlates.

BRAIN COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

A 'Mini Linguistic State Examination' to classify primary progressive aphasia

Nikil Patel, Katie A. Peterson, Ruth U. Ingram, Ian Storey, Stefano F. Cappa, Eleonora Catricala, Ajay Halai, Karalyn E. Patterson, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, James B. Rowe, Peter Garrard

Summary: Patel et al. present a new cognitive test called the Mini Linguistic State Examination for classifying primary progressive aphasia and characterizing language deficits in other brain disorders. The test is brief, accurate, and reproducible, and can be used in various clinical settings to profile language disorders. By adopting a novel assessment method, the test enables clinicians to assess and subclassify different presentations of primary progressive aphasia. The test has high diagnostic accuracy and will have a decisive impact on clinical descriptions of patients and screening for future therapeutic trials.

BRAIN COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Psychology, Mathematical

Semantic diversity is best measured with unscaled vectors: Reply to Cevoli, Watkins and Rastle (2020)

Paul Hoffman, Matthew A. Lambon Ralph, Timothy T. Rogers

Summary: The article discusses the measurement and results of semantic diversity, suggesting that using unscaled vectors can better fit human semantic judgments compared to scaled ones. The authors argue that the original semantic diversity measure should be preferred over other versions.

BEHAVIOR RESEARCH METHODS (2022)

No Data Available