4.5 Review

Constraints from Comets on the Formation and Volatile Acquisition of the Planets and Satellites

Journal

SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS
Volume 197, Issue 1-4, Pages 297-342

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11214-015-0161-z

Keywords

Solar system formation; Comets; Atmospheres; Giant planets; Terrestrial planets; Moon formation

Funding

  1. JPL [1345493]
  2. NASA [NNX13AQ99G]
  3. CNES
  4. A*MIDEX project - Investissements d'Avenir French Government program [ANR-11-IDEX-0001-02]
  5. National Aeronautics and Space Administration
  6. NASA/Origins of Solar Systems program
  7. European Research Council [267255]
  8. NASA [NNX13AQ99G, 464448] Funding Source: Federal RePORTER

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Comets play a dual role in understanding the formation and evolution of the solar system. First, the composition of comets provides information about the origin of the giant planets and their moons because comets formed early and their composition is not expected to have evolved significantly since formation. They, therefore serve as a record of conditions during the early stages of solar system formation. Once comets had formed, their orbits were perturbed allowing them to travel into the inner solar system and impact the planets. In this way they contributed to the volatile inventory of planetary atmospheres. We review here how knowledge of comet composition up to the time of the Rosetta mission has contributed to understanding the formation processes of the giant planets, their moons and small icy bodies in the solar system. We also discuss how comets contributed to the volatile inventories of the giant and terrestrial planets.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

In Situ exploration of the giant planets

O. Mousis, D. H. Atkinson, R. Ambrosi, S. Atreya, D. Banfield, S. Barabash, M. Blanc, T. Cavalie, A. Coustenis, M. Deleuil, G. Durry, F. Ferri, L. N. Fletcher, T. Fouchet, T. Guillot, P. Hartogh, R. Hueso, M. Hofstadter, J. -P. Lebreton, K. E. Mandt, H. Rauer, P. Rannou, J. -b. Renard, A. Sanchez-Lavega, K. M. Sayanagi, A. A. Simon, T. Spilker, E. Venkatapathy, J. H. Waite, P. Wurz

Summary: Remote sensing observations have limitations when studying the atmospheric composition of giant planets in our Solar System, impacting our understanding of their formation and atmospheres. In situ probe measurements, like those by the Galileo probe on Jupiter, provide crucial data on noble gas abundances and helium mixing ratios. Future in situ exploration of Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune aims to address scientific goals related to planetary formation history and atmospheric processes, with the potential for significant contributions to future NASA missions.

EXPERIMENTAL ASTRONOMY (2022)

Review Geochemistry & Geophysics

Volatile interactions with the lunar surface

Paul G. Lucey, Noah Petro, Dana M. Hurley, William M. Farrell, Parvathy Prem, Emily S. Costello, Morgan L. Cable, Michael K. Barker, Mehdi Benna, M. Darby Dyar, Elizabeth A. Fisher, Robert O. Green, Paul O. Hayne, Karl Hibbitts, Casey Honniball, Shuai Li, Erick Malaret, Kathy Mandt, Erwan Mazarico, Molly McCanta, Carle Pieters, Xiaoli Sun, David Thompson, Thomas Orlando

Summary: The Moon is generally lacking volatile elements, including water. Recent discoveries have revealed a more complex volatile environment than previously believed, with unexpected chemical reactions and issues regarding volatile transport.

GEOCHEMISTRY (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Science goals and new mission concepts for future exploration of Titan's atmosphere, geology and habitability: titan POlar scout/orbitEr and in situ lake lander and DrONe explorer (POSEIDON)

Sebastien Rodriguez, Sandrine Vinatier, Daniel Cordier, Gabriel Tobie, Richard K. Achterberg, Carrie M. Anderson, Sarah Badman, Jason W. Barnes, Erika L. Barth, Bruno Bezard, Nathalie Carrasco, Benjamin Charnay, Roger N. Clark, Patrice Coll, Thomas Cornet, Athena Coustenis, Isabelle Couturier-Tamburelli, Michel Dobrijevic, F. Michael Flasar, Remco de Kok, Caroline Freissinet, Marina Galand, Thomas Gautier, Wolf D. Geppert, Caitlin A. Griffith, Murthy S. Gudipati, Lina Z. Hadid, Alexander G. Hayes, Amanda R. Hendrix, Ralf Jaumann, Donald E. Jennings, Antoine Jolly, Klara Kalousova, Tommi T. Koskinen, Panayotis Lavvas, Sebastien Lebonnois, Jean-Pierre Lebreton, Alice Le Gall, Emmanuel Lellouch, Stephane Le Mouelic, Rosaly M. C. Lopes, Juan M. Lora, Ralph D. Lorenz, Antoine Lucas, Shannon MacKenzie, Michael J. Malaska, Kathleen Mandt, Marco Mastrogiuseppe, Claire E. Newman, Conor A. Nixon, Jani Radebaugh, Scot C. Rafkin, Pascal Rannou, Ella M. Sciamma-O'Brien, Jason M. Soderblom, Anezina Solomonidou, Christophe Sotin, Katrin Stephan, Darrell Strobel, Cyril Szopa, Nicholas A. Teanby, Elizabeth P. Turtle, Veronique Vuitton, Robert A. West

Summary: In response to ESA's Voyage 2050 announcement, the proposed POSEIDON mission aims to explore Saturn's largest moon, Titan, through joint orbital and in situ investigations. The mission aims to exceed the accomplishments of the Cassini-Huygens mission and explore Titan's northern latitudes in complement with NASA's upcoming Dragonfly mission. The ideal arrival time at Titan would be slightly before the next northern Spring equinox in 2039.

EXPERIMENTAL ASTRONOMY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Exogenic origin for the volatiles sampled by the Lunar CRater Observation and Sensing Satellite impact

K. E. Mandt, O. Mousis, D. Hurley, A. Bouquet, K. D. Retherford, L. O. Magana, A. Luspay-Kuti

Summary: Returning humans to the Moon offers a unique opportunity to study the origin of volatiles in the permanently shaded regions (PSRs). The source of these volatiles, sampled by the LCROSS mission, is likely cometary impacts and not volcanic outgassing. This suggests that volatiles in the top 1-3 meters of the Cabeus PSR regolith could be younger than the most recent volcanic outgassing event.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Hierarchical Bayesian Atmospheric Retrieval Modeling for Population Studies of Exoplanet Atmospheres: A Case Study on the Habitable Zone

Jacob Lustig-Yaeger, Kristin S. Sotzen, Kevin B. Stevenson, Rodrigo Luger, Erin M. May, L. C. Mayorga, Kathleen Mandt, Noam R. Izenberg

Summary: In this work, a Hierarchical Bayesian Atmospheric Retrieval (HBAR) model is developed to infer population-level trends in exoplanet atmospheric characteristics. Using simulated observations and JWST-quality observations, the study finds that CO2 causes subtle differences in the spectra, and the HBAR model is capable of inferring population-level parameters and rejecting other trends with high confidence.

ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

The first dedicated ice giants mission

Kathleen E. Mandt

SCIENCE (2023)

Review Astronomy & Astrophysics

Future Exploration of the Outer Heliosphere and Very Local Interstellar Medium by Interstellar Probe

P. C. Brandt, E. Provornikova, S. D. Bale, A. Cocoros, R. DeMajistre, K. Dialynas, H. A. Elliott, S. Eriksson, B. Fields, A. Galli, M. E. Hill, M. Horanyi, T. Horbury, S. Hunziker, P. Kollmann, J. Kinnison, G. Fountain, S. M. Krimigis, W. S. Kurth, J. Linsky, C. M. Lisse, K. E. Mandt, W. Magnes, R. L. McNutt, J. Miller, E. Moebius, P. Mostafavi, M. Opher, L. Paxton, F. Plaschke, A. R. Poppe, E. C. Roelof, K. Runyon, S. Redfield, N. Schwadron, V. Sterken, P. Swaczyna, J. Szalay, D. Turner, H. Vannier, R. Wimmer-Schweingruber, P. Wurz, E. J. Zirnstein

Summary: This article provides a detailed overview of the knowledge gaps in our understanding of the interaction between the heliosphere and the largely unexplored Very Local Interstellar Medium (VLISM), as well as predictions of potential scientific discoveries in this field. The article discusses the new measurements needed to make progress in space physics, including in-situ plasma and pick-up ion measurements, direct sampling of VLISM properties, and remote imaging to discern the heliospheric shape and interaction with interstellar hydrogen. A 4-year NASA funded mission study reports the implementation of a pragmatic Interstellar Probe mission with a nominal design life of reaching 375 Astronomical Units (au), with likely operation out to 550 au.

SPACE SCIENCE REVIEWS (2023)

Review Physics, Multidisciplinary

Cultivating a culture of inclusivity in heliophysics

Alexa J. Halford, Angeline G. Burrell, Michael W. Liemohn, McArthur Jones, Astrid Maute, Tuija I. Pulkkinen, Christopher M. Bard, Ryan M. McGranaghan, Lynn B. Wilson III, Robert C. Allen, Chuanfei Dong, Sarah K. Vines, Liang Wang, Niescja Turner, Katherine Garcia-Sage, Kathleen Mandt, Jeff Klenzing

Summary: A survey on heliophysics reveals that many heliophysicists suffer from bullying and harassment, leading to burnout and thoughts of leaving the field. This calls for collective efforts to establish policies and commitments towards a truly inclusive culture, ensuring the well-being of colleagues and the success of the field.

FRONTIERS IN PHYSICS (2023)

Correction Astronomy & Astrophysics

FUV Observations of the Inner Coma of 46P/Wirtanen (vol 2, 8, 2021)

John W. Noonan, Walter M. Harris, Steven Bromley, Davide Farnocchia, Jian-Yang Li, Kathleen E. Mandt, Joel Wm. Parker, Kumar Venkataramani, Dennis Bodewits

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

The Evolution of Activity and Chemical Composition in Rosetta's Comet Targets across Multiple Apparitions: Complications for CS2 as the CS Parent in Comet Nuclei

John W. Noonan, Joel Wm. Parker, Walter M. Harris, Steven Bromley, Mohammad Saki, Youssef Moulane, Davide Farnocchia, Marco Micheli, Jian-Yang Li, Kathleen E. Mandt, Kumar Venkataramani, Dennis Bodewits

Summary: Researchers used the Hubble Space Telescope to observe two comets and found that their volatile materials were more abundant than previously thought. The study of sulfur-bearing molecules in comets is important for understanding planetesimal formation environments. Several hypotheses were proposed to explain the discrepancy, and future studies were outlined to address these issues.

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

LRO-LAMP Lunar South Pole Cold Traps: Assessment of H2O and Potential CO2 and NH3 Reserves

L. O. Magana, K. D. Retherford, B. D. Byron, A. R. Hendrix, C. Grava, K. E. Mandt, U. Raut, E. Czajka, P. O. Hayne, D. M. Hurley, G. R. Gladstone, M. J. Poston, T. K. Greathouse, W. Pryor, J. T. Cahill, A. Stickle

Summary: Nighttime Lyman Alpha Mapping Project (LAMP) observations are used to investigate condensed volatiles at the south polar region of the Moon. The study detects an increase in albedo ratios consistent with condensed surface volatiles, but the identification of specific species like CO2 and NH3 requires further spectral modeling. The analysis of normalized albedo ratios across different regions of interest helps characterize the relative abundances of volatiles and is important for future missions to the Moon.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-PLANETS (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

New Insights into Aristarchus Crater with LRO LAMP Far-ultraviolet Observations

Elizabeth Czajka, Kurt Retherford, Georgiana Kramer, Amanda Hendrix, Joshua Cahill, Benjamin Byron, Benjamin Greenhagen, Thomas Greathouse, Lizeth Magana, Kathleen Mandt, Cesare Grava

Summary: Using LAMP data, this study investigates four regions of interest around Aristarchus crater and compares their Off/On-band ratios to laboratory-derived ratios of different minerals. The study finds that LAMP Off/On-band ratios can distinguish between plagioclase feldspars and minerals such as quartz, and the Off/On-band ratios at Aristarchus are higher than previously reported for plagioclase-rich regions, suggesting a unique composition.

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2023)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Moonraker: Enceladus Multiple Flyby Mission

O. Mousis, A. Bouquet, Y. Langevin, N. Andre, H. Boithias, G. Durry, F. Faye, P. Hartogh, J. Helbert, L. Iess, S. Kempf, A. Masters, F. Postberg, J. -B. Renard, P. Vernazza, A. Vorburger, P. Wurz, D. H. Atkinson, S. Barabash, M. Berthomier, J. Brucato, M. Cable, J. Carter, S. Cazaux, A. Coustenis, G. Danger, V. Dehant, T. Fornaro, P. Garnier, T. Gautier, O. Groussin, L. Z. Hadid, J. -C. Ize, I. Kolmasova, J. -P. Lebreton, S. Le Maistre, E. Lellouch, J. I. Lunine, K. E. Mandt, Z. Martins, D. Mimoun, Q. Nenon, G. M. Munoz Caro, P. Rannou, H. Rauer, P. Schmitt-Kopplin, A. Schneeberger, M. Simons, K. Stephan, T. Van Hoolst, J. Vaverka, M. Wieser, L. Woerner

Summary: Enceladus, a moon of Saturn, has an internal water ocean and expels ocean material into space. The Moonraker mission aims to investigate the composition of the plume formed by the ocean jets to understand the moon's habitability and origin. This proposed mission will use advanced instruments to pave the way for future landed missions.

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

The Volatile Carbon-to-oxygen Ratio as a Tracer for the Formation Locations of Interstellar Comets

Darryl Z. Seligman, Leslie A. Rogers, Samuel H. C. Cabot, John W. Noonan, Theodore Kareta, Kathleen E. Mandt, Fred Ciesla, Adam McKay, Adina D. Feinstein, W. Garrett Levine, Jacob L. Bean, Thomas Nordlander, Mark R. Krumholz, Megan Mansfield, Devin J. Hoover, Eric Van Clepper

Summary: Based on the discoveries of interstellar objects like 'Oumuamua and Borisov, the Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey is expected to detect at least one interstellar object annually. Future measurements of H2O, CO2, and CO production rates in these objects will help estimate their carbon-to-oxygen ratios. Studies on solar system comets suggest they formed interior to the CO snow line, while the preferential desorption of CO and CO2 relative to H2O in the interstellar medium indicates that measured C/O ratios represent lower limits on the primordial ratios.

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

The Case for a New Frontiers-Class Uranus Orbiter: System Science at an Underexplored and Unique World with a Mid-scale Mission

Ian J. Cohen, Chloe Beddingfield, Robert Chancia, Gina DiBraccio, Matthew Hedman, Shannon MacKenzie, Barry Mauk, Kunio M. Sayanagi, Krista M. Soderlund, Elizabeth Turtle, Caitlin Ahrens, Christopher S. Arridge, Shawn M. Brooks, Emma Bunce, Sebastien Charnoz, Athena Coustenis, Robert A. Dillman, Soumyo Dutta, Leigh N. Fletcher, Rebecca Harbison, Ravit Helled, Richard Holme, Lauren Jozwiak, Yasumasa Kasaba, Peter Kollmann, Statia Luszcz-Cook, Kathleen Mandt, Olivier Mousis, Alessandro Mura, Go Murakami, Marzia Parisi, Abigail Rymer, Sabine Stanley, Katrin Stephan, Ronald J. Vervack Jr., Michael H. Wong, Peter Wurz

Summary: The exploration of the Uranian system is crucial for understanding the formation and evolution of our solar system and studying exoplanets. The scientific case for a New Frontiers-class Uranus orbiter needs to be evaluated and studied.

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2022)

No Data Available