4.3 Article

The cost-effectiveness of contemporary home haemodialysis modalities compared with facility haemodialysis: A systematic review of full economic evaluations

Journal

NEPHROLOGY
Volume 19, Issue 8, Pages 459-470

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/nep.12269

Keywords

cost benefit analysis; cost-effectiveness; economics; facility dialysis; home haemodialysis; renal dialysis

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Aim: The financial burden of the increasing dialysis population challenges healthcare resources internationally. Home haemodialysis offers many benefits over conventional facility dialysis including superior clinical, patient-centred outcomes and reduced cost. This review updates a previous review, conducted a decade prior, incorporating contemporary home dialysis techniques of frequent and nocturnal dialysis. We sought comparative cost-effectiveness studies of home versus facility haemodialysis (HD) for people with end-stage kidney failure (ESKF). Methods: We conducted a systematic review of literature from January 2000-March 2014. Studies were included if they provided comparative information on the costs, health outcomes and cost-effectiveness ratios of home HD and facility HD. We searched medical and health economic databases using MeSH headings and text words for economic evaluation and haemodialysis. Results: Six studies of economic evaluations that compared home to facility HD were identified. Two studies compared home nocturnal HD, one home nocturnal and daily home HD, and three compared contemporary home HD to facility HD. Overall these studies suggest that contemporary home HD modalities are less costly and more effective than facility HD. Home HD start-up costs tend to be higher in the short term, but these are offset by cost savings over the longer term. Conclusions: Contemporaneous dialysis modalities including nocturnal and daily home haemodialysis are cost-effective or cost-saving compared with facility-based haemodialysis. This result is largely driven by lower staff costs, and better health outcomes for survival and quality of life. Expanding the proportion of haemodialysis patients managed at home is likely to produce cost savings.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

We Need a System that's Not Designed to Fail Maori: Experiences of Racism Related to Kidney Transplantation in Aotearoa New Zealand

Rachael C. Walker, Sally Abel, Suetonia C. Palmer, Curtis Walker, Nayda Heays, David Tipene-Leach

Summary: This paper examines the perceptions and experiences of prejudice and racism among indigenous Maori with kidney disease and their family members and donors. The study reveals that racism exists at institutional, personal, and internal levels, contributing to inequitable outcomes for Maori requiring kidney transplantation in Aotearoa New Zealand.

JOURNAL OF RACIAL AND ETHNIC HEALTH DISPARITIES (2023)

Article Economics

Estimating loss in capability wellbeing in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic: a cross-sectional study of the general adult population in the UK, Australia and the Netherlands

Paul Mark Mitchell, Rachael L. Morton, Mickael Hiligsmann, Samantha Husbands, Joanna Coast

Summary: Substantial losses in capability wellbeing were observed during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK, Australia, and the Netherlands. Future research is needed to understand the specific impact of different COVID-19 restrictions on individuals' capabilities.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Urology & Nephrology

Longitudinal assessment of the health-related quality of life of children and adolescents with chronic kidney disease

Chandana Guha, Anita van Zwieten, Rabia Khalid, Siah Kim, Amanda Walker, Anna Francis, Madeleine Didsbury, Armando Teixeira-Pinto, Belinda Barton, Chanel Prestidge, Emily Lancsar, Fiona Mackie, Joseph Kwon, Kirsten Howard, Kylie-Ann Mallitt, Martin Howell, Allison Jaure, Alison Hayes, Rakhee Raghunandan, Stavros Petrou, Suncica Lah, Steven McTaggart, Jonathan C. Craig, Germaine Wong

Summary: This multi-center longitudinal cohort study aimed to assess the trajectories of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in children with chronic kidney disease (CKD) over time. The results showed that the HRQoL scores differed between children with different CKD stages, and the transition from dialysis to transplantation was significantly associated with the improvement in HRQoL. Children with CKD stage 1-5 and transplant recipients at baseline had stable HRQoL over time.

KIDNEY INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Pediatrics

Baseline characteristics of participants in the NAVKIDS2 trial: a patient navigator program in children with chronic kidney disease

Chandana Guha, Rabia Khalid, Anita van Zwieten, Anna Francis, Carmel M. Hawley, Allison Jaure, Armando Teixeira-Pinto, Alistair R. Mallard, Amelie Bernier-Jean, David W. Johnson, Deirdre Hahn, Donna Reidlinger, Elaine M. Pascoe, Elizabeth G. Ryan, Fiona Mackie, Hugh J. McCarthy, Jonathan C. Craig, Julie Varghese, Charani Kiriwandeniya, Kirsten Howard, Nicholas G. Larkins, Luke Macauley, Amanda Walker, Martin Howell, Michelle Irving, Patrina H. Y. Caldwell, Reginald Woodleigh, Shilpanjali Jesudason, Simon A. Carter, Sean E. Kennedy, Stephen Alexander, Steven McTaggart, Germaine Wong

Summary: This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of a patient navigator program in children with chronic kidney disease. A total of 162 patients were enrolled and randomized into immediate intervention and waitlisted groups. The results of the study will be completed by October 2022.

PEDIATRIC NEPHROLOGY (2023)

Article Rehabilitation

Economic evaluation of digitally enabled aged and neurological rehabilitation care in the Activity and MObility UsiNg Technology (AMOUNT) trial

Marina B. Pinheiro, Leanne Hassett, Catherine Sherrington, Alison Hayes, Maayken van den Berg, Richard Lindley, Maria Crotty, Sakina Chagpar, Daniel Treacy, Heather Weber, Nicola Fairhall, Siobhan Wong, Annie McCluskey, Leanne Togher, Katharine Scrivener, Kirsten Howard

Summary: This study evaluated the cost-effectiveness of adding a tailored digitally enabled exercise intervention to usual care in improving mobility, showing that the intervention saved costs and was more effective for mobility and quality-adjusted life years compared to usual care. Decision makers willing to pay AU$50,000 per meaningful improvement in mobility or quality-adjusted life year gained had a high probability of the intervention being cost-effective.

CLINICAL REHABILITATION (2023)

Letter Dermatology

Risk of developing a second primary melanoma after a first primary melanoma in a population-based Australian cohort

Yuan Ni, Caroline G. Watts, Richard A. Scolyer, Christine Madronio, Bruce K. Armstrong, Rachael L. Morton, Scott W. Menzies, Graham J. Mann, John F. Thompson, Serigne N. Lo, Anne E. Cust

Summary: This cross-sectional survey identified risk factors for developing a second primary melanoma. Patients with melanoma who had characteristics such as male sex, older age, high naevus count, or melanoma on the trunk or upper limbs had a substantially higher risk of subsequent melanoma and should therefore be more intensively monitored.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF DERMATOLOGY (2023)

Article Urology & Nephrology

Simplified calculation of peritoneal dialysis-associated peritonitis rate: Accuracy of a recently developed estimating equation

Mark R. Marshall, Gerald P. Waters, Christian Verger

Summary: In this study, a simple method for estimating the peritonitis rate in peritoneal dialysis (PD) was validated and found to have good agreement with gold-standard measurements in two large dialysis registries. However, the International Society of Peritoneal Dialysis (ISPD) hesitated to recommend its adoption due to concerns about potential inaccuracies. Further analysis of the data sets confirmed the accuracy of the estimating equation and showed that its use would not compromise clinical decision-making for most patients.

PERITONEAL DIALYSIS INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Study protocol for a randomised controlled trial to evaluate the use of melanoma surveillance photography to the Improve early detection of MelanomA in ultra-hiGh and high-risk patiEnts (the IMAGE trial)

Mabel K. Yan, Anne E. Cust, H. Peter Soyer, Monika Janda, Katja Loewe, Gabrielle Byars, Paul Fishburn, Paul White, Rashidul Alam Mahumud, Robyn P. M. Saw, Alan Herschtal, Pablo Fernandez-Penas, Pascale Guitera, Rachael L. Morton, John Kelly, Rory Wolfe, Victoria J. Mar

Summary: This study aims to evaluate the clinical impact and cost-effectiveness of using Melanoma surveillance photography (MSP) for individuals at ultra-high or high risk of melanoma. The study is a randomized controlled trial (RCT) conducted over 3 years, with 580 participants from three Australian states. The primary outcome measure is the number of unnecessary biopsies, and secondary outcomes include health economic outcomes, quality of life, and patient acceptability. The results of this study will contribute to policy decision-making and the clinical application of MSP.

TRIALS (2023)

Review Economics

Systematic Review of the Psychometric Performance of Generic Childhood Multi-attribute Utility Instruments

Joseph Kwon, Sarah Smith, Rakhee Raghunandan, Martin Howell, Elisabeth Huynh, Sungwook Kim, Thomas Bentley, Nia Roberts, Emily Lancsar, Kirsten Howard, Germaine Wong, Jonathan Craig, Stavros Petrou

Summary: This study conducted a systematic review of psychometric evidence for generic childhood MAUIs and provides comprehensive evidence on their performance. It assists in selecting instruments based on scientific rigor and identifies gaps and methodological issues for future research.

APPLIED HEALTH ECONOMICS AND HEALTH POLICY (2023)

Review Pediatrics

A Systematic Review of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome

Zoe Wei, Yasmin Gilbert, Arabhi Thananjeyan, James Cope, Rachael L. Morton, Annie Li, Cecile T. Pham, Meredith Ward, Ju Lee Oei

Summary: This systematic review evaluated the quality and availability of clinical practice guidelines for neonatal abstinence syndrome. The findings suggest that the majority of guidelines are of insufficient quality, highlighting the need for more high-quality research to guide clinical practice and improve care.

CHILDREN-BASEL (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Preferences for Adjuvant Immunotherapy in Adults with Resected Stage III Melanoma-A Discrete Choice Experiment

Ann Livingstone, Kirsten Howard, Alexander M. Menzies, Georgina V. Long, Martin R. Stockler, Rachael L. Morton

Summary: This study aimed to quantify adult preferences for adjuvant immunotherapy for resected melanoma and the influence of varying levels of key attributes and baseline characteristics. The study found that 70% of respondents chose adjuvant immunotherapy over no adjuvant immunotherapy, preferring treatment that improved efficacy and safety. The importance of this study is rated 8 out of 10.

PATIENT-PATIENT CENTERED OUTCOMES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Physical Activity Preferences of People Living with Brain Injury: Formative Qualitative Research to Develop a Discrete Choice Experiment

Abby Haynes, Kirsten Howard, Liam Johnson, Gavin Williams, Kelly Clanchy, Sean Tweedy, Adam Scheinberg, Sakina Chagpar, Belinda Wang, Gabrielle Vassallo, Rhys Ashpole, Catherine Sherrington, Leanne Hassett

Summary: This study successfully developed a discrete choice experiment survey tool through discussions and interviews with patients with moderate-to-severe traumatic brain injury. The tool aimed to understand the preferences for physical activity among these patients and improve the World Health Organization guidelines for physical activity in traumatic brain injury. The formative co-development process significantly improved the relevance and comprehensibility of the survey tool.

PATIENT-PATIENT CENTERED OUTCOMES RESEARCH (2023)

Review Economics

Systematic Review of the Relative Social Value of Child and Adult Health

Tessa Peasgood, Martin Howell, Rakhee Raghunandan, Amber Salisbury, Marcus Sellars, Gang Chen, Joanna Coast, Jonathan C. Craig, Nancy J. Devlin, Kirsten Howard, Emily Lancsar, Stavros Petrou, Julie Ratcliffe, Rosalie Viney, Germaine Wong, Richard Norman, Cam Donaldson

Summary: This study aimed to synthesize knowledge on the social value of child and adult health and found that the majority of studies supported prioritizing children. However, not all studies were consistent with this view, and there are research gaps in understanding the value of health gains for very young children and the motivations behind the public's views.

PHARMACOECONOMICS (2023)

No Data Available