The fallacy of Meyer-Neldel temperature as a measure of disorder

Comment on “The mathematical origins of the kinetic compensation effect” Parts 1 and 2 by P. J. Barrie, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2012, 14, 318 and 327

(2012) A. Yelon et al.   PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY CHEMICAL PHYSICS

Effect of source-drain electric field on the Meyer–Neldel energy in organic field effect transistors

(2011) Mujeeb Ullah et al.   APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS

Electric field dependent activation energy of electron transport in fullerene diodes and field effect transistors: Gill’s law

(2011) A. Pivrikas et al.   APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS

Comparative study of bulk and interface transport in disordered fullerene films

(2011) Almantas Pivrikas et al.   PHYSICA STATUS SOLIDI B-BASIC SOLID STATE PHYSICS

Electric field and grain size dependence of Meyer–Neldel energy in C60 films

(2011) Mujeeb Ullah et al.   SYNTHETIC METALS

Dependence of Meyer–Neldel energy on energetic disorder in organic field effect transistors

(2010) Mujeeb Ullah et al.   APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS

Meyer–Neldel rule for charge carrier transport in fullerene devices: A comparative study

(2010) A. Pivrikas et al.   ORGANIC ELECTRONICS

Laplace Meyer-Neldel relation

(2010) Hiroaki Okamoto et al.   PHYSICA STATUS SOLIDI A-APPLICATIONS AND MATERIALS SCIENCE

Interpretation and consequences of Meyer-Neldel rule for conductivity of phase change alloys

(2010) S. D. Savransky et al.   PHYSICA STATUS SOLIDI A-APPLICATIONS AND MATERIALS SCIENCE

Temperature dependence of the charge carrier mobility in disordered organic semiconductors at large carrier concentrations

(2010) I. I. Fishchuk et al.   PHYSICAL REVIEW B

Observation of an Isokinetic Temperature and Compensation Effect for High-Temperature Crude Oil Fouling

(2009) Christopher A. Bennett et al.   HEAT TRANSFER ENGINEERING

Generalized Adiabatic Polaron Hopping: Meyer-Neldel Compensation and Poole-Frenkel Behavior

(2008) David Emin   PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS