4.5 Article

The effect of a short integrated study skills programme for first-year medical students at risk of failure: A randomised controlled trial

Journal

MEDICAL TEACHER
Volume 35, Issue 2, Pages 120-126

Publisher

INFORMA HEALTHCARE
DOI: 10.3109/0142159X.2012.733836

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: There is a need for outcome-based studies on strategies for supporting at-risk medical students that use long-term follow-up and contemporaneous controls. Aim: To measure the effect of a short integrated study skills programme (SSP) on the study progress of at-risk medical students. Methods: First-year students identified as at-risk of academic failure at 7 months after enrolment were invited to participate in the randomised controlled trial. Participants were randomly assigned to the SSP group or to a control group receiving standard academic support. Effects of SSP were measured on the short (passed first exam after intervention), medium (obtained enough credits to proceed to second year) and long term (completed first-year curriculum within 2 years). Results: SSP participants (n = 43) more often passed the first exam after the intervention than controls (n = 41; 30% versus 12%; X-2 (1) = 4.06, p < 0.005, effect size = 0.22), in particular those who had previously passed at least one exam. No medium or long-term effect was found. Participants who had attended four or five SSP sessions outperformed those who had attended fewer sessions on all outcome measures. Conclusion: A short, integrated SSP benefited some, but not all students. Our advice is to focus support efforts on at-risk students who have demonstrated commitment and academic potential.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Gender-specific effects of raising Year-1 standards on medical students' academic performance and stress levels

Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Mesut Savas, Jeroen Waal, Elisabeth F. C. Rossum, Andrea M. Woltman

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2020)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Effects of raising the bar on medical student study progress: An intersectional approach

Vera M. A. Broks, Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Walter W. van den Broek, Andrea M. Woltman

Summary: The study found that a stricter academic dismissal policy in medical schools increased Year-1 completion rates, especially for under-represented subgroups. However, dropout rates doubled under the new policy, particularly for students with standard prior education. Long-term effects showed that higher performance standards may harm other subgroups and student diversity.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2021)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Student ethnicity predicts social learning experiences, self-regulatory focus and grades

Chantal E. E. van Andel, Marise P. Born, Walter W. van den Broek, Karen M. Stegers-Jager

Summary: Ethnic minority students in clinical training experience more unfair treatment and lower trust in supervisors compared to their ethnic majority counterparts. They tend to have a prevention focus in clinical training, but this is not solely explained by their negative social learning experiences. Additionally, their lower clinical evaluations remain unexplained.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2022)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Inferring signs from purposeful samples: The role of context in competency assessment

Marise Ph Born, Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Chantal E. E. van Andel

Summary: This paper discusses how to infer students' overall competency profile from convenience samples using insights from psychology. It adapts Smith's theory of predictor validity to clinical competency assessment, emphasizing the importance of considering whether traits are universals, occupationals, or relationals when generalizing from assessed clinical competencies to generic competencies. Smith's distinction offers a promising way forward for medical education in terms of assessment, student selection, and career choice.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2022)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Do norms unintentionally increase stereotypical expressions? A randomised controlled trial

Chantal E. E. van Andel, Marise P. Born, Walter W. van den Broek, Karen M. Stegers-Jager

Summary: The study found that interventions do not unintentionally increase stereotypes by communicating what the majority of people thinks or does. Individual perceptions and preferences are predictive of stereotypes, whereas descriptive social norms are not.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Medical educators' experiences on medically unexplained symptoms and intercultural communication-an expert focus group study

Viola Sallay, Tamas Martos, Lilla Lucza, Anne Weiland, Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Peter Vermeir, An Noelle Margareta Mariman, Marta Csabai

Summary: The study identified the need for medical specialists to adapt to the personal world of patients, search for common frames to understand MUS, discover methods for adapting to cultural differences, and enhance interprofessional coordination of knowledge and practices.

BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION (2022)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Applicant perceptions of selection methods for health professions education: Rationales and subgroup differences

Suzanne Fikrat-Wevers, Karen Stegers-Jager, Marleen Groenier, Andries Koster, Jan Hindrik Ravesloot, Renske Van Gestel, Anouk Wouters, Walter van den Broek, Andrea Woltman

Summary: Applicant perceptions of selection methods can affect motivation, performance and withdrawal, and this study aimed to examine how different applicant subgroups perceive various selection methods. The findings showed that applicants prefer selection methods that give them a sense of control and allow them to showcase attributes beyond cognitive abilities. However, conflicting preferences and concerns were also identified.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Selection tools and student diversity in health professions education: a multi-site study

S. Fikrat-Wevers, K. M. Stegers-Jager, P. M. Afonso, A. S. Koster, R. A. Van Gestel, M. Groenier, J. H. Ravesloot, A. Wouters, W. W. Van Den Broek, A. M. Woltman

Summary: This study examined how selection procedures in health professions education impact student diversity. The results showed that different selection tools have different effects on the chances of selection for subgroups of applicants. The study highlights the importance of continuous evaluation and the use of alternative tools in order to improve diversity in health professions education.

ADVANCES IN HEALTH SCIENCES EDUCATION (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Medical students' crisis-induced stress and the association with social support

Vera M. A. Broks, Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Jeroen van der Waal, Walter W. van den Broek, Andrea M. Woltman

Summary: This study aimed to assess the impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on perceived stress levels of medical students and explore the relationship between social support and stress during the pandemic. The results showed that medical students experienced higher levels of perceived stress during the outbreak, especially those with lower levels of social support. Therefore, medical schools should optimize social support to minimize crisis-induced stress.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Editorial Material Education, Scientific Disciplines

Selection based on athletics: What price will the candidates pay?

Suzanne Fikrat-Wevers, Karen M. M. Stegers-Jager, Andrea M. M. Woltman

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

The association between how medical students were selected and their perceived stress levels in Year-1 of medical school

Vera M. A. Broks, Karen M. Stegers-Jager, Suzanne Fikrat-Wevers, Walter. W. van den Broek, Andrea M. Woltman

Summary: The study found that students selected by assessment or weighted lottery showed higher levels of stress perception in Year-1 of medical school, while students selected by high grades had lower stress perception levels. Additionally, academic performance also had an impact on stress perception levels.

BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Medical students' perception of general practice: a cross-sectional survey

D. H. J. Pols, A. Kamps, J. Runhaar, G. Elshout, K. F. van Halewijn, Patrick J. E. Bindels, K. M. Stegers-Jager

Summary: This study investigated the attitudes and perceptions of Dutch medical students towards general practice and found that multiple factors were significantly associated with their interest in pursuing a career in general practice. Despite the low status of general practice within the medical profession, students acknowledged its social importance and pleasant working environment.

BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

The added value of free preparatory activities for widening access to medical education: a multi-cohort study

S. Fikrat-Wevers, W. E. De Leng, W. W. van den Broek, A. M. Woltman, K. M. Stegers-Jager

Summary: This study evaluated the relationship between four free preparatory activities and the demographic composition of participating and non-participating applicants. The results showed that these activities contribute to student diversity in medical education, but participation is not directly associated with early academic performance.

BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Review Education & Educational Research

Curricular fit perspective on motivation in higher education

R. Kickert, M. Meeuwisse, K. M. Stegers-Jager, P. Prinzie, L. R. Arends

Summary: This article introduces a curricular perspective that emphasizes the importance of alignment between curriculum objectives and assessment in students' motivation. In reality, there is often a cognitive and operant misalignment between assessments and objectives, leading to a focus on assessed learning rather than all learning tasks. As a result, students may be more motivated to concentrate their efforts on assessed learning in order to perform well on assessments.

HIGHER EDUCATION (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Assessment policies and academic progress: differences in performance and selection for progress

Rob Kickert, Marieke Meeuwisse, Lidia R. Arends, Peter Prinzie, Karen M. Stegers-Jager

Summary: Changes to assessment policies can impact student academic progress, with differences in progress explained by variations in performance and selection for progress by different policies. Although assessment policies seem effective in shaping student progress, a one-size-fits-all approach may not be suitable.

ASSESSMENT & EVALUATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION (2021)

No Data Available