4.5 Article

Is it me or is it them? Factors that influence the passing of underperforming students

Journal

MEDICAL EDUCATION
Volume 42, Issue 8, Pages 800-809

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2008.03113.x

Keywords

clinical competence, standards; education, medical, undergraduate; disclosure

Ask authors/readers for more resources

CONTEXT Research has found that clinical assessments do not always accurately reflect medical student performance. Barriers to failing underperformance in students have been identified in other vocational settings. Is 'failure to fail' an issue for medical educators in the UK, and, if so, what are its determinants? METHODS We carried out a qualitative focus group study exploring the views of medical educators (general practitioners, hospital doctors and non-clinical tutors) from two different UK medical schools. To make sense of a potential multitude of factors impacting on failure to fail, we selected the integrative model of behavioural prediction to underpin our data collection and analysis. RESULTS Ten focus groups were carried out with 70 participants. Using both theory and data-driven framework analysis, we identified six main themes relevant to the integrative model of behavioural prediction. These are: tutor attitudes towards an individual student; tutor attitudes towards failing a student; normative beliefs and motivation to comply; efficacy beliefs (self-efficacy); skills and knowledge, and environmental constraints. DISCUSSION Many different factors impact on medical educators' failure to report underperformance in students. There are conflicts between these factors and the need to report competence accurately (i.e. duty to protect the public). Although some of the barriers identified are similar to those found in previous studies, using a theory-based approach added value in that it facilitated a richer exploration of failure to fail. Insights offered in this study will be used to plan a questionnaire study and subsequent intervention to support medical educators in accurately reporting underperformance in students.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Education & Educational Research

Priority setting in higher education research using a mixed methods approach

Tammie Choi, Claire Palermo, Mahbub Sarkar, Joy Whitton, Charlotte Rees, Allie Clemans

Summary: This study aimed to identify research priorities for higher education at one Australian university. Through a mixed methods approach, it was found that the top three priorities were engaging students in learning, teaching creative and critical thinking skills, and promoting resilience, wellbeing and student connectedness.

HIGHER EDUCATION RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Pharmacist-independent prescriber deprescribing in UK care homes: Contextual factors associated with increased activity

Mohammed Alharthi, Sion Scott, David Phillip Alldred, Richard Holland, Carmel Hughes, Linda Birt, Jeanette Blacklock, Christine Bond, Allan Clark, David Wright

Summary: A study conducted in UK care homes found that contextual factors may influence the likelihood of pharmacist-independent prescribers deprescribing medications.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGY (2023)

Editorial Material Education, Scientific Disciplines

The socialisation of mistreatment in the healthcare workplace: Moving beyond narrative content to analyse educator data as discourse

Lynn V. Monrouxe, Charlotte E. Rees

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Review Education, Scientific Disciplines

The development of professional identity in clinical psychologists: A scoping review

Samantha Schubert, Niels Buus, Lynn V. Monrouxe, Caroline Hunt

Summary: Our professional identity as health care professionals, including clinical psychologists, is crucial for the realization of health care reforms. The alignment of our professional identity with reform directions is important, and more research is needed to understand the development of professional identities in the mental health care field. Future research should focus on theoretical frameworks and improved methodologies to facilitate this process and enable the implementation of health care reforms.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Editorial Material Education, Scientific Disciplines

When I say ... Identity

Adam P. Sawatsky, Lynn V. Monrouxe

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Shifting the narrative and practice of assessing professionalism in dietetics education: An Australasian qualitative study

Janeane Dart, Charlotte Rees, Susan Ash, Louise McCall, Claire Palermo

Summary: There have been considerable advances in professionalism assessment in dietetics education in Australia and New Zealand in recent years. These advances include approaching professionalism through a more interpretive lens, holistically and more student-centered. However, further development and transformation are needed to fully embed and strengthen curricula approaches across programs.

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2023)

Editorial Material Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Improving the quality of publications in and advancing the paradigms of clinical and social pharmacy practice research: the Granada Statements

Fernando Fernandez-Llimos, Shane Desselle, Derek Stewart, Victoria Garcia-Cardenas, Zaheer-Ud-Din Babar, Christine Bond, Ana Dago, Ramune Jacobsen, Lotte Stig Norgaard, Carlo Polidori, Manuel Sanchez-Polo, Bernardo Santos-Ramos, Natalia Shcherbakova, Fernanda S. Tonin

Summary: Pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences encompass various disciplines, and pharmacy practice focuses on studying the practice of pharmacy and its impact on healthcare systems and patient care. Clinical and social pharmacy practice disseminates research findings through scientific journals, and journal editors play a role in enhancing the quality of published articles. A group of clinical and social pharmacy practice journal editors gathered in Granada, Spain to discuss how journals could contribute to strengthening pharmacy practice, resulting in the compilation of the Granada Statements with 18 recommendations.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PHARMACY (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Interrogation in clinical supervision sessions: Exploring the construction of clinical psychology trainees' professional identities

Samantha Schubert, Niels Buus, Lynn Monrouxe, Caroline Hunt

Summary: This study provides an in-depth exploration of novice healthcare professionals' identity development within formal educational interactions, focusing on clinical psychology trainee supervision. The findings reveal that supervisors' use of quality control or reflective frames in interrogations influences the construction of trainees' identities, and trainees employ impression management tactics to manage face-threat. Maintaining a reflective space in supervision during interrogations poses challenges.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2023)

Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Improving the quality of publications in and advancing the paradigms of clinical and social pharmacy practice research: the Granada Statements

Fernando Fernandez-Llimos, Shane Desselle, Derek Stewart, Victoria Garcia-Cardenas, Zaheer-Ud-Din Babar, Christine Bond, Ana Dago, Ramune Jacobsen, Lotte Stig Norgaard, Carlo Polidori, Manuel Sanchez-Polo, Bernardo Santos-Ramos, Natalia G. Shcherbakova, Fernanda S. Tonin

Summary: Pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences encompass various disciplines, including clinical pharmacy and social pharmacy. The Granada Statements emerged from a meeting of clinical and social pharmacy journal editors in Spain, discussing how journals can strengthen the discipline. The statements provide 18 recommendations, covering topics such as terminology, abstracts, peer reviews, journal scattering, and article performance metrics.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF HOSPITAL PHARMACY (2023)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Striving to thrive or striving to survive: Professional identity constructions of medical trainees in clinical assessment activities

Kuo-Chen Liao, Rola Ajjawi, Chang-Hsuan Peng, Chang-Chyi Jenq, Lynn V. Monrouxe

Summary: This study used a narrative approach to investigate how medical trainees construct professional identities in clinical assessment contexts. Two key narrative plotlines were identified and the roles played by trainees in the assessment process were examined. The findings have implications for educators in improving assessment practices and facilitating trainee identity construction.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

Dignity during work-integrated learning: Piloting an online learning resource for placement students and supervisors

Mahbub Sarkar, Corinne Davis, Olivia King, Kadheeja Wahid, Charlotte E. Rees

Summary: This study addresses the issue of medical student abuse within work-integrated learning by creating an online learning resource to improve stakeholders' understanding of workplace dignity and promote dignified practices. Through a pilot evaluation, the researchers found potential benefits and applications of learning from the resource and provided recommendations for improvement.

MEDICAL TEACHER (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

The graduate dietitian experience of employment and employability: A longitudinal qualitative research study from one Australian university

Merran Blair, Lana Mitchell, Simone Gibson, Charlotte E. Rees, Ella Ottrey, Lynn V. Monrouxe, Claire Palermo

Summary: This study aimed to explore the experiences of dietetics graduates in terms of employment and employability up to 6 months after completing their degree. The findings revealed that many graduates faced difficulties during the job application process, including repeated rejections. They also experienced an uncertain journey to employment and felt pressure from various sources. However, they were able to enhance their employability by utilizing resources. It suggests that providing more placement opportunities and assisting students in developing job-seeking skills, networking, and volunteering experiences during their education can improve their employability.

NUTRITION & DIETETICS (2023)

Review Education, Scientific Disciplines

A roadmap to realist interviews in health professions education research: Recommendations based on a critical analysis

Charlotte E. Rees, Corinne Davis, Van N. B. Nguyen, Dominic Proctor, Karen L. Mattick

Summary: Realist evaluation is increasingly used in health professions education research to understand the effectiveness of educational interventions, and realist interviewing plays a crucial role in this process. This article aims to provide guidance on conducting, reporting, and critiquing realist interviews in the field.

MEDICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Why the trial researcher matters: Day-to-day work viewed through the lens of normalization process theory

Lindsay Dalgarno, Linda Birt, Christine Bond, Jeanette Blacklock, Annie Blyth, Jacqueline Inch, Frances Notman, Amrit Daffu-O'Reilly, Maureen Spargo, Laura Watts, David Wright, Fiona Poland

Summary: This study aimed to understand the nature of the often invisible work conducted by researchers in the field during randomised controlled trials (RCTs). The results indicated that Research Associates (RAs) played a crucial role in the successful conduct of a complex RCT study, helping stakeholders and participants make sense of the research, building relationships for participant retention, operationalising data collection procedures, and reflecting on their experiences to inform trial procedure changes.

SSM-QUALITATIVE RESEARCH IN HEALTH (2023)

No Data Available