4.6 Article

MAKING LAND MANAGEMENT MORE SUSTAINABLE: EXPERIENCE IMPLEMENTING A NEW METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK IN BOTSWANA

Journal

LAND DEGRADATION & DEVELOPMENT
Volume 24, Issue 5, Pages 463-477

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1002/ldr.1142

Keywords

knowledge management; sustainable land management; drylands; Botswana

Funding

  1. EU [037046]
  2. University of Botswana
  3. British Academy Research Development Award

Ask authors/readers for more resources

It is increasingly recognised that tackling land degradation through more sustainable land management depends on incorporating multiple perspectives by using a variety of methods at multiple scales, including the perspectives of those who manage and/or use the land. This paper reports experience implementing a previously proposed methodological framework that is designed to facilitate knowledge sharing between researchers and stakeholders about land degradation severity and extent, and sustainable land management options. Empirical findings are presented from the Botswana site of the EU-funded Desertification Mitigation and Remediation of Land project. The paper reflects upon the challenges and benefits of the proposed framework and identifies a number of benefits, notably related to insights arising from the integration of local and scientific knowledge, and the ownership of the sustainable land management strategies that emerged from the process. However, implementing the framework was not without challenges, and levels of poverty and formal education may limit the implementation of the framework in some developing world contexts. Copyright (c) 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Water Resources

The impact of semi-natural broadleaf woodland and pasture on soil properties and flood discharge

Felicity Monger, Dominick Spracklen, Mike Kirkby, Lee Schofield

Summary: The study shows that semi-natural broadleaf woodlands can reduce peak discharge and runoff coefficients, prolong flood response time, and the more permeable woodland soils contribute to the differences in flood response.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Water Resources

Overland flow velocity and soil properties in established semi-natural woodland and wood pasture in an upland catchment

Felicity Monger, Stephanie Bond, Dominick Spracklen, Mike J. Kirkby

Summary: The management of upland land-use can reduce flood risk by increasing topsoil storage and slowing overland flow. This study measures soil properties and overland flow velocities in different types of woodland habitats, and finds that bracken-dominated wood pasture has lower overland flow velocity compared to established broadleaf woodland and grass-dominated wood pasture. Soil saturated hydraulic conductivity is also higher in established woodland compared to wood pasture dominated by bracken or grass. The findings suggest that managing upland habitats can effectively reduce flood risk by storing storm water in the soil and reducing overland flow velocity through vegetation.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Re-thinking research impact: voice, context and power at the interface of science, policy and practice

Mark S. Reed, Hannah Rudman

Summary: This article discusses three considerations for rethinking how research can create beneficial impacts on policy and practice: sensitivity to context, representation and legitimization of diverse voices, and the management of power dynamics. By considering the factors of context, power, and voice in the research and impact generation processes, it is possible to envision a just transformation of knowledge systems that prioritizes the knowledge and needs of diverse groups, including historically marginalized groups.

SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Water Resources

Evaluating the effectiveness of land use management as a natural flood management intervention in reducing the impact of flooding for an upland catchment

Lorna Kingsbury-Smith, Thomas Willis, Mark Smith, Helene Boisgontier, Daniel Turner, Jack Hirst, Michael Kirkby, Megan Klaar

Summary: Natural flood management (NFM) is a catchment-based approach for reducing flood risk. This study uses fieldwork, laboratory analysis, and modeling to quantify the impact of land use management changes on catchment flood hazard. The findings support the implementation of NFM interventions as a means of reducing flood hazard within a rural upland catchment.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Economic Feasibility of Rainwater Harvesting Applications in the West Bank, Palestine

Johanna E. M. Schild, Luuk Fleskens, Michel Riksen, Sameer Shadeed

Summary: Freshwater resources in Palestine are uncertain and the situation is expected to worsen due to climate change and politics. Rainwater harvesting through eyebrow terracing and domestic rooftop harvesting shows economic feasibility, but construction costs hinder widespread adoption. Subsidies for rainwater harvesting could make it more attractive for households.

WATER (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

How greenhouse horticulture in arid regions can contribute to climate-resilient and sustainable food security

Simon Goddek, Oliver Koerner, Karel J. Keesman, Mark A. Tester, Ryan Lefers, Luuk Fleskens, Alyssa Joyce, Erik van Os, Amit Gross, Rik Leemans

Summary: A potential change in climate and temperature could strongly affect weather-related crop losses. Using wastelands to grow crops in controlled greenhouse environments could improve global food security and preserve ecosystems. However, the impact of climate change on additional energy and water requirements of greenhouse horticulture food production is still unknown.

GLOBAL FOOD SECURITY-AGRICULTURE POLICY ECONOMICS AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

System-wide nexus analyses: water distribution rules, agricultural productivity and livelihoods in flood-based livelihood systems

Mara Zenebe, Luuk Fleskens, Karim Newaz, Coen Ritsema

Summary: Water management and distribution rules play a crucial role in enhancing productivity and livelihoods in flood-based livelihood systems (FBLS). While the potential of such rules has been harnessed to some extent in DG Khan FBLS in Pakistan, it has not been fulfilled in the Tana River and Fogera FBLS in Kenya and Ethiopia. The absence of comprehensive water management and distribution rules has resulted in negative consequences for downstream farmers in Kenya and Ethiopia, leading to scarcity of floodwater, low crop yields, and poor livelihoods. These findings emphasize the importance of formulating effective water distribution rules to maximize the productivity and livelihood potentials of FBLS.

RENEWABLE AGRICULTURE AND FOOD SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Ethics

Rethinking Appropriateness of Actions in Environmental Decisions: Connecting Interest and Identity Negotiation with Plural Valuation

Christopher M. Raymond, Paul Hirsch, Bryan Norton, Andrew Scott, Mark S. Reed

Summary: Issues of interest, identity and values are interconnected in environmental conflicts. To address these challenges, a relational understanding of environmental ethics and the concept of 'appropriateness of actions' are introduced. Success factors for supporting appropriate actions include understanding context and identifying key stakeholders, surfacing diverse interests and building system-level trust, building empathy for different identities grounded in specific places, eliciting diverse values and seeking to understand their links to worldviews and knowledge systems, and seeking out appropriate actions.

ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Trade-offs between the natural environment and recreational infrastructure: A case study about peatlands under different management scenarios

Simone Martino, Jasper O. Kenter, Nora Albers, Mark J. Whittingham, Dylan M. Young, James W. Pearce-Higgins, Julia Martin-Ortega, Klaus Glenk, Mark S. Reed

Summary: The paper examines the importance of recreation in peatlands and the trade-offs between natural properties and recreational infrastructure. The study finds that different types of recreationists have varying landscape preferences, highlighting potential value conflicts. These conflicts need to be considered in net zero climate mitigation strategies.

LAND USE POLICY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Peatland core domain sets: building consensus on what should be measured in research and monitoring

Mark S. Reed, Dylan M. Young, Nigel G. Taylor, Roxane Andersen, Nicholle G. A. Bell, Hinsby Cadillo-Quiroz, Matthew Grainger, Andreas Heinemeyer, Kristell Hergoualc'h, Adam M. Gerrand, Johannes Kieft, Haruni Krisnawati, Erik A. Lilleskov, Gabriela Lopez-Gonzalez, Lulie Melling, Hannah Rudman, Sophie Sjogersten, Jonathan S. Walker, Gavin Stewart

Summary: Lack of data consistency among multiple studies hampers decision-making in policy and practice regarding the conservation and restoration of peatlands. This study proposes a methodological framework and discusses subsequent steps to standardize the measurement and reporting of outcomes in peatland research. These efforts contribute to the creation of reliable datasets that inform evidence-based policy and contribute to the sustainable management of globally significant carbon stores.

MIRES AND PEAT (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

The Effects of Soil Improving Cropping Systems (SICS) on Soil Erosion and Soil Organic Carbon Stocks across Europe: A Simulation Study

Jantiene E. M. Baartman, Joao Pedro Nunes, Hedwig van Delden, Roel Vanhout, Luuk Fleskens

Summary: This study used a modeling approach to evaluate the effects of Soil Improving Cropping Systems (SICS) on soil health and land degradation in Europe. The results showed that SICS significantly reduced soil erosion and increased soil organic carbon stocks.
Article Environmental Studies

Soil-Improving Cropping Systems for Sustainable and Profitable Farming in Europe

Rudi Hessel, Guido Wyseure, Ioanna S. Panagea, Abdallah Alaoui, Mark S. Reed, Hedwig van Delden, Melanie Muro, Jane Mills, Oene Oenema, Francisco Areal, Erik van den Elsen, Simone Verzandvoort, Falentijn Assinck, Annemie Elsen, Jerzy Lipiec, Aristeidis Koutroulis, Lilian O'Sullivan, Martin A. Bolinder, Luuk Fleskens, Ellen Kandeler, Luca Montanarella, Marius Heinen, Zoltan Toth, Moritz Hallama, Julian Cuevas, Jantiene E. M. Baartman, Ilaria Piccoli, Tommy Dalgaard, Jannes Stolte, Jasmine E. Black, Charlotte-Anne Chivers

Summary: Soils are essential for agriculture and ecosystem services, and their management should focus on improving quality and resilience. The SoilCare project developed the concept of soil-improving cropping systems (SICS) as a holistic approach to promote sustainable and profitable soil management. The adoption of SICS by stakeholders was monitored and evaluated for environmental, sociocultural, and economic effects. The project emphasized the importance of understanding local dynamics in Europe-wide assessments and highlighted the role of economic considerations and social factors such as trust in the uptake of SICS. The results pointed to the need for coherent policies to support a transition to more sustainable agricultural practices.
Article Environmental Studies

A New Framework to Assess Sustainability of Soil Improving Cropping Systems in Europe

Abdallah Alaoui, Moritz Hallama, Roger Baer, Ioanna Panagea, Felicitas Bachmann, Carola Pekrun, Luuk Fleskens, Ellen Kandeler, Rudi Hessel

Summary: Assessing agricultural sustainability is a challenging task that requires considering multidisciplinary factors and cultural values. This study developed a methodology to assess the sustainability of soil improving cropping systems and tested it in a case study.
Article Environmental Studies

Perceived Causes and Solutions to Soil Degradation in the UK and Norway

Niki Rust, Ole Erik Lunder, Sara Iversen, Steven Vella, Elizabeth A. Oughton, Tor Arvid Breland, Jayne H. Glass, Carly M. Maynard, Rob McMorran, Mark S. Reed

Summary: Soil quality decline is a global issue with multiple causes and no single solution. Stakeholders' opinions on managing this problem vary. Engaging with diverse stakeholders is crucial in developing socially acceptable and effective policies. A study in the UK and Norway found that stakeholders perceived causes of and solutions to soil degradation differently, with an overarching theme of industrialized agriculture being responsible. Multi-actor approaches can help improve the social acceptance of land use policies to address soil degradation.
No Data Available