Some butterflies do not care much about topography: a single genetic lineage of Erebia euryale (Nymphalidae) along the northern Iberian mountains

The phylogeography of montane species often reveals strong genetic differentiation among mountain ranges. Both classic morphological and genetic studies have indicated distinctiveness of Pyrenean populations of the butterfly Erebia euryale. This hypothesis remained inconclusive until data from the westernmost populations of the distribution area (Cantabrian Mountains) were analysed. In the present study, we set out to describe the population structure of Erebia euryale in western Cantabria, where the species occurs in scattered localities. For this goal, we estimate the genetic diversity and differentiation found in 218 individuals from six Cantabrian (North Spain) localities genotyped by 17 allozyme loci. We also sequence 816 bp of the cytochrome oxidase subunit I mitochondrial gene in 49 individuals from Cantabrian localities and 41 specimens from five other European sites. Mitochondrial data support the recognition of four major genetic groups previously suggested for the European populations based on allozyme polymorphisms. Both mitochondrial and nuclear markers reveal genetic distinctiveness of a single Pyrenean-Cantabrian lineage of E. euryale. The lack of geographical structure and the star-like topology displayed by the mitochondrial haplotypes indicate a pattern of demographic expansion in northern Iberia, probably related to Upper Pleistocene climatic oscillations. By contrast, within the Pyrenean-Cantabrian lineage, Cantabrian samples are genetically structured in nuclear datasets. In particular, San Isidro is significantly differentiated from the other five populations, which cluster into two groups. We recognize an evolutionary significant unit for Pyrenean-Cantabrian populations of Erebia euryale. Our results also illustrate that the evolutionary history of a species may be shaped by processes undetectable by using mtDNA alone.