4.3 Article

NITROGEN REMOVAL BY STORMWATER MANAGEMENT STRUCTURES: A DATA SYNTHESIS

Journal

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN WATER RESOURCES ASSOCIATION
Volume 50, Issue 6, Pages 1594-1607

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/jawr.12223

Keywords

best management practices; constructed wetland; detention pond; nitrogen removal; nutrients; performance; stormwater management; retention basin; urban areas; vegetated swale

Funding

  1. USEPA Global Change Research Program [GS-10F-0502N]
  2. National Socio-Environmental Synthesis Center (SESYNC) from NSF [DBI-1052875]
  3. Div Of Biological Infrastructure
  4. Direct For Biological Sciences [1052875] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

A comprehensive synthesis of data from empirically based published studies and a widely used stormwater best management practice (BMP) database were used to assess the variability in nitrogen (N) removal performance of urban stormwater ponds, wetlands, and swales and to identify factors that may explain this variability. While the data suggest that BMPs were generally effective on average, removal efficiencies of ammonium (NH4), nitrate (NO3), and total nitrogen (TN) were highly variable ranging from negative (i.e., BMPs acting as sources of N) to 100%. For example, removal of NO3 varied from (median +/- 1SD) -15 +/- 49% for dry ponds, 32 +/- 120% for wet ponds, 58 +/- 210% for wetlands, and 37 +/- 29% for swales. Across the same BMP types, TN removal was 27 +/- 24%, 40 +/- 31%, 61 +/- 30%, and 50 +/- 29%. NH4 removal was 9 +/- 36%, 29 +/- 72%, 31 +/- 24%, and 45 +/- 34%. BMP size, age, and location explained some of the variability. For example, small and shallow ponds and wetlands were more effective than larger, deeper ones in removing N. Despite well-known intra-annual variation in N fluxes, most measurements have been made over short time periods using concentrations, not flow-weighted N fluxes. Urban N export is increasing in some areas as large storms become more frequent. Thus, accounting for the full range of BMP performance under such conditions is crucial. A select number of long-term flux-based BMP studies that rigorously measure rainfall, hydrology, and site conditions could improve BMP implementation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Effects of Using High Resolution Satellite-Based Inundation Time Series to Estimate Methane Fluxes From Forested Wetlands

Kelly L. Hondula, Ben DeVries, C. Nathan Jones, Margaret A. Palmer

Summary: This study used satellite imagery and a methane emission model to estimate the surface water extent and diffusive methane fluxes in wetlands, showing that wetlands smaller than 1 hectare were responsible for the majority of emissions. Considering the dynamic inundation of forested wetlands resulted in 49%-62% lower emission totals compared to models using a single estimate for each wetland's size.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Ecology

The potential role of biotic interactions in stream restoration

Bridget E. White, Angus R. McIntosh, Catherine M. Febria, Helen J. Warburton

Summary: The presence of protected snails in restored stream communities can disrupt vulnerable prey populations and have long-term negative effects on predators. Additionally, mayflies appeared less on surfaces with high snail densities, potentially due to altered resource use. These biotic interactions may form a barrier to successful biotic restoration by preventing colonization of desired vulnerable prey.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effects of seasonal inundation on methane fluxes from forested freshwater wetlands

Kelly L. Hondula, C. Nathan Jones, Margaret A. Palmer

Summary: Methane emissions from small freshwater ecosystems are a major uncertainty in the global methane budget. The study found that inundation extent and duration, as well as the direction of water level change, are major drivers of methane emissions in seasonally inundated forested wetlands. Modeling the hydrologic regime of these wetlands can lead to more accurate estimation of methane emissions.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Fisheries

Hatchery crashes among shellfish research hatcheries along the Atlantic coast of the United States: A case study of production analysis at Horn Point Laboratory

Matthew W. Gray, Stephanie T. Alexander, Brian F. Beal, Tom Bliss, Colleen A. Burge, Jacob A. Cram, Michael De Luca, James Dumhart, Patricia M. Glibert, Michael Gonsior, Andrew Heyes, Klaus B. Huebert, Vyacheslav Lyubchich, Katherine McFarland, Matt Parker, Louis Plough, Eric J. Schott, Lisa A. Wainger, Gary H. Wikfors, Ami E. Wilbur

Summary: Shellfish hatcheries play a crucial role in US aquaculture production, but hatchery crashes remain a persistent and understudied problem. Through case studies and data analysis, this research aims to uncover the causes of crashes and propose potential solutions.

AQUACULTURE (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

A systematic review of the global freshwater mussel restoration toolbox

Roland A. Eveleens, Catherine M. Febria

Summary: Halting the global decline of freshwater mussels requires a better understanding of the shortcomings in current restoration methods and the development of new approaches. Evaluations of restoration efforts are limited and biased temporally and geographically, with a focus on mussel-diverse regions in North America and Europe. Efforts mainly involve population support such as relocation, translocation, and captive breeding, and future restoration approaches emphasize planning and prioritization.

AQUATIC CONSERVATION-MARINE AND FRESHWATER ECOSYSTEMS (2022)

Article Fisheries

Riparian plant species offer a range of organic resources to stream invertebrate communities through varied leaf breakdown rates

Kristy Hogsden, Sophie O'Brien, Stacey Bartlett, Helen Warburton, Hayley Devlin, Kathryn Collins, Catherine Febria, Brandon Goeller, Angus McIntosh, Jon Harding

Summary: Riparian plants provide energy for freshwater food webs through leaf litter, and planting mixed species in riparian buffers can enhance the resource supply for invertebrates. Leaf breakdown rates differ among plant species, but invertebrate colonisation is not affected, although some leaves have high abundance of consumers.

NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF MARINE AND FRESHWATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

The sustainable agriculture imperative: A perspective on the need for an agrosystem approach to meet the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals by 2030

Rene S. Shahmohamadloo, Catherine M. Febria, Evan D. G. Fraser, Paul K. Sibley

Summary: The development of modern, industrial agriculture is making agricultural landscapes less resilient, while increasing the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events due to climate change. To achieve the UN's sustainable development goals, the agriculture sector must lead in reversing negative environmental trends in today's landscapes to adapt to future climate change.

INTEGRATED ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT AND MANAGEMENT (2022)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

Early career researchers benefit from inclusive, diverse and international collaborations: Changing how academic institutions utilize the seminar series

Catherine M. Febria, Donna R. Kashian, Kory R. T. Bertrand, Brittanie Dabney, Matthew Day, Madison Dugdale, Kate O. Ekhator, Hector J. Esparra-Escalera, Ryan Graham, Keira Harshaw, Darrin S. Hunt, Savannah Knorr, Katrina Lewandowski, Colleen Linn, Allison Lucas, Scott O. C. Mundle, Gelareh Raoufi, Chelsea Salter, Zoha Siddiqua, Smita Tyagi, Megan M. Wallen

Summary: Efforts to create inclusive and diverse research environments are beneficial for the next generation of Great Lakes researchers. The COVID-19 pandemic prompted academic institutions to re-evaluate and adapt research traditions, leading to the development of virtual collaborations and partnerships to support early career researchers.

JOURNAL OF GREAT LAKES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Ecology

Mapping and assessing the knowledge base of ecological restoration

Tina Heger, Jonathan M. Jeschke, Catherine Febria, Johannes Kollmann, Stephen Murphy, Line Rochefort, Nancy Shackelford, Vicky M. Temperton, Eric Higgs

Summary: This article discusses the problem of dispersed information in restoration science and practice, and proposes the development of an interactive online platform to promote the integration of restoration science and practice. The platform will provide an overview of restoration ecology, theoretical research relevant to ecological restoration, direct links to relevant publications, and empirical evidence summaries for ecological theories in specific settings.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Physical Protection in Aggregates and Organo-Mineral Associations Contribute to Carbon Stabilization at the Transition Zone of Seasonally Saturated Wetlands

Anna I. Kottkamp, C. Nathan Jones, Margaret A. Palmer, Katherine L. Tully

Summary: Seasonally saturated wetlands play a significant role in physically protecting soil organic carbon (SOC) through the formation of macroaggregates and organic-mineral associations. Understanding the dynamics and vulnerability of SOC in wetlands is crucial in the face of climate and land use changes.

WETLANDS (2022)

Article Ecology

Integrative analysis of stressor gradients reveals multiple discrete trait-defined axes underlie community assembly

Isabelle C. Barrett, Angus R. McIntosh, Catherine M. Febria, S. Elizabeth Graham, Francis J. Burdon, Justin P. F. Pomeranz, Helen J. Warburton

Summary: This study conducted an analysis of stream macroinvertebrate communities under different stressor gradients using trait-based approaches and found that anthropogenic stressors have stronger effects on community composition compared to natural stressors. The movement of communities along multiple axes in trait space is likely driven by limited adaptation to these novel stressors.

ECOSPHERE (2022)

Book Review Multidisciplinary Sciences

If the Past Teaches, What Does the Future Learn?

Margaret A. Palmer

SCIENCE (2022)

Review Biodiversity Conservation

Ecosystem-level effects of re-oligotrophication and N:P imbalances in rivers and estuaries on a global scale

Carles Ibanez, Nuno Caiola, Jose Barquin, Oscar Belmar, Xavier Benito-Granell, Frederic Casals, Siobhan Fennessy, Jocelyne Hughes, Margaret Palmer, Josep Penuelas, Estela Romero, Jordi Sardans, Michael Williams

Summary: The decline in phosphorus and the increase in nitrogen to phosphorus ratios have resulted in re-oligotrophication in rivers and estuaries of high-income countries, while widespread eutrophication occurs in low-income countries. The biotic response and ecological effects of these changes, as well as the N:P imbalance, need further investigation. The regime shift from phytoplankton to macrophyte dominance, documented in shallow lakes, is less observed in rivers and estuaries.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Setting a reference for wetland carbon: the importance of accounting for hydrology, topography, and natural variability

Graham A. Stewart, Anna Kottkamp, Michael R. Williams, Margaret A. Palmer

Summary: Wetland soils serve as a vital carbon sink globally and play a crucial role in carbon management and accounting. However, the lack of reference information and incomplete understanding of wetland variability hinder the accurate assessment of carbon storage potential. This study aimed to quantify the variability in wetland soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks on a depressional landscape and investigate the role of hydrology and relative topography. The results indicate high variability within and among wetlands with similar characteristics, suggesting the need to explicitly address uncertainties when inferring ecosystem processes. Hydrology and relative topography were found to be important factors in explaining SOC stock variability, emphasizing the importance of considering these factors in large-scale analyses and wetland restoration efforts.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Biology

Monitoring biodiversity loss in rapidly changing Afrotropical ecosystems: an emerging imperative for governance and research

A. O. Achieng, G. B. Arhonditsis, N. Mandrak, C. Febria, B. Opaa, T. J. Coffey, F. O. Masese, K. Irvine, Z. M. Ajode, K. Obiero, J. E. Barasa, B. Kaunda-Arara

Summary: Africa is facing extensive biodiversity loss due to environmental changes, lack of data and resources, as well as insufficient capacity to implement conservation measures. The lack of harmonized indicators and databases further hinders effective policies and monitoring. The article emphasizes the importance of establishing monitoring programs to inform evidence-based decisions for ecosystem conservation and restoration in Africa.

PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2023)

No Data Available