4.3 Article

Proposed experimental test of an alternative electrodynamic theory of superconductors

Journal

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.physc.2014.10.018

Keywords

Electrodynamics of superconductors; London equations electric screening length; Kelvin probe microscopy

Ask authors/readers for more resources

An alternative form of London's electrodynamic theory of superconductors predicts that the electrostatic screening length is the same as the magnetic penetration depth. We argue that experiments performed to date do not rule out this alternative formulation and propose an experiment to test it. Experimental evidence in its favor would have fundamental implications for the understanding of superconductivity. (C) 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Physics, Applied

Thermodynamic inconsistency of the conventional theory of superconductivity

J. E. Hirsch

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MODERN PHYSICS B (2020)

Letter Multidisciplinary Sciences

Unusual width of the superconducting transition in a hydride

J. E. Hirsch, F. Marsiglio

NATURE (2021)

Article Physics, Applied

Hole superconductivity xOr hot hydride superconductivity

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: Under the influence of the BCS-electron-phonon theory, experimentalists have discovered high temperature conventional superconductors in pressurized hydrides, while theorists have been predicting and explaining these findings. However, the alternative theory of hole superconductivity suggests that no superconductivity exists in these materials.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS (2021)

Article Physics, Applied

Granular Superconductivity in Hydrides Under Pressure

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: This article points out that hysteresis in transport properties has never been reported for hydrides under pressure, and this phenomenon can determine whether they are superconductors.

JOURNAL OF SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND NOVEL MAGNETISM (2022)

Editorial Material Physics, Multidisciplinary

Absence of evidence of superconductivity in sulfur hydride in optical reflectance experiments

J. E. Hirsch, F. Marsiglio

NATURE PHYSICS (2022)

Article Physics, Applied

Superconducting materials: Judge and jury of BCS-electron-phonon theory

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: The article briefly introduces the classification of superconducting materials and the success and failure of the existing theory in describing conventional superconductors. It suggests exploring the possibility of a single theory different from the conventional theory that may describe the superconductivity of all materials.

APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS (2022)

Article Physics, Applied

Comment on On the Analysis of the Tin-Inside-H3S Mossbauer Experiment

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: Prozorov and Bud'ko analyzed the tin-inside-H3S Mossbauer experiment and concluded that it is consistent with the expected behavior of a type II superconductor. However, their analysis shows that the reported nuclear resonant scattering measurements are incompatible with the recently reported magnetization measurements.

JOURNAL OF SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND NOVEL MAGNETISM (2022)

Correction Physics, Multidisciplinary

Incompatibility of published ac magnetic susceptibility of a room temperature superconductor with measured raw data (vol 7, 048401, 2022)

J. E. Hirsch, D. van der Marel

MATTER AND RADIATION AT EXTREMES (2022)

Article Physics, Multidisciplinary

Clear evidence against superconductivity in hydrides under high pressure

J. E. Hirsch, F. Marsiglio

Summary: The Meissner effect, magnetic field expulsion, is a hallmark of superconductivity. Recent studies claimed to have found definitive evidence of the Meissner effect in sulfur hydride and lanthanum hydride under high pressure, but we argue that the evidence presented does not support the case for superconductivity in these materials. Combining previous experimental evidence, we strongly suggest that hydrides under pressure are not high-temperature superconductors.

MATTER AND RADIATION AT EXTREMES (2022)

Article Physics, Applied

Superconductivity, what the H? the emperor has no clothes

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: This article discusses the current state of superconductivity theory, the bibliometric H-index, and H.C. Andersen's tale about the emperor's new clothes. It was first published in the APS Forum on Physics and Society quarterly newsletter in January 2020.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MODERN PHYSICS B (2023)

Article Physics, Applied

Electrical Resistance of Hydrides Under High Pressure: Evidence of Superconductivity or Confirmation Bias?

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: Over the past 9 years, there has been extensive experimental evidence suggesting that hydrogen-rich materials under high pressure exhibit high-temperature superconductivity, in line with the conventional BCS-electron-phonon theory. The primary evidence comes from electrical resistance measurements, indicating significantly lower resistivity compared to the best normal metals within the limits of experimental accuracy. However, an alternative explanation is proposed to account for the vanishing resistance observed in these materials without invoking superconductivity.

JOURNAL OF SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND NOVEL MAGNETISM (2023)

Article Physics, Applied

Enormous Variation in Homogeneity and Other Anomalous Features of Room Temperature Superconductor Samples: A Comment on Nature 615, 244 (2023)

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: The resistive transition width of a newly discovered room temperature near-ambient-pressure hydride superconductor varies significantly between different samples, while the transition temperature remains almost constant. In the narrowest transitions, the transition width relative to Tc is only 0.014%. The observed behaviors, such as the vanishing critical current and unusually small normal state resistance, question the superconductivity of this system. Implications for other hydrides are also discussed.

JOURNAL OF SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND NOVEL MAGNETISM (2023)

Article Physics, Applied

On Magnetic Field Screening and Expulsion in Hydride Superconductors

J. E. Hirsch, F. Marsiglio

Summary: Reference [1] provides evidence for magnetic field screening and subtle evidence for magnetic field expulsion in hydrides under high pressure, which supports the claim that these materials are high temperature superconductors. However, we point out that the data presented in different figures of Ref. [1] are inconsistent (i) with each other, (ii) with other work by the same authors on the same samples [2, 3], and (iii) with the expected behavior of standard superconductors. This suggests that the reported magnetic phenomena for these materials are not associated with superconductivity, undermining the claim that these materials are high temperature superconductors.

JOURNAL OF SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND NOVEL MAGNETISM (2023)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

Are hydrides under high-pressure-high-temperature superconductors?

J. E. Hirsch

Summary: Contrary to the current consensus, the author argues that the existing evidence for high-temperature superconductivity in hydrides under high pressure is not convincing. The author suggests that the focus of research should urgently shift to experimentally establish whether or not superconductivity exists in pressurized hydrides, instead of searching for new materials that may show unproven superconductivity signals at higher temperatures. The implications of a negative finding for the theoretical understanding of superconductivity are discussed.

NATIONAL SCIENCE REVIEW (2023)

Article Physics, Multidisciplinary

Incompatibility of published ac magnetic susceptibility of a room temperature superconductor with measured raw data

J. E. Hirsch, D. van der Marel

Summary: This study reports the analysis results of carbonaceous sulfur hydride material, finding that the measured raw data are inconsistent with the published data. These results have significant implications for the claim that the material is a room temperature superconductor.

MATTER AND RADIATION AT EXTREMES (2022)

No Data Available