4.3 Article Proceedings Paper

What Counts as Scientific Data? A Relational Framework

Journal

PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE
Volume 82, Issue 5, Pages 810-821

Publisher

UNIV CHICAGO PRESS
DOI: 10.1086/684083

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Max Planck Institute
  2. European Research Council under the European Union [335925]
  3. European Research Council (ERC) [335925] Funding Source: European Research Council (ERC)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper proposes an account of scientific data that makes sense of recent debates on data-driven and 'big data' research, while also building on the history of data production and use particularly within biology. In this view, 'data' is a relational category applied to research outputs that are taken, at specific moments of inquiry, to provide evidence for knowledge claims of interest to the researchers involved. They do not have truth-value in and of themselves, nor can they be seen as straightforward representations of given phenomena. Rather, they are fungible objects defined by their portability and prospective usefulness as evidence.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article History & Philosophy Of Science

Where health and environment meet: the use of invariant parameters in big data analysis

Sabina Leonelli, Niccolo Tempini

Summary: This paper discusses a new approach to studying the spread of infectious diseases or the impact of the built environment on human health using big data. By maintaining basic parameters and recognizing unique perspectives, researchers can effectively link, search, and interpret diverse data. This strategy can facilitate data linkage and predictions, and support public health efforts, while also acknowledging the limitations of data linkage and predictive power.

SYNTHESE (2021)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

Data - from objects to assets

Sabina Leonelli

NATURE (2019)

Article Plant Sciences

How to build an effective research network: lessons from two decades of the GARNet plant science community

Geraint Parry, Yoselin Benitez-Alfonso, Daniel J. Gibbs, Murray Grant, Andrea Harper, C. Jill Harrison, Eirini Kaiserli, Sabina Leonelli, Sean May, Sarah McKim, Steven Spoel, Colin Turnbull, Renier A. L. van der Hoorn, James Murray

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL BOTANY (2020)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Actionable data for precision oncology: Framing trustworthy evidence for exploratory research and clinical diagnostics

Niccolo Tempini, Sabina Leonelli

Summary: This paper examines the actionability and trust of genomic data in medical research, discussing the case of COSMIC as a leading cancer genomics database and comparing exploratory and diagnostics research. Researchers highlight various questions and concerns when using genomic data in different situations, while also acknowledging similarities in evaluation and re-use strategies.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2021)

Editorial Material Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The changing climates of global health

Thomas Cousins, Michelle Pentecost, Alexandra Alvergne, Clare Chandler, Simukai Chigudu, Clare Herrick, Ann Kelly, Sabina Leonelli, Javier Lezaun, Jamie Lorimer, David Reubi, Sharifah Sekalala

BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH (2021)

Editorial Material History & Philosophy Of Science

Open science, data sharing and solidarity: who benefits?

Ciara Staunton, Carlos Andres Barragan, Stefano Canali, Calvin Ho, Sabina Leonelli, Matthew Mayernik, Barbara Prainsack, Ambroise Wonkham

Summary: Research, innovation, and progress in the life sciences increasingly rely on access to large amounts of data, driving the open science movement and global initiatives to promote the sharing of personal data, datasets, and research findings. This paper discusses the outcomes of a panel discussion on open science and data sharing, highlighting the importance of solidarity and mutual benefits in fostering collaboration in the field.

HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF THE LIFE SCIENCES (2021)

Article History & Philosophy Of Science

Open Science and Epistemic Diversity: Friends or Foes?

Sabina Leonelli

Summary: The current conceptualization and implementation of Open Science do not adequately consider epistemic diversity within research. Through three case studies, it is shown that Open Science tends to favor certain forms of inquiry, exacerbating divides within and across systems of practice and overlooking important sources and forms of epistemic diversity.

PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE (2022)

Editorial Material History & Philosophy Of Science

Introduction: biomedical knowledge in a time of COVID-19

Sabina Leonelli

HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF THE LIFE SCIENCES (2022)

Article History & Philosophy Of Science

Accelerating agriculture: Data-intensive plant breeding and the use of genetic gain as an indicator for agricultural research and development

Hugh F. Williamson, Sabina Leonelli

Summary: In recent years, accelerating the rate of genetic gain has become a key objective in plant breeding for the Global South. This concept relies on new data technologies and aims to enhance the cost efficiency of breeding programs. This paper explores the implications of pursuing genetic gain as an indicator of agricultural development, including changes in knowledge-control regimes of plant breeding, social and political consequences for smallholder farmers, and climate-adaptive agriculture. It concludes that genetic gain should not be considered the primary indicator of agricultural development without considering other key areas and tools to evaluate the pros and cons of its adoption.

STUDIES IN HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE (2022)

Article Social Issues

Evincing Offence: How Digital Forensics Turns Big Data into Evidence for Policing Sexual Abuse

Brian Rappert, Hannah Wheat, Dana Wilson-Kovacs, Sabina Leonelli

Summary: This article examines the resources and labor required to convert digital footprints into evidence for the possession of indecent images through in-depth observations and interviews with four police forces in England. The study highlights the complexity of the interrelation between expertise and roles in digital forensics, and raises questions about the descriptive and normative adequacies of prevalent theories of objectivity in this field.

ENGAGING SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY (2022)

Letter Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Large language models challenge the future of higher education

Silvia Milano, Joshua A. McGrane, Sabina Leonelli

NATURE MACHINE INTELLIGENCE (2023)

Article Social Sciences, Interdisciplinary

From FAIR data to fair data use: Methodological data fairness in health-related social media research

Sabina Leonelli, Rebecca Lovell, Benedict W. Wheeler, Lora Fleming, Hywel Williams

Summary: The paper raises concerns about the reliability and ethics of using social media data for health-related research, emphasizing the importance of methodological data fairness and providing practical steps for ensuring scientific and ethical outcomes. Failure to address these concerns may lead to serious ethical, methodological, and epistemic issues in the knowledge and evidence being produced.

BIG DATA & SOCIETY (2021)

Article History

Mobilizing the Transnational History of Knowledge Flows. COVID-19 and the Politics of Research at the Borders

John Krige, Sabina Leonelli

Summary: This paper advocates for transnational cooperation to combat national protectionism, focusing on digital technology governance and data sharing, emphasizing interdependence. Through two case studies, it showcases the emergence of transnational realms of scientific and political cooperation, and explores the importance of transnational knowledge flows.

HISTORY AND TECHNOLOGY (2021)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

The Ontologies Community of Practice: A CGIAR Initiative for Big Data in Agrifood Systems

Elizabeth Arnaud, Marie-Angelique Laporte, Soonho Kim, Celine Aubert, Sabina Leonelli, Berta Miro, Laurel Cooper, Pankaj Jaiswal, Gideon Kruseman, Rosemary Shrestha, Pier Luigi Buttigieg, Christopher J. Mungall, Julian Pietragalla, Afolabi Agbona, Jacqueline Muliro, Jeffrey Detras, Vilma Hualla, Abhishek Rathore, Roma Rani Das, Ibnou Dieng, Guillaume Bauchet, Naama Menda, Cyril Pommier, Felix Shaw, David Lyon, Leroy Mwanzia, Henry Juarez, Enrico Bonaiuti, Brian Chiputwa, Olatunbosun Obileye, Sandrine Auzoux, Esther Dzale Yeumo, Lukas A. Mueller, Kevin Silverstein, Alexandra Lafargue, Erick Antezana, Medha Devare, Brian King

PATTERNS (2020)

Article History & Philosophy Of Science

How to choose your research organism

Michael R. Dietrich, Rachel A. Ankeny, Nathan Crowe, Sara Green, Sabina Leonelli

STUDIES IN HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE PART C-STUDIES IN HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF BIOLOGICAL AND BIOMEDICAL SCIENCES (2020)

No Data Available