4.7 Article

Modeling salt accumulation in osmotic membrane bioreactors: Implications for FO membrane selection and system operation

Journal

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE
Volume 366, Issue 1-2, Pages 314-324

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.memsci.2010.10.023

Keywords

Salt accumulation; Forward osmosis (FO); Osmotic membrane bioreactor (OMBR); Solute reverse diffusion; Volumetric concentration factor

Funding

  1. Environment & Water Industry Development Council of Singapore (EWI) [MEWR C651/06/173 (EWI0901-02-01)]
  2. Nanyang Technological University

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Novel osmotic membrane bioreactors (OMBRs) have been recently reported in the literature. An OMBR uses a dense salt-rejecting forward osmosis (FO) membrane, which exhibits high retention of organic matter and various other contaminants. Meanwhile, the high rejection nature also leads to the accumulation of salts in the bioreactor, which can adversely affect the biological activities as well as the FO water flux. A salt accumulation model is developed in the current study. Our model suggests that both the bioreactor salt concentration and the FO water flux are controlled by membrane properties (water permeability A, salt permeability B, mass transfer coefficient K-m. and membrane orientation relative to the draw solution) and the OMBR operational conditions (salt concentration of the influent wastewater, draw solution concentration, hydraulic retention time (HRT), and sludge retention time (SRT)). The salt accumulation is contributed by both the influent wastewater and the reverse diffusion of solutes from the draw solution, and is directly proportional to the volumetric concentration factor (i.e., the SRT/HRT ratio). The relative importance of reverse diffusion over contribution from influent solutes is governed by the membrane selectivity. For a relatively selective membrane (B/A << the osmotic pressure of the influent water), solute reverse diffusion has negligible effect on OMBR performance. In contrast, the salt accumulation and FO water flux reduction are governed by reverse diffusion for B/A greater than the osmotic pressure of the influent water. The current study reveals the critical importance of the B/A ratio and HRT/SRT ratio for optimized OMBR operation. (C) 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Environmental

Robust polyamide-PTFE hollow fibre membranes for harsh organic solvent nanofiltration

Verona Nithya Francis, Jeng Yi Chong, Guoying Yang, Lei Che, Rong Wang

Summary: This study successfully synthesized polyamide-PTFE thin film composite (TFC) membranes with excellent chemical resistance to strong solvents by using polytetrafluomethylene (PTFE) as the substrate and a simple modification and coating technique. These membranes showed high permeabilities and good rejection rates, demonstrating their great potential in molecular separation in harsh solvents.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Choice of DLVO approximation method for quantifying the affinity between latex particles and membranes

Huang Teik Lay, Chi Siang Ong, Rong Wang, Jia Wei Chew

Summary: The study demonstrates that the DLVO approximation methods used to predict interfacial foulant-membrane interactions are sensitive to the boundary condition assumptions. Both the Poisson-Boltzmann (P-B) and linear superposition approximation (LSA) equations can quantify electrostatic interaction energy, but the LSA equation provides more accurate predictions in various filtration tests.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Reactivity of various brominating agents toward polyamide nanofiltration membranes

Huihui Zhao, Linyan Yang, Xueming Chen, Jinrui Wang, Lichun Bai, Guomin Cao, Lankun Cai, Chuyang Y. Tang

Summary: Polyamide (PA) membranes used in reverse osmosis and nanofiltration can be degraded by bromination under chlorinated bromide-containing water conditions. This study addresses the misconception that only hypobromous acid (HOBr) is responsible for membrane degradation, while other more reactive but less abundant brominating agents are often overlooked. The findings show that the rate of membrane degradation is strongly correlated with bromide, chloride, and hypochlorous acid concentrations.

SEPARATION AND PURIFICATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Ionic resource recovery for carbon neutral papermaking wastewater reclamation by a chemical self-sufficiency zero liquid discharge system

Yangbo Qiu, Sifan Wu, Lei Xia, Long-Fei Ren, Jiahui Shao, Jiangnan Shen, Zhe Yang, Chuyang Y. Tang, Chao Wu, Bart Van der Bruggen, Yan Zhao

Summary: The papermaking industry generates large amounts of wastewater and waste gas, and their treatment often involves the use of chemicals, lacks resource recovery, and consumes high amounts of energy. In this study, a chemical self-sufficiency zero liquid discharge (ZLD) system called NF-BMED-MC was designed to recover resources from papermaking wastewater and waste gas. This integrated system has shown great synergy by utilizing nanofiltration, bipolar membrane electrodialysis, and membrane contactor technologies. It enables the recovery of NaCl, generation of HCl/NaOH, and CO2 capture, while achieving efficient water recovery and resource purification without the need for additional chemicals. The study also demonstrates the potential of NF-BMED-MC as a sustainable alternative for the ZLD treatment of papermaking industry discharges.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Hydrogel-regulated interfacial polymerization: A gateway to effective nanostructure tuning of polyamide nanofiltration membranes

Dong Wang, Na Zhang, Jiaojiao Zhang, Yuyao Qin, Sen Wang, Chuyang Y. Tang, Zhining Wang

Summary: This study presents a simple and versatile method to prepare novel polyamide nanofiltration membranes via a hydrogel-assisted interfacial polymerization process. The diffusion of piperazine was precisely controlled by adjusting the hydrogel composition and crosslinking degree, resulting in the formation of a thin film composite membrane with improved water permeance and Na2SO4 rejection due to the synergistic effect of decreased thickness and improved surface hydrophilicity.

DESALINATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Polyelectrolyte-assisted interfacial polymerization for polyamide nanofiltration membrane with enhanced separation and anti-biofouling properties in groundwater treatment

Ying Mei, Zhe Yang, Peng-Fei Sun, Shenghua Zhou, Hao Guo, Lu Elfa Peng, Zhikan Yao, Wulin Yang, Chuyang Y. Tang

Summary: We proposed a facile method of using polyelectrolyte additive to tune interfacial polymerization reaction and tailor polyamide NF membrane with better separation performance and lower bio-fouling potential for groundwater treatment. The fabricated TFC-P6 membrane possessed enhanced water permeance and better selectivity which can be beneficial to achieve higher water recovery compared to the control TFC membrane. In addition, the TFC-P6 membrane demonstrated enhanced rejection of perfluorooctane sulfonate and the biofouling was inhibited by its additional negative charge and smoother surface.

DESALINATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Kinetics of support-free interfacial polymerization polyamide films by in-situ absorbance spectroscopy

Jaleh Mansouri, Shiyang Huang, Anthony Agostino, Rhiannon P. Kuchel, Greg Leslie, Chuyang Y. Tang, Anthony G. Fane

Summary: Understanding the kinetics of interfacial polymerization (IP) reaction is crucial for tailoring the characteristics and performance of reverse osmosis (RO) membranes. In this study, the kinetic behavior and film characteristics of polyamide (PA) film formation by IP reaction between M-phenylenediamine (MPD) and trimesoyl chloride (TMC) were investigated using the absorbance spectroscopy (AS) method in real-time. The results showed that monomer concentration and reaction time significantly influenced the kinetics of the IP reaction. The study confirmed the potential of the AS method for predicting the characteristics and optimizing the conditions of IP to achieve customized RO and nanofiltration (NF) membranes.

DESALINATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Stability of layer-by-layer nanofiltration membranes in highly saline streams

Jiarui Chen, Shanshan Xu, Chuyang Y. Tang, Binjie Hu, Begum Tokay, Tao He

Summary: Layer-by-layer (LBL) assembly is an important method for preparing nanofiltration (NF) membranes with tunable charge and pore size, high water permeability, and good anti-fouling properties. However, LBL NF membranes suffer from salinity instability in highly saline solutions. This review analyzes the physical and chemical principles of LBL assembly related to the salinity stability of LBL NF membranes, and proposes methods to improve their stability.

DESALINATION (2023)

Article Automation & Control Systems

A Self-Adaptive-Step-Size Incremental-Resistance-MPPT Technique for Reverse-Electrodialysis System

Zhihong Yan, Ying Huang, Siew-Chong Tan, Chuyang Y. Tang, Shu Yuen Hui

Summary: In this article, a self-adaptive-step-size incremental-resistance MPPT technique is proposed to extract maximum power from RED stacks. It is simple and easy to implement, and realizes a balance between fast dynamic responses and small oscillations at a steady state. Various tests are conducted to validate the effectiveness of the proposed MPPT technique.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Modeling nanovoid-enhanced water permeance of thin film composite membranes

Yaowen Hu, Fei Wang, Zhe Yang, Chuyang Y. Tang

Summary: Nanovoids in polyamide layers significantly influence the roughness structures and water permeance of thin film composite (TFC) reverse osmosis (RO) and nanofiltration (NF) membranes. This study investigates water transport behaviors in a polyamide layer with or without nanovoids through numerical simulations and also develops an analytical model to quantify the competition between substrate-induced unfavorable funnel effect and nanovoid-induced favorable multi-effects. The modeling results demonstrate that even tiny nanovoids can minimize water transport distance and enhance the membrane permeance by 1-2 orders of magnitude.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Multi-layer structure toward simultaneous enhancement of forward osmosis membrane separation performance and anti-biofouling property

Peng-Fei Sun, Pulak Sarkar, Eun-Tae Yun, Jeong Hoon Lee, Chuyang Y. Tang, Hee-Deung Park

Summary: Biofouling is a critical issue in membrane-based water treatment processes. A thin-film nanocomposite membrane with a multilayer structure consisting of an MXene/CNT interlayer and a CNT back layer was fabricated to mitigate biofouling. The CNT back layer possessed superior antibiofilm properties and effectively prevented bacteria from entering the porous substrate, resulting in excellent resistance to biofouling.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

In Situ Utilization of Iron Flocs after Fe3+ Coagulation Enhances H2O2 Chemical Cleaning to Eliminate Viruses and Mitigate Ultrafiltration Membrane Fouling

Zixiao Ren, Huicong Shi, Jie Zeng, Xu He, Guibai Li, Huu Hao Ngo, Jun Ma, Chuyang Y. Y. Tang, An Ding

Summary: Viruses in the effluent and on the membrane during UF processes pose hidden biosecurity risks to drinking water. Fe3+ coagulation combined with H2O2 creates an in situ membrane cleaning method, and MS2 bacteriophage was used to investigate virus removal in the presence of humic acid (HA). The study found that HA removed MS2 based on size exclusion, hydrophobicity, and electrostatic repulsion, while Fe3+ pretreatment eliminated MS2 by iron floc adsorption and size exclusion, and iron flocs-H2O2 cleaning completely eliminated MS2. The study provides a potentially useful and cost-saving membrane cleaning method for virus-containing water treatment.

ACS ES&T WATER (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Precise Regulation of Monomer Reactive Sites Enhances the Water Permeance and Membrane Selectivity of Polyamide Nanofiltration Membranes

Ke Jiang, Li Long, Lu Elfa Peng, Zhe Yang, Wenyu Liu, Dong-Myeong Shin, Chuyang Y. Tang

Summary: Polyamide structure and chemistry are crucial for the separation performance of thin-film composite nanofiltration membranes. By regulating reactive sites on monomers, the properties of polyamide and membrane performance can be precisely tailored, resulting in improved water permeance and solute selectivity. This study provides new insights into developing high-performance nanofiltration membranes.

INDUSTRIAL & ENGINEERING CHEMISTRY RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Precisely regulated in-plane pore sizes of Co-MOF nanosheet membranes for efficient dye recovery

Li Wang, Meng Zhang, Yufei Shu, Qi Han, Beizhao Chen, Bei Liu, Zhongying Wang, Chuyang Y. Tang

Summary: This study presents a new approach for efficient and selective dye recovery from highly saline textile waters using Co-MOF nanosheet membranes. The membranes exhibit superior permeance and selectivity due to their precisely regulated in-plane pore sizes. The Co-MOF membranes have high selectivity for salts over dye and exhibit excellent pure water permeance and high rejection of dyes. The in-plane pores on the nanosheets are responsible for the remarkable permeability and selectivity of the membranes.

DESALINATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Guanidinium manipulated interfacial polymerization for polyamide nanofiltration membranes with ultra-high permselectivity

Shuting Xu, Jiahuan Liu, Jianqiang Wang, Haibo Lin, Qiu Han, Fu Liu, Chuyang Y. Tang

Summary: This study presents a new method for preparing polyamide nanofiltration membranes with high permeability and selectivity by introducing guanidil into the reaction. The membranes exhibited excellent water permeance and rejection of Na2SO4, as well as outstanding anion sieving capability and tetracycline removal. This convenient and scalable preparation strategy holds great application potential in desalination and resource recovery.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

r-HGO/MXene composite membrane with enhanced permeability and rejection performance for water treatment

Jiawei Hou, Shixuan Guo, Nigel Graham, Wenzheng Yu, Kening Sun, Ting Liu

Summary: A novel 2D composite membrane based on r-HGO and MXene materials was developed, demonstrating exceptional performance for water treatment in terms of permeability, pollutant rejection, and physical stability. The optimization of preparation conditions and material proportions can result in high water flux and efficient removal of pollutants.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Designing a multifunctional TFC membrane with improved permeability and anti-biofouling performance using zwitterionic, quaternary ammonium, and fluorinated materials

Rui Gao, Caihong Liu, Andreia F. Faria, Qiang He, Chun Yang, Jun Ma

Summary: A novel copolymer architecture has been developed to address biofouling concerns in thin-film composite (TFC) membranes by integrating anti-fouling, bactericidal, and fouling-release functions. The multifunctional membrane demonstrates promising anti-adhesive properties, self-cleaning ability, and high flux recovery rate.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Defect-free asymmetric Matrimid® gas separation membranes using dihydrolevoglucosenone (Cyrene™) as a greener polar aprotic solvent than traditional solvents

Alexander T. Bridge, Noah P. Wamble, Matthew S. Santoso, Joan F. Brennecke, Benny D. Freeman

Summary: This study demonstrates the reproducible preparation of high-flux defect-free asymmetric gas separation membranes using Cyrene(TM) as a majority dope formulation component. By adjusting the volume ratios of Cyrene(TM) and THF, as well as the concentrations of Matrimid(R) and the dry step time, optimal membrane performance is achieved.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Nanofiber composite ultrafiltration membrane functionalized with cross-linked β-cyclodextrin for steroid hormone micropollutant removal

Alessandra Imbrogno, Han Ya Lin, Babak Minofar, Andrea Iris Schaefer

Summary: In this study, a composite nanofiber membrane containing cross-linked beta-cyclodextrin-epichlorohydrin was prepared and evaluated for the removal of steroid hormones. The results showed that the membrane had high adsorption capacity and the ability to form a specific inclusion complex interaction with the hormones, indicating its potential application in hormone removal.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Modeling the flux of volatile fatty acid in a membrane distillation with the effect of pH

Bora Shin, Jaewon Shin, Yanuar Chandra Wirasembada, Ki Young Park, Jinwoo Cho

Summary: This study develops a mathematical model to estimate the initial flux of volatile fatty acids in the direct contact membrane distillation process. It identifies the parameters affecting the flux and their relationship with pH.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Plasma-engineered GQD-inorganic membranes with tunable interactions for ultrahigh-efficiency molecular separations

Yi-Jui Yeh, Jr Rong Liou, Wei Lin, Kuo-Lun Tung, Wei-Hung Chiang

Summary: This study demonstrates an effective plasma engineering method to create nitrogen-doped graphene quantum dot (NGQD)-inorganic nanocomposites for tunable molecular separation. The composite materials show high separation efficiency and controllable nanopore structures, making them potentially valuable for various applications.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Water vapor sorption and transport in carbon molecular sieve membranes

Horacio Lopez-Marques, Kristofer L. Gleason, Manuel Aguilar-Vega, Rita Sulub-Sulub, J. Ehren Eichler, Hyeonji Oh, C. Buddie Mullins, Benny D. Freeman, Manish Kumar

Summary: In this study, water transport properties in Carbon Molecular Sieve (CMS) membranes were investigated. It was found that membranes synthesized at different pyrolysis temperatures exhibited varying water permeabilities. Compared to other polymeric materials, CMS membranes showed high water permeability, indicating potential for dehydration applications.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Vinyl-addition polynorbornenes with glycerol and diethylene glycol moieties: Synthesis and structure-property study

Dmitry A. Alentiev, Roman Yu. Nikiforov, Marina A. Rudakova, Danil P. Zarezin, Maxim A. Topchiy, Andrey F. Asachenko, Nikolay A. Belov, Maxim Bermeshev

Summary: A series of new norbornene-type monomers containing linear and branched substituents were synthesized, and robust thin membranes were prepared by vinyl-addition polymerization. Gas separation performance for the synthesized polymers was evaluated, and the structure of substituent side chains was found to significantly affect gas permeability and CO2 facilitated transport.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Hydrogel electrolyte membrane with regulated pore effect to stabilize zinc anode in aqueous zinc-ion batteries

Lei Yan, Qi Zhang, Ze Zhang, Gui-Jie Li, Yi Jin, Xin-Lin Zhang, Yan-Yun Sun

Summary: In this study, a continuous, stable and fast ion transport channel was established through in-situ guided cross-linking of zinc alginate hydrogels on a porous membrane, overcoming the negative pore effect and effectively inhibiting the dendrite growth of zinc anodes and interfacial side reactions.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Fabrication of an ultra-thin and ordered SPEEK proton exchange membrane by a Langmuir-Blodgett self-assembly process

Yuqing Zhang, Ailing Zhang, Huiyang He, Yuting Fan, Yongjiang Li, Song Wang, Sanxi Li

Summary: The Langmuir-Blodgett self-assembly process is used to create an ordered SPEEK membrane, which enhances the proton conductivity by three times compared to conventional solution casting method.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Estimating Gas Sorption In Polymeric Membranes From The Molecular Structure: A Machine Learning Based Group Contribution Method For The Non-Equilibrium Lattice Fluid Model (ML-GC-NELF)

Hasan Ismaeel, David Gibson, Eleonora Ricci, Maria Grazia De Angelis

Summary: In this study, a machine learning-based group contribution method (ML-GC) was developed to predict pure polymer parameters and successfully applied to predict gas solubility and gas solubility isotherms in glassy polymeric membranes. The model showed satisfactory performance on a small dataset, but has the potential to provide more accurate predictions for a wider range of polymers as more data becomes available.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Angular vibrations for fouling control during ultrafiltration of microalgae in a spiral wound module

Yi Ji, Yu Sun, Huilin Li, Qiang Fu, Yan Zhang

Summary: Previous studies have shown that vibration- or rotation-based techniques can effectively mitigate fouling during membrane filtration. However, it is difficult to incorporate these techniques with spiral wound modules (SWMs) widely used in water and wastewater treatment. This study developed a prototype membrane system to accommodate angular vibrations with a modified SWM, and experimental results showed that applying angular vibrations can effectively control algal fouling in an SWM with lower energy consumption compared to traditional methods.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Polyphenol-coated hollow fiber system for energy-efficient dehumidification in air-conditioning

Lakshmeesha Upadhayaya, Abaynesh Yihdego Gebreyohannes, Muhammad Wakil Shahzad, Usman T. Syed, Sandra L. Aristizabal, Radoslaw Gorecki, Suzana P. Nunes

Summary: Increasing temperatures worldwide pose a significant health risk, exacerbated by high humidity. Conventional air conditioners contribute heavily to carbon dioxide emissions, with dehumidification being a major factor. Membrane-based dehumidification system offers energy efficiency and non-toxic water vapor removal. This study demonstrates a membrane dehumidification system with polymeric hollow fibers coated with a green polyphenol coating, showing remarkable water vapor transport rate and selectivity. Long-term testing reveals minimal decline in vapor transport and a 4-5 times higher coefficient of performance (COP) compared to conventional dehumidifiers, making it a highly competitive, energy-saving device with reduced emissions and a smaller footprint.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)

Article Engineering, Chemical

A facile method to fabricate anti-fouling nanofiltration membrane with aminated lignin

Zhengzhong Zhou, Xue Zhu, Yi Yuan, Shaoqiang Wang, Xiaoshan Meng, Taoli Huhe, Qian Wang

Summary: In this study, lignin, a biomass material, was chemically modified and utilized in the interfacial polymerization process to improve the performance of nanofiltration membranes. The modified membranes showed enhanced hydrophilicity and anti-fouling properties, and the optimization of membrane pore size increased permeability. The study also demonstrated the potential application of the membranes in biogas slurry valorization.

JOURNAL OF MEMBRANE SCIENCE (2024)