4.3 Article

Achieving online consent to participation in large-scale gene-environment studies: a tangible destination

Journal

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ETHICS
Volume 37, Issue 8, Pages 487-492

Publisher

B M J PUBLISHING GROUP
DOI: 10.1136/jme.2010.040352

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Welsh Assembly Government

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background Population based genetics studies are dependent on large numbers of individuals in the pursuit of small effect sizes. Recruiting and consenting a large number of participants is both costly and time consuming. We explored whether an online consent process for large-scale genetics studies is acceptable for prospective participants using an example online genetics study. Methods We conducted semi-structured interviews with 42 members of the public stratified by age group, gender and newspaper readership (a measure of social status). Respondents were asked to use a website designed to recruit for a large-scale genetic study. After using the website a semi-structured interview was conducted to explore opinions and any issues they would have. Responses were analysed using thematic content analysis. Results The majority of respondents said they would take part in the research (32/42). Those who said they would decline to participate saw fewer benefits from the research, wanted more information and expressed a greater number of concerns about the study. Younger respondents had concerns over time commitment. Middle aged respondents were concerned about privacy and security. Older respondents were more altruistic in their motivation to participate. Common themes included trust in the authenticity of the website, security of personal data, curiosity about their own genetic profile, operational concerns and a desire for more information about the research. Conclusions Online consent to large-scale genetic studies is likely to be acceptable to the public. The online consent process must establish trust quickly and effectively by asserting authenticity and credentials, and provide access to a range of information to suit different information preferences.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Potential impact of encounter patient decision aids on the patient-clinician dialogue: a qualitative study on Dutch and American medical specialists' experiences

Ester A. Rake, Dunja Dreesens, Kristie Venhorst, Marjan J. Meinders, Tessa Geltink, Jenny T. Wolswinkel, Michelle Dannenberg, Jan A. M. Kremer, Glyn Elwyn, Johanna W. M. Aarts

Summary: A study was conducted to examine the impact of using encounter patient decision aids (ePDAs) on the clinical practice of Dutch and American clinicians. The findings showed that ePDAs had several impacts on the patient-clinician dialogue. Based on clinicians' experiences, recommendations were made to improve ePDA use, such as adding pictorial health information and providing flexible and personalized instructions for clinicians.

BMJ OPEN (2022)

Article Psychology, Clinical

Perceived threat of COVID-19, attitudes towards vaccination, and vaccine hesitancy: A prospective longitudinal study in the UK

Rhiannon Phillips, David Gillespie, Britt Hallingberg, Jennifer Evans, Khadijeh Taiyari, Anna Torrens-Burton, Rebecca Cannings-John, Denitza Williams, Elizabeth Sheils, Pauline Ashfield-Watt, Ashley Akbari, Kathryn Hughes, Emma Thomas-Jones, Delyth James, Fiona Wood

Summary: Using the Health Belief Model, this study examined the attitudes towards COVID-19, COVID-19 vaccinations, and vaccine hesitancy in a UK cohort over a 9-month period. The results showed a decrease in fear of COVID-19, perceived susceptibility to the disease, and perceived personal control over reducing infection-transmission. Vaccine hesitancy was associated with low fear of the disease and more negative attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccination.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Review Substance Abuse

Tobacco use, smoking identities and pathways into and out of smoking among young adults: a meta-ethnography

Ria Poole, Hannah Carver, Despina Anagnostou, Adrian Edwards, Graham Moore, Pamela Smith, Fiona Wood, Kate Brain

Summary: This meta-ethnography explores how young adults perceive and engage in tobacco use, as well as their motivations for smoking and barriers to quitting. The findings suggest that smoking is often seen as a means of stress relief, identity transformation, and coping with life transitions among young adults. It is also used as a tool for social acceptance and resistance, particularly in marginalized communities. The study highlights the importance of designing health interventions that are tailored to the needs and desires of young adults, addressing both smoking prevention and harm reduction strategies.

SUBSTANCE ABUSE TREATMENT PREVENTION AND POLICY (2022)

Article Gastroenterology & Hepatology

Bidirectional Correlations Between Health Confidence and Inflammatory Bowel Disease Activity: A Nationwide Longitudinal Cohort Study

Chung Sang Tse, Gil Y. Melmed, Corey A. Siegel, Chien-Hsiang Weng, Samir A. Shah, S. Alandra Weaver, Brant J. Oliver, Glyn Elwyn, Welmoed K. van Deen

Summary: Health confidence has bidirectional temporal correlations with inflammatory bowel disease activity, where low health confidence is associated with higher risks for future disease activity.

INFLAMMATORY BOWEL DISEASES (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Unpacking the 'black box of horrendousness': a qualitative exploration of the barriers and facilitators to conducting trials involving adults lacking capacity to consent

Victoria Shepherd, Kerenza Hood, Fiona Wood

Summary: This study explores the barriers and facilitators to conducting trials involving adults lacking capacity to consent. The researchers found several inter-related obstacles and facilitators, and emphasize the urgent need for greater access to expertise and training, as well as the development of supportive interventions and tailored guidance for future trials involving this under-served population.

TRIALS (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Co-Development of a Web Application (COVID-19 Social Site) for Long-Term Care Workers (Something for Us): User-Centered Design and Participatory Research Study

Catherine H. Saunders, Ailyn Sierpe, Gabrielle Stevens, Glyn Elwyn, Matthew Cantrell, Jaclyn Engel, Melissa Gonzalez, Martha Hayward, Joellen Huebner, Lisa Johnson, Alejandro Jimenez, Nancy Ruth Little, Corinne McKenna, Manu Onteeru, May Oo Khine, Jacqueline Pogue, Jose Luis Salinas Vargas, Peter Schmidt, Rachael Thomeer, Marie -Anne Durand

Summary: By using a user-centric and participatory research approach, an accessible social media application has been developed to increase vaccine confidence among long-term care workers (LTCWs) for COVID-19 vaccines. The application provides curated content specifically targeting LTCWs and includes an online community for discussion and engagement.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Development of a measure to assess the quality of proxy decisions about research participation on behalf of adults lacking capacity to consent: the Combined Scale for Proxy Informed Consent Decisions (CONCORD scale)

Victoria Shepherd, Kerenza Hood, Katie Gillies, Fiona Wood

Summary: A new measure called the CONCORD scale has been developed to evaluate the quality of decisions made by proxy decision-makers on behalf of adults without the capacity to consent in non-emergency settings. Initial evaluation indicates that the scale has content adequacy and feasibility for use.

TRIALS (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Recruitment interventions for trials involving adults lacking capacity to consent: methodological and ethical considerations for designing Studies Within a Trial (SWATs)

Victoria Shepherd, Fiona Wood, Katie Gillies, Abby O'Connell, Adam Martin, Kerenza Hood

Summary: This article introduces an intervention aimed at recruiting adults lacking capacity to consent and evaluates its effectiveness using Studies Within Trials (SWATs). The authors discuss the methodological and ethical considerations encountered when designing such SWATs and propose potential solutions.

TRIALS (2022)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

Development of a core outcome set for the evaluation of interventions to prevent COVID-19 in care homes (COS-COVID-PCARE Study)

Victoria Shepherd, Ishrat Islam, Fiona Wood, Paula R. Williamson, Claire Goodman, Philip M. Bath, Carl Thompson, Martin Knapp, Adam L. Gordon, Kerenza Hood

Summary: The study aimed to develop a core outcome set (COS) for trials assessing the effectiveness of pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions for preventing COVID-19 infection and transmission in care homes.

BMC GERIATRICS (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Between- and Within-Individual Sociodemographic and Psychological Determinants of PrEP Adherence Among Men Who have Sex with Men Prescribed a Daily PrEP Regimen in Wales

David Gillespie, Marijn de Bruin, Dyfrig A. Hughes, Richard Ma, Adam Williams, Fiona Wood, Zoe Couzens, Adam Jones, Kerenza Hood

Summary: This study investigated the factors influencing the use of PrEP and the coverage of condomless anal sex (CAS) by PrEP among men who have sex with men in Wales, UK. The results showed that an STI diagnosis was associated with lower PrEP use and coverage, while older adults had higher PrEP use. Believing that other PrEP users took PrEP as prescribed was associated with lower PrEP coverage. These findings suggest that an STI diagnosis can be an important cue for interventions to improve PrEP coverage, and provide a basis for developing evidence-informed interventions to promote PrEP coverage.

AIDS AND BEHAVIOR (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The relationship between HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis, sexually transmitted infections, and antimicrobial resistance: a qualitative interview study of men who have sex with men

Adam Dale Newman Williams, Fiona Wood, David Gillespie, Zoe Couzens, Kathryn Hughes, Kerenza Hood

Summary: MSM in Wales have positive views and good knowledge of PrEP and bacterial STIs. Despite concerns about reduced condom use, condom use behaviors remain stable in relation to PrEP initiation. PrEP use is primarily driven by HIV concern and shows minimal association with awareness of resistant STIs.

BMC PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Feasibility, effectiveness and costs of a decision support intervention for consultees and legal representatives of adults lacking capacity to consent (CONSULT): protocol for a randomised Study Within a Trial

Victoria Shepherd, Fiona Wood, Katie Gillies, Adam Martin, Abby O'Connell, Kerenza Hood

Summary: This study describes a research protocol for evaluating the effectiveness of a decision aid tool in supporting families making decisions for adults lacking capacity to consent in trials. The study uses a randomized controlled design embedded in multiple trials, with an emphasis on assessing intervention effects in a variety of contexts. Process evaluation and economic evaluation will provide insights into factors influencing implementation of the decision aid tool.

TRIALS (2022)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

The limits of shared decision making

Glyn Elwyn, Amy Price, Juan Victor Ariel Franco, Pal Gulbrandsen

BMJ EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE (2023)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

Multi-cancer Early Detection Tests, Primary Care, and Shared Decision Making

Kevin Selby, Glyn Elwyn, Robert J. Volk

ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Monitoring and Managing Lifestyle Behaviors Using Wearable Activity Trackers: Mixed Methods Study of Views From the Huntington Disease Community

Philippa Morgan-Jones, Annabel Jones, Monica Busse, Laura Mills, Philip Pallmann, Cheney Drew, Astri Arnesen, Fiona Wood

Summary: This study explored the perceptions, motivators, and potential barriers relating to the adoption of wearable activity trackers by people with Huntington disease (HD). The study found that people with HD had a more positive attitude towards wearable activity trackers and important considerations for device use included device compatibility and accuracy, data security, impact on relationships, and the ability to monitor and self-manage lifestyle behaviors.

JMIR FORMATIVE RESEARCH (2022)

No Data Available