4.3 Article

A model of hunter-gatherer skeletal element transport: The effect of prey body size, carriers, and distance


Volume 73, Issue -, Pages 1-14


DOI: 10.1016/j.jhevol.2014.06.004


Skeletal element profile; Optimal foraging theory; High-survival elements; Shannon evenness index; Utility strategies; Skeletal transport models

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Zooarchaeologists frequently use the relative abundance of skeletal elements in faunal assemblages in conjunction with foraging theory models to infer subsistence decisions made by prehistoric hunter-gatherers. However, foraging models applied to ethnoarchaeological cases have had variable success linking skeletal transport decisions with foraging predictions. Here, we approach this issue with the well-known Hadza data to statistically model the skeletal element transport decisions in response to distance from the residential hub and the number of carriers available for carcass transport. We compare our modeling approach to the traditional skeletal element utility curves from Binford's work with the Nunamiut, and to the more recently proposed Shannon evenness measure. Our approach, based on standard yet powerful statistical modeling techniques, can help researchers gain increased insight into the prey part transport responses of hunter-gatherers. Our analyses treat individual prey skeletal elements by body size as the response variable. The results of this analysis suggest that utility curves, and the Shannon evenness approach as a proxy for utility curves, are problematic for making statements about prehistoric foraging from zooarchaeological data. Transport distance does not explain a significant portion of small prey (size class 2) skeletal element transport variation. However, distance explains a great deal of transport variation in large prey (size classes 4 and 5). Inferences from skeletal element profiles should be made relative to prey body size and the discard probability of individual elements. Understanding the influence of these variables allows construction of a framework for testing archaeological element profiles against ethnographically derived transport models. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.


I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.


Primary Rating

Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Scientific rigor
Rate this paper


Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Innovative Homo sapiens behaviours 105,000 years ago in a wetter Kalahari

Jayne Wilkins, Benjamin J. Schoville, Robyn Pickering, Luke Gliganic, Benjamin Collins, Kyle S. Brown, Jessica von der Meden, Wendy Khumalo, Michael C. Meyer, Sechaba Maape, Alexander F. Blackwood, Amy Hatton

Summary: The study revealed that human behavioral innovations in the interior of southern Africa did not lag behind those near the coast, and these innovations may have developed in a wet savannah environment. This challenges the dominant narrative that ties modern human origins to coastal regions and suggests a revision of models linking behavioral innovations to the exploitation of coastal resources by our species.

NATURE (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Early human impacts and ecosystem reorganization in southern-central Africa

Jessica C. Thompson, David K. Wright, Sarah J. Ivory, Jeong-Heon Choi, Sheila Nightingale, Alex Mackay, Flora Schilt, Erik Otarola-Castillo, Julio Mercader, Steven L. Forman, Timothy Pietsch, Andrew S. Cohen, J. Ramon Arrowsmith, Menno Welling, Jacob Davis, Benjamin Schiery, Potiphar Kaliba, Oris Malijani, Margaret W. Blome, Corey A. O'Driscoll, Susan M. Mentzer, Christopher Miller, Seoyoung Heo, Jungyu Choi, Joseph Tembo, Fredrick Mapemba, Davie Simengwa, Elizabeth Gomani-Chindebvu

Summary: Archaeological and environmental data from northern Malawi reveal that early Homo sapiens started significant ecosystem modifications during the Late Pleistocene, with the use of fire and climate changes leading to an ecological transition to an early anthropogenic landscape.


Article Anthropology

Exploring variability in lithic armature discard in the archaeological record

Claudine Gravel-Miguel, John K. Murray, Benjamin J. Schoville, Colin D. Wren, Curtis W. Marean

Summary: The study used an agent-based model to simulate a hunter-gatherer foraging system and explore the impact of human behaviors and environmental constraints on the distribution of lithic armatures in archaeological assemblages. The results showed that most armatures used as projectile weapons are lost or discarded at hunting sites, and fluctuations in armature counts at archaeological sites should be evaluated within demographic and environmental contexts to understand spatiotemporal changes in hunting behavior.


Letter Multidisciplinary Sciences

Reply to: Clusters of flowstone ages are not supported by statistical evidence

Robyn Pickering, Andy I. R. Herries, Jon D. Woodhead, John C. Hellstrom, Helen E. Green, Bence Paul, Terrence Ritzman, David S. Strait, Benjamin J. Schoville, John Hancox

NATURE (2021)

Article Anthropology

Parts and Wholes: Reduction Allometry and Modularity in Experimental Folsom Points

Michael J. Shott, Erik Otarola-Castillo

Summary: Projectile points are a common subject of archaeological study, and geometric morphometrics have been increasingly used to analyze their allometric changes caused by resharpening. Different segments or modules of points experience varying degrees of resharpening, leading to differences in morphological integrity as points are used over time.


Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ostrich eggshell beads from Ga-Mohana Hill North Rockshelter, southern Kalahari, and the implications for understanding social networks during Marine Isotope Stage 2

Amy Hatton, Benjamin Collins, Benjamin J. Schoville, Jayne Wilkins

Summary: This study examines ostrich eggshell (OES) beads in southern African archaeological sites, highlighting their importance in understanding personal ornamentation and social networks. By analyzing OES bead assemblages and comparing them with other contemporary sites, it is found that OES beads were consistently present in the region during the terminal Pleistocene period, indicating a persistent cultural practice. The variations in bead diameters suggest stylistic differences.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Tufas indicate prolonged periods of water availability linked to human occupation in the southern Kalahari

Jessica von der Meden, Robyn Pickering, Benjamin J. Schoville, Helen Green, Rieneke Weij, John Hellstrom, Alan Greig, Jon Woodhead, Wendy Khumalo, Jayne Wilkins

Summary: Detailed palaeoclimate and archaeological records are crucial for understanding the impact of environmental change on human evolution. A Pleistocene archaeological sequence in South Africa's southern Kalahari has provided well-dated evidence of past flowing streams and waterfalls through analysis of relict tufas. By using uranium-thorium dating, researchers have identified five tufa formation episodes over the past 110,000 years, three of which coincide with archaeological units. The findings suggest a coupling between wet phases and human occupation, which became decoupled around 20,000 years ago during the Last Glacial Maximum.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Archaeology

Holding your shape: Controlled tip fracture experiments on cast porcelain points

Liam Neill, Chris Clarkson, Benjamin Schoville

Summary: This study introduces a new experimental method that uses vitrified porcelain points to analyze fracture characteristics of projectiles. By comparing different types of weapons, the research provides insights into the use of past weapon systems.


Article Ecology

Integrated evidence-based extent of occurrence for North American bison (Bison bison) since 1500 CE and before

Jeff M. Martin, Rachel A. Short, Glenn E. Plumb, Lauren Markewicz, Dirk H. Van Vuren, Bradly Wehus-Tow, Erik Otarola-Castillo, Matthew E. Hill

Summary: This paper presents a multidisciplinary approach to assemble a comprehensive database and meta-analysis of bison occurrence over the last 200,000 years. The database includes data from paleontology, archaeology, and historical ecology, totaling 6438 observations. The findings contribute to the fields of bison ecology, evolution, rewilding, management, and conservation.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Archaeology

Beyond Chronology, Using Bayesian Inference to Evaluate Hypotheses in Archaeology

Erik R. Otarola-Castillo, Melissa G. Torquato, Jesse Wolfhagen, Matthew E. Hill, Caitlin E. Buck

Summary: This article introduces the application of Bayesian statistics in archaeology, comparing it with null hypothesis significance testing (NHST) and using a fictional archaeological faunal assemblage to guide readers through a step-by-step Bayesian analysis. It demonstrates the broader applications of Bayesian statistics and how it can be used with different types of data.


Article Archaeology

The Drone, the Snake, and the Crystal: Manifesting Potency in 3D Digital Replicas of Living Heritage and Archaeological Places

Stephen Wessels, Sechaba Maape, Benjamin. J. J. Schoville, Jayne Wilkins

Summary: Creating and sharing 3D digital replicas of archaeological sites online has become common and is used for excavation, public engagement, and research communication. However, there has been little critical examination of current practices, leading to problematic visualizations. This article critiques the western paradigm and proposes inclusive and decolonized approaches to representing archaeological and living heritage places.


Article Anthropology

Does the evidence at Arroyo del Vizcaino (Uruguay) support the claim of human occupation 30,000 years ago?

Justin A. Holcomb, Rolfe D. Mandel, Erik Otarola-Castillo, Kurt Rademaker, Richard L. Rosencrance, Katelyn N. McDonough, D. Shane Miller, Brian T. Wygal

Summary: Researchers at Arroyo del Vizcaino in Uruguay argue for human occupation prior to the Last Glacial Maximum, but their claims are unsupported. After evaluating their research, it is concluded that the site is best interpreted as a natural accumulation over four millennia in a fluvial setting.


Article Anthropology

A Lithic Provisioning Model as a Proxy for Landscape Mobility in the Southern and Middle Kalahari

Benjamin J. Schoville, Kyle S. Brown, Jayne Wilkins

Summary: The study found that humans adopted different land-use strategies in water-stressed environments, including logistical foraging for food and longer occupation duration in areas closer to water sources. The research showed that variable means of achieving water security may have been key underlying behaviors for the dispersal of our species into marginal environments.


Article Anthropology

Fabric Analysis and Chronology at Ga-Mohana Hill North Rockshelter, Southern Kalahari Basin: Evidence for In Situ, Stratified Middle and Later Stone Age Deposits

Jayne Wilkins, Benjamin J. Schoville, Kyle S. Brown, Luke Gliganic, Michael C. Meyer, Emma Loftus, Robyn Pickering, Benjamin Collins, Alexander F. Blackwood, Simangaliso Makalima, Amy Hatton, Sechaba Maape


Article Archaeology

A quantitative analysis of wear distributions on Middle Stone Age marine shell beads from Blombos Cave, South Africa

Amy Hatton, Benjamin J. Schoville, Jayne Wilkins


No Data Available