4.3 Article

Effect of Forensic Evidence on Criminal Justice Case Processing

Journal

JOURNAL OF FORENSIC SCIENCES
Volume 58, Issue -, Pages S78-S90

Publisher

WILEY-BLACKWELL
DOI: 10.1111/1556-4029.12020

Keywords

forensic science; case processing; criminal justice; decision making; crime scene evidence; laboratory analysis

Funding

  1. National Institute of Justice [2006-DN-BX-0094]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study examined the role and impact of forensic evidence on case-processing outcomes in a sample of 4205 criminal cases drawn from five U.S. jurisdictions. Regression analyses demonstrated that forensic evidence played a consistent and robust role in case-processing decisions. Still, the influence of forensic evidence is time- and examination-dependent: the collection of crime scene evidence was predictive of arrest, and the examination of evidence was predictive of referral for charges, as well as of charges being filed, conviction at trial, and sentence length. The only decision outcome in which forensic evidence did not have a general effect was with regard to guilty plea arrangements. More studies are needed on the filtering of forensic evidence in different crime categories, from the crime scene to its use by investigators, prosecutors, and fact-finders, and to identify factors that shape decisions to collect evidence, submit it to laboratories, and request examinations.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Substance Abuse

Practitioner and digitally delivered interventions for reducing hazardous and harmful alcohol consumption in people not seeking alcohol treatment: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Fiona R. Beyer, Ryan P. W. Kenny, Eugenie Johnson, Deborah M. Caldwell, Claire Garnett, Stephen Rice, Julija Simpson, Colin Angus, Dawn Craig, Matt Hickman, Susan Michie, Eileen F. S. Kaner

Summary: This study compares the effectiveness of practitioner versus digitally delivered interventions for reducing hazardous and harmful alcohol consumption. The findings suggest that practitioner delivered interventions are more effective in reducing consumption up to 6 months, but there is no evidence of a difference at 12 months.

ADDICTION (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Comprehensive needle and syringe program and opioid agonist therapy reduce HIV and hepatitis c virus acquisition among people who inject drugs in different settings: A pooled analysis of emulated trials

Daniela K. van Santen, Sara Lodi, Paul Dietze, Wijnand van den Boom, Kanna Hayashi, Huiru Dong, Zishan Cui, Lisa Maher, Matthew Hickman, Anders Boyd, Maria Prins

Summary: Comprehensive needle and syringe program and opioid agonist therapy participation can significantly reduce the risk of HIV and HCV infection compared with no or partial participation, according to this study. These findings emphasize the crucial role of comprehensive access to harm reduction in preventing infection among people who inject drugs.

ADDICTION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Should I Stay or Should I Go? A Qualitative Exploration of Stigma and Other Factors Influencing Opioid Agonist Treatment Journeys

Victoria Rice Carlisle, Olivia M. Maynard, Darren Bagnall, Matthew Hickman, Jon Shorrock, Kyla Thomas, Joanna Kesten

Summary: The UK government's emphasis on recovery may be leading to high attrition rates in opioid agonist treatment (OAT). Through interviews with OAT users and service providers, the study identified three key themes affecting treatment journeys: a broken system, power struggles, and filling the void. The findings underscore the importance of prioritizing treatment retention, addressing stigma, and developing targeted interventions.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Recommendations for hepatitis care in drug users

Jason Grebely, Geert Robaeys, Philip Bruggmann, Alessio Aghemo, Markus Backmund, Julie Bruneau, Jude Byrne, Olav Dalgard, Jordan J. Feld, Margaret Hellard, Matthew Hickman, Achim Kautz, Alain Litwin, Andrew R. Lloyd, Stefan Mauss, Maria Prins, Tracy Swan, Martin Schaefer, Lynn E. Taylor, Gregory J. Dore

Summary: The majority of new hepatitis C virus (HCV) infections occur in people who inject drugs (PWID) in high-income countries, as well as in many low- and middle-income countries. Despite increasing liver inflammation caused by HCV, treatment uptake remains low among PWID. The development of interferon-free HCV therapy with direct-acting antiviral (DAA) agents has brought optimism and the possibility of achieving optimal efficacy in short-duration oral therapy regimens. HCV treatment has been proven safe and effective across different healthcare settings. Strategies to improve HCV diagnosis and treatment in PWID are urgently needed.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DRUG POLICY (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Recommendations for the management of hepatitis C virus infection among intravenous drug users

Jason Grebely, Geert Robaeys, Philip Bruggmann, Alessio Aghemo, Markus Backmund, Julie Bruneau, Jude Byrne, Olav Dalgard, Jordan J. Feld, Margaret Hellard, Matthew Hickman, Achim Kautz, Alain Litwin, Andrew R. Lloyd, Stefan Mauss, Maria Prins, Tracy Swan, Martin Schaefer, Lynn E. Taylor, Gregory J. Dore

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DRUG POLICY (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Incidence of suicide and self-harm among people with opioid use disorder and the impact of opioid agonist treatment: A retrospective data linkage study

Samantha Colledge-Frisby, Nicola Jones, Louisa Degenhardt, Matthew Hickman, Prianka Padmanathan, Thomas Santo Jr, Michael Farrell, Natasa Gisev

Summary: This study examined the incidence of self-harm and suicide among people receiving opioid agonist treatment (OAT), and the impact of different periods of OAT exposure. The study found that the rates of self-harm and suicide were elevated during the initiation and cessation of OAT.

DRUG AND ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE (2023)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Association Between Gender Minority Status and Mental Health in High School Students

James White, Laurence Moore, Rebecca Cannings-John, Jemma Hawkins, Chris Bonell, Matthew Hickman, Stanley Zammit, Linda Adara

Summary: Adolescence is a crucial period for exploring gender identity, and gender minority individuals are vulnerable to mental health problems due to stigmatization. A study found that gender minority students had significantly higher odds of experiencing depressive symptoms, anxiety, and auditory hallucinations compared to cisgender students. Therefore, appropriate support and services should be provided to address the mental health needs of gender minority high-school students.

JOURNAL OF ADOLESCENT HEALTH (2023)

Article Psychology, Developmental

The effect of parental alcohol use on alcohol use disorder in young adulthood: Exploring the mediating roles of adolescent alcohol expectancies and consumption

Mallory Stephenson, Jon Heron, Kaitlin Bountress, Matthew Hickman, Kenneth S. S. Kendler, Alexis C. C. Edwards

Summary: This study examines the effects of parental alcohol consumption on adolescent and young adult children, finding that parental drinking indirectly contributes to the development of alcohol use disorder (AUD) in young adulthood, primarily through adolescent alcohol consumption. These findings underscore the importance of parental drinking in the development of alcohol use and problems during adolescence and young adulthood.

JOURNAL OF ADOLESCENCE (2023)

Review Infectious Diseases

Estimates of hepatitis B virus prevalence among general population and key risk groups in EU/EEA/UK countries: a systematic review

Sandra Bivegete, Anna L. McNaughton, Adam Trickey, Zak Thornton, Becky Scanlan, Aaron G. Lim, Lina Nerlander, Hannah Fraser, Josephine G. Walker, Matthew Hickman, Peter Vickerman, Helen Johnson, Erika Duffell, Ellen Brooks-Pollock, Hannah Christensen

Summary: The prevalence of hepatitis B virus is low in the general population in most European countries, with higher rates among risk populations such as migrants and people in prison. Screening and treatment should be targeted towards these high-risk groups.

EUROSURVEILLANCE (2023)

Article Immunology

Impact of HCV Testing and Treatment on HCV Transmission Among Men Who Have Sex With Men and Who Inject Drugs in San Francisco: A Modelling Analysis

Adelina Artenie, Jack Stone, Shelley N. Facente, Hannah Fraser, Jennifer Hecht, Perry Rhodes III, Willi McFarland, Erin Wilson, Matthew Hickman, Peter Vickerman, Meghan D. Morris

Summary: Based on data from San Francisco, this study estimates that HCV incidence among men who have sex with men and inject drugs will decrease by over 80% from 2015 to 2030, achieving the WHO elimination target. This decline is largely attributed to high HCV testing and treatment, despite COVID-19 related disruptions.

JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The Agile Co-production and Evaluation framework for developing public health interventions, messaging and guidance

Lucy Yardley, Sarah Denford, Atiya Kamal, Tom May, Jo M. M. Kesten, Clare E. French, Dale Weston, G. James Rubin, Jeremy Horwood, Matthew Hickman, Richard Amlot, Isabel Oliver

Summary: A lesson from the COVID-19 pandemic is that we need to extend existing best practice for intervention development by integrating state-of-the-art methods of coproducing public health interventions and evaluating their effectiveness. The Agile Co-production and Evaluation (ACE) framework is proposed as a way to rapidly develop and test interventions through a combination of co-production methods and large-scale evaluation. There is a need for further research to refine and validate methods in different public health contexts.

FRONTIERS IN PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Adverse childhood experiences and adolescent cannabis use trajectories: findings from a longitudinal UK birth cohort

Lindsey A. Hines, Hannah J. Jones, Matthew Hickman, Michael Lynskey, Laura Howe, Stan Zammit, Jon Heron

Summary: This study aimed to explore the association between adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) and the timing and frequency of cannabis use in adolescence. The findings showed that individuals with 4 or more ACEs, particularly those with parental substance use or abuse, were at a higher risk of problematic adolescent cannabis use. Therefore, reducing ACEs may help reduce cannabis use among adolescents.

LANCET PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Review Psychiatry

Buprenorphine versus methadone for the treatment of opioid dependence: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised and observational studies

Louisa Degenhardt, Brodie Clark, Georgina Macpherson, Oscar Leppan, Suzanne Nielsen, Emma Zahra, Briony Larance, Jo Kimber, Daniel Martino-Burke, Matthew Hickman, Michael Farrell

Summary: This systematic review and meta-analysis compared the effects of buprenorphine and methadone in the treatment of opioid dependence. The study found that methadone had better treatment retention rates compared to buprenorphine, but there were few significant differences in other primary and secondary outcomes. These findings emphasize the importance of interventions to improve treatment retention, consideration of client-centered factors (such as client preference) when selecting between buprenorphine and methadone, and harmonization of data collection and reporting to strengthen future synthesis.

LANCET PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Development of a Brief Intervention for Emergency Department Attendees Presenting With Self-Harm and Co-Occurring Substance Use Problems

Prianka Padmanathan, Rachel Cohen, David Gunnell, Lucy Biddle, Emma Griffith, Katie Breheny, Matt Hickman, Nik Munien, Anish Patel, Elaine Crocker, Paul Moran

Summary: This study aimed to develop a brief psychosocial intervention for individuals presenting to the emergency department with self-harm and co-occurring substance use problems. Through a modified Delphi method, expert consensus was achieved for 22 items, resulting in an intervention that includes weekly follow-up phone calls and support for accessing community services.

CRISIS-THE JOURNAL OF CRISIS INTERVENTION AND SUICIDE PREVENTION (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Effect of incarceration and opioid agonist treatment transitions on risk of hospitalisation with injection drug use-associated bacterial infections: A self-controlled case series in New South Wales, Australia

Thomas D. Brothers, Dan Lewer, Nicola Jones, Samantha Colledge-Frisby, Matthew Bonn, Alice Wheeler, Jason Grebely, Michael Farrell, Matthew Hickman, Andrew Hayward, Louisa Degenhardt

Summary: Transitional times in opioid use, such as release from prison and discontinuation of opioid agonist treatment, increase the risk of injection drug use-associated bacterial infections. Social contextual factors likely contribute to excess risk at transitions in incarceration and OAT exposure.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DRUG POLICY (2023)

No Data Available