4.7 Article

Explicitly incorporating socioeconomic criteria and data into marine protected area zoning

Journal

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT
Volume 116, Issue -, Pages 523-529

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2015.08.018

Keywords

Tenure; Zones; Marine spatial planning; Conservation planning; Indonesia; Coral triangle

Funding

  1. Walton Family Foundation
  2. David and Lucile Packard Foundation [2007-31720]
  3. USAID

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Addressing community needs or aspirations is critical for the success of marine protected areas (MPAs). However MPA design based on the results of systematic conservation planning tools alone does not fully represent important information on socioeconomic factors. This is because of the reliance of conservation planning tools on spatial data which is better suited to ecological rather than socioeconomic factors which are predominantly non-spatial. We present a case study from Raja Ampat in Indonesia, to demonstrate how we developed MPA zoning plans for six multiple use MPAs that encompass more than 1 million ha of the world's most diverse coral reef ecosystems. These were developed by combining analysis of ecological and spatial socioeconomic data using decision support tools (Marzone), and incorporation of non-spatial socioeconomic data from experts, stakeholders, and local communities. By explicitly including socioeconomic criteria and data into MPA zoning, the final zoning plans recognize community use and governance of resources, maximize equity and access to traditional fishing grounds, and better support long-term food security and livelihoods of local communities. These plans also met recommended guidelines for resilient MPA design and were supported by the community and MPA managers (i.e. Raja Ampat Regency and Indonesian National Government). This case study can act as a guide to other MPA managers and conservation practitioners to better incorporate socioeconomic considerations into MPA zoning plans and systematic marine conservation planning. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Contributions of tourism-based Marine Conservation Agreements to natural resource management in Fiji

Sangeeta Mangubhai, Helen Sykes, Marita Manley, Kiji Vukikomoala, Madeline Beattie

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2020)

Article Ecology

Large geographic variability in the resistance of corals to thermal stress

Timothy R. McClanahan, Joseph M. Maina, Emily S. Darling, Mireille M. M. Guillaume, Nyawira A. Muthiga, Stephanie D'agata, Julien Leblond, Rohan Arthur, Stacy D. Jupiter, Shaun K. Wilson, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Ali M. Ussi, Austin T. Humphries, Vardhan Patankar, George Shedrawi, Pagu Julius, January Ndagala, Gabriel Grimsditch

GLOBAL ECOLOGY AND BIOGEOGRAPHY (2020)

Article Ecology

Highly variable taxa-specific coral bleaching responses to thermal stresses

Timothy R. McClanahan, Emily S. Darling, Joseph M. Maina, Nyawira A. Muthiga, Stephanie D'agata, Julien Leblond, Rohan Arthur, Stacy D. Jupiter, Shaun K. Wilson, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Ali M. Ussi, Mireille M. M. Guillaume, Austin T. Humphries, Vardhan Patankar, George Shedrawi, Julius Pagu, Gabriel Grimsditch

MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES (2020)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Responses of benthic habitat and fish to severe tropical cyclone Winston in Fiji

Brae A. Price, Euan S. Harvey, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Benjamin J. Saunders, Marji Puotinen, Jordan S. Goetze

Summary: Tropical cyclones can have significant negative impacts on coral reefs, with the study showing spatial variability in live coral damage and increases in algae post-cyclone. The modelling of cyclone wave dynamics was found to better predict coral damage than proximity to the cyclone path, highlighting the importance of understanding and predicting cyclone impacts on marine habitats for effective mitigation and management strategies.

CORAL REEFS (2021)

Article Water Resources

Understanding the decision-making structures, roles and actions of village-level water committees in Fiji

Sarah Nelson, Seye Abimbola, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Aaron Jenkins, Stacy Jupiter, Kelera Naivalu, Vilisi Naivalulevu, Joel Negin

Summary: Village water committees play a key role in managing, operating, and maintaining water and sanitation facilities, with both reactive and proactive management approaches. Men dominate membership, roles, and decision-making in the water committees.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Politics of vulnerability: Impacts of COVID-19 and Cyclone Harold on Indo-Fijians engaged in small-scale fisheries

Sangeeta Mangubhai, Yashika Nand, Chinnamma Reddy, Arundhati Jagadish

Summary: The global COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the weaknesses in health, social, and economic systems, particularly affecting small-scale fisheries actors in Indo-Fiji. Many of these actors have experienced a reduction in fish sales and purchasing power, leading to challenges in meeting daily needs. The lack of social security or safety nets has left them vulnerable to the current crisis and other shocks.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Increasing Coral Reef Resilience Through Successive Marine Heatwaves

Michael D. Fox, Anne L. Cohen, Randi D. Rotjan, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Stuart A. Sandin, Jennifer E. Smith, Simon R. Thorrold, Laura Dissly, Nathan R. Mollica, David Obura

Summary: Global ocean warming has led to declines in coral reefs, but research in the central equatorial Pacific suggests that selective mortality during recurrent heatwaves may help coral communities adapt to future warming. Identifying and facilitating conditions for coral survival and recovery are crucial steps towards successful stewardship of coral reefs in the 21st century climate change.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Sea anemones in the marine aquarium trade: Market preferences indicate opportunities for mariculture and conservation

Nicola Fraser, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Karina Hall, Anna Scott

Summary: This study surveyed aquarists and businesses to understand preferences and attitudes towards sea anemones in marine aquariums. The results showed a preference for captive-bred sea anemones over wild-harvested ones, with respondents willing to pay more for the former. The study also found that sea anemones in captivity generally have a survival time of 12 months or longer, with 20% living more than 10 years.

AQUATIC CONSERVATION-MARINE AND FRESHWATER ECOSYSTEMS (2021)

Article Ecology

Safeguarding nutrients from coral reefs under climate change

Camille Mellin, Christina C. Hicks, Damien A. Fordham, Christopher D. Golden, Marian Kjellevold, M. Aaron MacNeil, Eva Maire, Sangeeta Mangubhai, David Mouillot, Kirsty L. Nash, Johnstone O. Omukoto, James P. W. Robinson, Rick D. Stuart-Smith, Jessica Zamborain-Mason, Graham J. Edgar, Nicholas A. J. Graham

Summary: This Perspective discusses the potential effects of ocean warming on the provision of human nutrition from coral reef fish. It explores how altered metabolism, microbiome composition, and trophic interactions may change fish nutrient profiles. Climate change is a key stressor threatening coral reefs and their associated fish services, which affects the sustainability of coral reef fisheries. The response of fish nutrient concentrations to warming oceans is still uncertain, but it is likely influenced by both direct and indirect effects. Assessing the nutritional quality of available food in addition to quantity is crucial for food security and malnutrition research. The study also outlines future research priorities and a framework for sustainable reef fisheries in a warming ocean.

NATURE ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Development Studies

Progressing gender equality in fisheries by building strategic partnerships with development organisations

Sangeeta Mangubhai, Sarah Lawless, Anna Cowley, Jayshree P. Mangubhai, Meryl J. Williams

Summary: Gender equality is a universally agreed principle and value, but its implementation varies across different sectors. This study compares the perspectives and investments in gender of the development and fisheries sectors, and explores opportunities to strengthen collaboration and networks between them. The findings reveal divergences in the inclusion of gender in their work and highlight the challenges and potential for knowledge transfer and capacity building. The study suggests strategic partnerships in shifting values, gender mainstreaming, adopting best practices, and investing in gender networks and coalitions to promote gender equality in the fisheries sector.

WORLD DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Fisheries

Gender-based violence: Relevance for fisheries practitioners

Sangeeta Mangubhai, Kate M. Barclay, Sarah Lawless, Natalie Makhoul

Summary: Attention to the human dimensions of capture fisheries is important in understanding the experience and distribution of harms and benefits among different groups. We found that gender-based violence (GBV) is pervasive and reinforced by fisheries policies, practices, and institutions. Our synthesis demonstrates the various forms of GBV present in capture fisheries, including physical, sexual, psychological, economic, and cultural violence. We provide seven recommendations for addressing GBV in capture fisheries, such as investing in gender-sensitization, forming partnerships, and improving policies and coordination among regulatory bodies.

FISH AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

National-level evaluation of a community-based marine management initiative

Tanya O'Garra, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Arundhati Jagadish, Margaret Tabunakawai-Vakalalabure, Alifereti Tawake, Hugh Govan, Morena Mills

Summary: Understanding the mechanisms and impacts of community-based initiatives in environmental management is crucial, but such evaluations are rare. This study presents a national-scale evaluation of a locally managed marine areas network in Fiji, showing that it improves participation, knowledge, management, and financial support. However, these mechanisms do not lead to significant social outcomes or perceived ecological health improvement.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Understanding on-site sanitation in rural Fiji: where definitions of sanitation back-ends differ

Nabeela Nasim, Shylett Anthony, Thompson Daurewa, Sikeli Gavidi, Pierre Horwitz, Aaron Jenkins, Stacy Jupiter, Shuang Liu, Kinikoto Mailautoka, Sangeeta Mangubhai, Kelera Naivalu, Timoci Naivalulevu, Vilisi Naivalulevu, Sikeli Naucunivanua, Joel Negin, Mereia Ravoka, Andrew Tukana, Donald Wilson, Jacqueline Thomas

Summary: Rural communities in Fiji rely on on-site sanitation systems, which have been found to be unsafe and contribute to faecal-oral diseases. This study aimed to assess the safety of existing sanitation infrastructure and estimate the proportion of safely managed systems. The findings revealed discrepancies between self-reported back-end category and actual observations, highlighting the need for improved sanitation practices.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE-WATER RESEARCH & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Exploring gender inclusion in small-scale fisheries management and development in Melanesia

Sangeeta Mangubhai, Sarah Lawless

Summary: The study reveals that while gender inclusive approaches are being used in the Pacific fisheries sector, there are challenges in implementation, such as most approaches only 'reaching' women without truly 'benefitting', 'empowering', or 'transforming' women's lives. Fisheries organizations need to strengthen their gender commitment and efforts in implementing effective gender approaches.

MARINE POLICY (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Spawning potential surveys in Fiji: A new song of change forsmall-scalefisheries in the Pacific

Jeremy Prince, Watisoni Lalavanua, Jone Tamanitoakula, Laitia Tamata, Stuart Green, Scott Radway, Epeli Loganimoce, Tevita Vodivodi, Kalisiana Marama, Pitila Waqainabete, Frank Jeremiah, Diana Nalasi, Mosese Naleba, Waisea Naisilisili, Uraia Kaloudrau, Lepani Lagi, Kalisiana Logatabua, Rosemary Dautei, Rahul Tikaram, James Sloan, Sangeeta Mangubhai

Summary: Catastrophic overfishing in small-scale coastal fisheries in the Pacific highlights the need for a reevaluation of fisheries management methods. The application of Spawning Potential Surveys (SPS) shows effectiveness in guiding and motivating fisheries reform, emphasizing the necessity of a long-term and interdisciplinary approach to achieve societal change.

CONSERVATION SCIENCE AND PRACTICE (2021)

Article Oceanography

Ecological impacts of dam construction on epilithic diatom communities in estuaries: A case study of the Korean peninsula

Ha-Kyung Kim, In-Hwan Cho, Eun-A Hwang, Young-Hyo Kim, Jeong-Suk Moon, Bae-Kyung Park, Baik-Ho Kim

Summary: This study investigated the distribution of diatoms in 324 estuaries on the Korean Peninsula from 2016 to 2018, with a focus on the ecological impact of artificial dams. The results highlighted the complex interactions between dams, land use, and diatom communities, providing important data for ecosystem management and biodiversity conservation. Understanding the consequences of artificial dams on diatom distribution is crucial for preserving estuarine health.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

The impact of new western land and sea corridor development on port deep hinterland transport service and route selection

Tianhang Gao, Jia Tian, Chuan Huang, Hongyu Wu, Xing Xu, Changjian Liu

Summary: This study explores the microcontainer transport service and route selection problem within the context of a new transportation corridor. A multiobjective planning model is established to minimize transportation cost, time, and carbon emissions. The findings demonstrate that the New Western Land and Sea Corridor is appealing for time-sensitive cargoes and can enhance economic benefits with supportive policies.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Dynamic relationship between marine fisheries economic development, environmental protection and fisheries technological Progress-A case of coastal provinces in China

Jintao Ma, Zhengjie Wu, Mengqian Guo, Qiuguang Hu

Summary: With the deepening of economic globalization and regional economic integration, marine fisheries are becoming increasingly connected to national strategic interests and economic vitality. It is necessary to explore the synergistic evolution of marine fisheries economic development, environmental protection, and technological progress in order to promote sustainable and healthy development of marine fisheries.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Evolution of marine ecology-industry symbiosis patterns and ecological security assessment: New evidence from coastal areas of China

Wenhan Ren, Yuhan Xu, Jing Ni

Summary: This paper focuses on the key role of human economic activities in the evolution of ecological security from the perspective of eco-industrial symbiosis and constructs a symbiotic system of indicators considering human economic activities and all subsystems. The research findings reveal that in China's coastal areas, the socio-economic development index shows a stable upward trend, the environmental capacity index remains stable, and the ecological impact index shows a fluctuating and undulating trend.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Spatial risk assessment of maritime transportation in offshore waters of China using machine learning and geospatial big data

Xiao Zhou

Summary: This study develops a spatial risk assessment approach for maritime transportation in China using machine learning and geospatial big data. The study identifies wave height, rainfall, and sea surface temperature as the most influential factors affecting navigational safety. It also analyzes the matching relationship between coastal search and rescue resources and maritime transportation risks.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Review Oceanography

Review of risk assessment for navigational safety and supported decisions in arctic waters

X. Yang, Z. Y. Lin, W. J. Zhang, S. Xu, M. Y. Zhang, Z. D. Wu, B. Han

Summary: The study highlights the increasing importance of Arctic navigation safety and identifies gaps in the application of risk assessment methodologies. It calls for decision-oriented modelling techniques and bridging the gap between academic research and practical application.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Potential challenges for the restoration of Biscayne Bay (Florida, USA) in the face of climate change effects revealed with predictive models

Vladimir J. Alarcon, Anna C. Linhoss, Christopher R. Kelble, Paul F. Mickle, Alexandra Fine, Enrique Montes

Summary: Estuaries and coastal areas are undergoing rapid changes due to climate change and sea level rise. This research presents a salinity transport model for Biscayne Bay and investigates the potential impacts of altered precipitation, increased salinity/temperature, and sea level rise on bay salinity. The findings suggest that current restoration plans may not be sufficient to maintain current salinity conditions, and management measures such as urban greening, artificial groundwater recharge, and water consumption reduction should be considered.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

A method to establish marine bio-regions in the pelagic ecosystem based on phytoplanktonic communities. Aplication to the southern Spanish coast

Manuel Vargas-Yanez, Ana Reeves-Bueno, Sara Fernandez-Topham, Francina Moya, Enrique Ballesteros, Cristina Alonso, Teresa Perez-Sanchez, Patricia Romero-Fernandez, Silvia Sanchez-Aguado, Ricardo Felix Sanchez-Leal, M. Carmen Garcia-Martinez

Summary: This study analyzed the phytoplankton communities in the upper 100 m of the Gulf of Cadiz and the Alboran Sea using time series data. The results show that these two regions can be considered as two differentiated bioregions, with the latter having higher productivity.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Spatiotemporal fishing effort simulations and restriction scenarios in Thermaikos Gulf, Greece (northeastern Mediterranean Sea)

Donna Dimarchopoulou, Ioannis Keramidas, Konstantinos Tsagarakis, Vasiliki Markantonatou, Ghassen Halouani, Athanassios C. Tsikliras

Summary: The study shows that spatiotemporal simulation modeling is an effective tool for investigating management options in ecosystem-based fisheries management. It demonstrates that fisheries restricted areas can help rebuild the biomass of exploited stocks, but their effectiveness depends on the size and location of the areas. The study also suggests that a parallel reduction in total fishing effort is necessary to achieve the highest benefits of protection.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

One mesh does not fit all: A dual compartment codend provides flexible selectivity opportunities to manage mixed fisheries

Junita D. Karlsen, Ludvig Ahm Krag, Bent Herrmann

Summary: Fisheries management is transitioning from a single-species approach to an ecosystem-based approach to address the complexities of mixed-species fisheries. A dual compartment codend concept can provide a complex selectivity profile and allow for flexible adjustments at sea, improving compliance with management objectives.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

A comparative study on the measurement of sustainable development of marine fisheries in China

Yi-Zhuo Zhang, Cheng Xue, Na Wang, Gang Chen

Summary: This paper evaluates typical coastal provinces and cities in China, constructing an evaluation indicator system and clarifying the regional differences in the sustainable development capacity of China's marine fisheries industry. The results show that Shandong Province and Fujian Province have advantages in sustainable development, while Tianjin, Hebei Province, and Shanghai have room for improvement.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Yard space allocation of container port based on dual cycle strategy

Caimao Tan, Tiantian Qin, Junliang He, Yu Wang, Hang Yu

Summary: This study addresses the storage space allocation problem of container yards based on the dual-cycle operation mode. A mixed integer programming model is established to optimize container transportation distance. The results show that dual-cycle operation can decrease transportation distance and the space allocation method based on it is more effective than traditional methods. The study also provides management insights for container ports and suggests effective solutions for bottleneck problems.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Oceanography

Setting the stage for decision-making on nature-based solutions for coastal climate adaptation

Haye H. Geukes, Peter M. van Bodegom, Alexander P. E. van Oudenhoven

Summary: This study aims to identify and explore the information requirements at different stages of the decision-making process of coastal nature-based solutions (NbS). The study found substantial differences in information requirements across the decision-making stages, with values and indicators becoming more specific and concrete as the stages progressed. The study also suggests that future changes in the information required for decision-making on coastal NbS can be anticipated and prepared for.

OCEAN & COASTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)