4.3 Review

Fuel switching in the electricity sector under the EU ETS: Review and prospective

Journal

JOURNAL OF ENERGY ENGINEERING
Volume 134, Issue 2, Pages 40-46

Publisher

ASCE-AMER SOC CIVIL ENGINEERS
DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9402(2008)134:2(40)

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The European Union has implemented the European Union emission trading scheme (EU ETS) as an instrument to facilitate greenhouse gas (GHG) emission abatement stipulated in the Kyoto protocol. Empirical data show that in the early stages of the EU ETS, the value of a ton of CO2 has already led to emission abatement through switching from coal to gas in the European electric power sector. In the second part of this paper, an electricity generation simulation model is used to perform simulations on the switching behavior in both the first and the second trading periods of the EU ETS. In 2005, the reduction in GHG emissions in the electric power sector due to EU ETS is estimated close to 88 Mton. For the second trading period, a European Union allowance (EUA) price dependent GHG reduction curve has been determined. The obtained switching potential turns out to be significant, up to 300 Mton/year, at sufficiently high EUA prices.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Comparative analysis of risk-aversion and strategic investment behavior in generation expansion

Steffen Kaminski, Mihaly Dolanyi, Kenneth Bruninx, Erik Delarue

Summary: This research examines the impact of risk-averse behavior and strategic bidding on energy and capacity market outcomes. By introducing a comparative analysis framework, the study identifies situations where these two behaviors lead to the same outcomes. The implications of this work for regulators lie in their ability to differentiate risk-aversion from strategic behavior based on observed market outcomes.

ELECTRIC POWER SYSTEMS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Economics

Distortions of National Policies to Renewable Energy Cooperation Mechanisms

Jelle Meus, Hanne Pittomvils, Stef Proost, Erik Delarue

Summary: The use of renewable energy cooperation mechanisms can reduce the policy cost for meeting renewable targets, but concerns about efficiency losses exist due to different national regulatory conditions and cross-border support instrument selection. This paper presents an analytical framework and a mathematical model to evaluate the impact of national grid cost allocation and cross-border feed-in premium implementation. The results suggest that EU-wide auctions for renewable electricity should not use sliding feed-in premiums and should ideally be discriminatory based on national regulatory conditions. Additionally, there may be distributional effects for Member States engaging in renewable cooperation.

ENERGY JOURNAL (2022)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Risk-Based Constraints for the Optimal Operation of an Energy Community

Mihaly Dolanyi, Kenneth Bruninx, Jean-Francois Toubeau, Erik Delarue

Summary: This paper presents a time-series scenario-driven stochastic optimization model for the centralized optimal bidding and scheduling problem of an energy community, using real-life measurement data. The research extends existing models by implementing a worst-case conditional value at risk (WCVaR) constraint for storage system state-of-charge bounds. A numerical comparison shows that the proposed WCVaR based constraint provides better protection against extreme out-of-sample outcomes compared to the conditional value at risk based equivalent. Real-life measurement data is directly leveraged for uncertainty in the imbalance market and load forecast errors, using a shape-based clustering method to capture the temporal characteristics of input scenarios.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SMART GRID (2022)

Article Economics

The Economics of Demand-side Flexibility in Distribution Grids

Athir Nouicer, Leonardo Meeus, Erik Delarue

Summary: To avoid unnecessary distribution network investments, it is expected that distribution tariffs will become more cost-reflective and Distribution System Operators (DSOs) will procure flexibility. The paper develops a long-term bi-level equilibrium model where the DSO optimizes social welfare and sets network tariffs while consumers maximize their own welfare. The study finds that implicit and explicit incentives for demand-side flexibility are complementary regulatory tools, but there are limits and difficulties in setting appropriate compensation levels due to prosumer reaction.

ENERGY JOURNAL (2023)

Article Economics

Demand-side flexibility in distribution grids: Voluntary versus mandatory contracting

Athir Nouicer, Leonardo Meeus, Erik Delarue

Summary: In this paper, two schemes for contracting demand-side flexibility by the Distribution System Operator (DSO) at the planning stage are investigated. The first scheme is a voluntary demand-side connection agreement where consumers offer their flexibility, while the second scheme is a mandatory demand-side connection agreement where the DSO sets the flexibility levels. Through modeling and analysis, it is found that mandatory demand-side connection agreements result in higher welfare gains compared to voluntary ones, but may face implementation issues and different curtailment levels among consumers.

ENERGY POLICY (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

The effect of short term storage operation on resource adequacy

Sebastian Gonzato, Kenneth Bruninx, Erik Delarue

Summary: The potential contribution of short-term storage technologies, such as batteries, to resource adequacy in power systems with high penetrations of Variable Renewable Energy Sources (VRES) is increasingly important. However, there are multiple ways in which storage may be operated to contribute to resource adequacy. This study investigates different storage operational strategies to determine their impact on the Loss of Load Expectation (LOLE) and Capacity Credits (CCs) and highlights the need for explicit and transparent assumptions in adequacy assessments and capacity credit calculations.

SUSTAINABLE ENERGY GRIDS & NETWORKS (2023)

Article Economics

The effect of flow-based market coupling on cross-border exchange volumes and price convergence in Central Western European electricity markets

Marten Ovaere, Michiel Kenis, Kenneth Van den Bergh, Kenneth Bruninx, Erik Delarue

Summary: The introduction of FBMC has positively affected day-ahead electricity price convergence and cross-border exchange volumes. However, these benefits have decreased over time, potentially due to decreased commercial transmission capacity on critical branches.

ENERGY ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Exploring the impact of boundedly rational power plant investment decision-making by applying prospect theory

Zhenmin Tao, Jorge Andres Moncada, Erik Delarue

Summary: This study uses prospect theory, a Nobel-prize-winning theory, to assess the impact of bounded rationality on the transition of the electric power system. The findings indicate that bounded rational investment behavior leads to increased uncertainties and higher system costs. Moreover, the overlooked factor of reference dependence is found to dominate the system's evolution. Considering these results, it is important for energy policy evaluation to consider the perspectives and status of investors, among other factors.

UTILITIES POLICY (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Signaling future or historical distribution grid costs via tariffs? A welfare analysis of long-run incremental cost pricing

Niels Govaerts, Kenneth Bruninx, Helene Le Cadre, Leonardo Meeus, Erik Delaru

Summary: The study finds that applying marginal cost pricing principles can enhance the economic efficiency of distribution network tariffs. By investigating the Long-Run Incremental Cost (LRIC) methodology implemented in Great Britain since 2012, the paper analytically derives the long-term social welfare achieved under three different tariff-setting methods. The study compares the resulting social welfare based on a range of system characteristics and discusses the underlying mechanisms, revealing that LRIC is more efficient than historical cost-based allocation.

UTILITIES POLICY (2023)

Editorial Material Chemistry, Physical

Trading rights to consume wind in presence of farm-farm interactions

Michiel Keris, Luca Lanzilao, Kenneth Brunix, Johan Meyers, Erik Delarue

JOULE (2023)

Correction Energy & Fuels

Toward a fundamental understanding of flow-based market coupling for cross-border electricity trading (vol 2, 100027, 2021)

David Schoenheit, Michiel Kenis, Lisa Lorenz, Dominik Moest, Erik Delarue, Kenneth Bruninx

ADVANCES IN APPLIED ENERGY (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Spatial representation of renewable technologies in generation expansion planning models

K. Phillips, J. A. Moncada, H. Ergun, E. Delarue

Summary: In this paper, we analyze the impact of the spatial representation of intermittent renewable technologies on generation planning models. The study finds that the spatial resolution and aggregation method significantly influence system costs, especially at high spatial resolutions. The paper also compares basic spatial aggregation methods for processing high resolution input data.

APPLIED ENERGY (2023)

Proceedings Paper Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Solar PV hosting capacity: grid-based vs. market-based scenarios

Chiara Gorrasi, Arpan Koirala, Kenneth Bruninx, Erik Delarue, Dirk Van Hertem

Summary: Assessing the capability of distribution grids to integrate new solar PV installations has been extensively researched. Existing analysis methods fail to consider consumer preferences or economic feasibility. By using market-based optimal power flow and hosting capacity analysis, this study compares the economic and technical limits of solar PV integration in low voltage distribution systems. Findings indicate that relying solely on grid limits does not provide a complete understanding of solar PV integration potential, deterministic power flow is not foolproof for assessing network security, and the number of technically feasible installation sites surpasses the economically feasible ones.

2023 19TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THE EUROPEAN ENERGY MARKET, EEM (2023)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Triggering a variety of Nash-equilibria in oligopolistic electricity markets

Mihaly Dolanyi, Kenneth Bruninx, Erik Delarue

Summary: Liberalized electricity markets offer cost-efficient operation and expansion of power systems but also create opportunities for strategic gaming by price-making agents. Regulators and policymakers face challenges in dealing with unconventional generation and consumption patterns and preventing strategic behavior.

OPTIMIZATION AND ENGINEERING (2023)

Proceedings Paper Computer Science, Theory & Methods

Off-shore Bidding Zones Under Flow-Based Market Coupling

Michiel Kenis, Erik Delarue, Kenneth Bruninx, Fernando Dominguez

Summary: This study examines the market integration of hybrid off-shore projects and the impact of bidding zone definitions on welfare distribution. The study finds that off-shore bidding zones result in a transfer of welfare and have implications for the need for support instruments for off-shore wind farms.

2023 IEEE BELGRADE POWERTECH (2023)

No Data Available