4.7 Review

Incomplete Caries Removal: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Journal

JOURNAL OF DENTAL RESEARCH
Volume 92, Issue 4, Pages 306-314

Publisher

SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC
DOI: 10.1177/0022034513477425

Keywords

dental caries; dental cavity preparation; partial excavation; indirect pulp treatment; dental pulp exposure; dental pulp capping

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Increasing numbers of clinical trials have demonstrated the benefits of incomplete caries removal, in particular in the treatment of deep caries. This study systematically reviewed randomized controlled trials investigating one-or two-step incomplete compared with complete caries removal. Studies treating primary and permanent teeth with primary caries lesions requiring a restoration were analyzed. The following primary and secondary outcomes were investigated: risk of pulpal exposure, post-operative pulpal symptoms, overall failure, and caries progression. Electronic databases were screened for studies from 1967 to 2012. Cross-referencing was used to identify further articles. Odds ratios (OR) as effect estimates were calculated in a random-effects model. From 364 screened articles, 10 studies representing 1,257 patients were included. Meta-analysis showed risk reduction for both pulpal exposure (OR [95% CI] 0.31 [0.19-0.49]) and pulpal symptoms (OR 0.58 [0.31-1.10]) for teeth treated with one-or two-step incomplete excavation. Risk of failure seemed to be similar for both complete and incomplete excavation, but data for this outcome were of limited quality and inconclusive (OR 0.97 [0.64-1.46]). Based on reviewed studies, incomplete caries removal seems advantageous compared with complete excavation, especially in proximity to the pulp. However, evidence levels are currently insufficient for definitive conclusions because of high risk of bias within studies.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Health economic evaluation of endodontic therapies

Falk Schwendicke, Sascha Rudolf Herbst

Summary: This review introduces the main concepts of health economic analysis, systematically reviews the existing economic literature on endodontic treatments, and suggests further action for the community. The identified evidence on the health economics of endodontic therapies is limited and has some limitations. However, maintaining pulpal vitality is preferred over root canal treatment for cost-effectiveness, retaining teeth is usually more cost-effective than extraction and replacement, and endodontic retreatment may be clinically indicated but not always cost-effective and should be carefully considered.

INTERNATIONAL ENDODONTIC JOURNAL (2023)

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Clustering of Signs and Symptoms of Oral Diseases in a Colombian Population

Ana Cristina Mafla, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: The aim of this study was to estimate disease pattern clusters and co-occurrences of oral signs and symptoms in a Colombian population. A cross-sectional study was carried out through a telephone survey among 1155 people. Age-specific clustering of signs and symptoms and diagnostic patterns were present in this Colombian cohort.

INTERNATIONAL DENTAL JOURNAL (2023)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Machine Learning in Dentistry: A Scoping Review

Lubaina T. Arsiwala-Scheppach, Akhilanand Chaurasia, Anne Mueller, Joachim Krois, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: Machine learning is increasingly used in dental research and application. This study aimed to compile and evaluate studies using machine learning in dentistry, focusing on methodological quality and reporting standards. The findings showed that machine learning is commonly employed for classification tasks in different clinical fields. Forty-two different metrics were used to evaluate model performances, with accuracy, sensitivity, precision, and intersection-over-union being the most common. The study identified a significant risk of bias and moderate adherence to reporting standards, highlighting the need for a minimum (core) set of outcome and outcome metrics for comparison across studies.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE (2023)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Resin Infiltration of Non-Cavitated Proximal Caries Lesions in Primary and Permanent Teeth: A Systematic Review and Scenario Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Marcus Cebula, Gerd Goestemeyer, Joachim Krois, Vinay Pitchika, Sebastian Paris, Falk Schwendicke, Susanne Effenberger

Summary: The present study conducted a meta-analysis to evaluate the certainty of evidence for resin infiltration of proximal carious lesions in primary and permanent teeth. The results showed that resin infiltration can effectively arrest caries lesions in both primary and permanent teeth. However, the certainty of evidence remains unclear due to the high or unclear risk of bias in the included trials.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE (2023)

Article Immunology

How Do Users Respond to Mass Vaccination Centers? A Cross-Sectional Study Using Natural Language Processing on Online Reviews to Explore User Experience and Satisfaction with COVID-19 Vaccination Centers

Stella Danek, Martha Buettner, Joachim Krois, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: To reach more vaccine recipients, high-income countries have introduced mass vaccination centers for COVID-19. Understanding user experiences of these structures can help improve their design and increase patient satisfaction and vaccine uptake.

VACCINES (2023)

Editorial Material Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Artificial intelligence: advances and pitfalls

Falk Schwendicke, Martha Buettner

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL (2023)

Editorial Material Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Natural language processing in dentistry

Martha Buettner, Falk Schwendicke

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL (2023)

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Identification of Dental Implant Systems Using a Large-Scale Multicenter Data Set

W. Park, F. Schwendicke, J. Krois, J. -K. Huh, J. -H. Lee

Summary: This study evaluated the efficacy of deep learning in identifying and classifying different types of dental implant systems using a large-scale multicenter data set. Deep learning outperformed dental professionals in accuracy and required less reading and classification time. The results suggest that deep learning can be used successfully as a decision support aid for the identification and classification of dental implant systems encountered in clinical practice.

JOURNAL OF DENTAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Super-Resolution of Dental Panoramic Radiographs Using Deep Learning: A Pilot Study

Hossein Mohammad-Rahimi, Shankeeth Vinayahalingam, Erfan Mahmoudinia, Parisa Soltani, Stefaan J. Berge, Joachim Krois, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: Using super-resolution algorithms, low-resolution images can be converted to high-quality images. This study compared deep learning-based super-resolution models with a conventional approach for enhancing the resolution of dental panoramic radiographs. The LTE model outperformed other models, showing significant improvements in the quality of panoramic radiographs compared to low-resolution images.

DIAGNOSTICS (2023)

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Federated vs local vs central deep learning of tooth segmentation on panoramic radiographs

Lisa Schneider, Roman Rischke, Joachim Krois, Aleksander Krasowski, Martha Buettner, Hossein Mohammad-Rahimi, Akhilanand Chaurasia, Nielsen S. Pereira, Jae-Hong Lee, Sergio E. Uribe, Shahriar Shahab, Revan Birke Koca-Unsal, Gurkan Unsal, Yolanda Martinez-Beneyto, Janet Brinz, Olga Tryfonos, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: This study demonstrates the effectiveness of Federated Learning (FL) in dentistry, showing that it can train high-performance and generalizable deep learning models without sharing sensitive data. FL outperformed Local Learning (LL) in tooth segmentation on panoramic radiographs and proved to be a valuable alternative when data pooling is not feasible.

JOURNAL OF DENTISTRY (2023)

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Cost-effectiveness of school-based caries screening using transillumination

Falk Schwendicke, Lisa Bombeck

Summary: This study assessed the cost-effectiveness of near-infrared-light-transillumination (NILT) for school-based caries screening and found that NILT may provide limited effectiveness gains and cost savings in the modelled populations. However, in countries other than Germany, NILT may have higher cost-effectiveness.

JOURNAL OF DENTISTRY (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Machine Learning to Predict Apical Lesions: A Cross-Sectional and Model Development Study

Sascha Rudolf Herbst, Vinay Pitchika, Joachim Krois, Aleksander Krasowski, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: This study aimed to identify factors associated with the presence of apical lesions (AL) in panoramic radiographs and evaluate their predictive value. The results showed that the presence of AL was higher in root-canal treated teeth, those with crowns, and molars. Less-complex machine learning models, such as decision tree, performed better in predicting AL.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE (2023)

Article Immunology

The Role of Vaccination Centers in a National Mass Immunization Campaign-Policymaker Insights from the German COVID-19 Pandemic Vaccine Roll-Out

Stella Danek, Dmitrij Achelrod, Ole Wichmann, Falk Schwendicke

Summary: This qualitative study examined the role of mass vaccination centers in the COVID-19 vaccination campaign in Germany and explored their optimal deployment. The study found that these centers played an essential role in terms of controllability, throughput, accessibility, and openness. Unlike regular vaccination structures, public administration had direct authority over these centers, allowing for prioritization and documentation of vaccine access. The deployment of vaccination centers should be guided by vaccine availability, demand, logistics, and local capacities to ensure effective and equitable access. Improvements in capacity use, scalability, and flexibility of governmental vaccination structures are necessary for future pandemics.

VACCINES (2023)

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Accuracy of different approaches for detecting proximal root caries lesions in vitro

Gerd Goestemeyer, Mareike Preus, Karim Elhennawy, Falk Schwendicke, Sebastian Paris, Haitham Askar

Summary: In this study, the diagnostic accuracy of radiographic evaluation, visual-tactile assessment, laser-fluorescence, and near-infrared-light transillumination were evaluated for proximal root caries lesions. The results showed that near-infrared-light transillumination was not applicable for detecting proximal root caries, while laser-fluorescence and visual-tactile assessment were more accurate than radiographic evaluation for detecting these lesions.

CLINICAL ORAL INVESTIGATIONS (2023)

No Data Available