Ligand Binding Mode Prediction by Docking: Mdm2/Mdmx Inhibitors as a Case Study

The p53-binding domains of Mdm2 and Mdrnx, two negative regulators of the tumor suppressor p53, are validated targets for cancer therapeutics, but correct binding poses of some proven inhibitors, particularly the nutlins, have been difficult to obtain with standard docking procedures. Virtual screening pipelines typically draw from a database of compounds represented with 1D or 2D structural information from which one or more 3D conformations must be generated. These conformations are then passed to a docking algorithm that searches for optimal binding poses on the target protein. This work tests alternative pipelines using several commonly used conformation generation programs (LigPrep, ConfGen, MacroModel, and Corina/Rotate) and docking programs (GOLD, Glide, MOE-dock, and AutoDock Vina) for their ability to reproduce known poses for a series of Mdrnx and/or Mdm2 inhibitors, including several nutlins. Most combinations of these programs using default settings fail to find correct poses for the nutlins but succeed for all other compounds. Docking success for the nutlin class requires either computationally intensive conformational exploration or an anchoring procedure that incorporates knowledge of the orientation of the central imidazoline ring.