4.5 Review

Participatory environmental assessment in drylands: Introducing a new approach

Journal

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS
Volume 77, Issue -, Pages 1-10

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS LTD- ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.jaridenv.2011.09.015

Keywords

Ecosystem services; Environmental assessment; Local knowledge; Participatory modelling; Scenarios; Stakeholder participation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

A recent wave of participatory and 'integrated local and scientific knowledge' methodologies have been conceived, trialled and published in an attempt to offer solutions to the challenges of conducting dryland environmental assessment from a socio-ecological perspective. Some of the key ideas and approaches within this literature are synthesized and reviewed here. Three conceptual elements that, in combination, remain largely absent within the dryland assessment literature, are identified: (1) drylands as political, cultural and economic systems, (2) drylands as complex resilient systems, and (3) drylands as temporally-embedded systems. These conceptual elements are then combined in presenting a new methodological approach, which is based on the participatory modelling of ecosystem services and participatory assessment of future scenarios. It is an approach to environmental assessment that is sensitive to the needs and experience of present and future stakeholders and creates potential avenues for co-operative management decisions and socially-acceptable policies. (C) 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Framing of sustainable agricultural practices by the farming press and its effect on adoption

Niki A. Rust, Rebecca M. Jarvis, Mark S. Reed, Julia Cooper

Summary: There is a growing political pressure for farmers to adopt sustainable agricultural practices in order to protect people and the planet. The farming press plays a role in influencing farmers to try more sustainable practices by changing discourse and raising awareness, with a focus on economic and agronomic aspects. However, respondents often do not fully trust the farming press as they believe it represents agribusinesses, and while some farmers are motivated to try new sustainable practices after learning about them in the press, this is rare.

AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES (2021)

Article Development Studies

The tree of participation: a new model for inclusive decision-making

Karen Bell, Mark Reed

Summary: The importance and challenges of participatory decision-making in community development. A new participatory decision-making model is proposed to empower marginalized groups and improve transparency, accountability, equity, and efficiency.

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT JOURNAL (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Have farmers had enough of experts?

Niki A. Rust, Petra Stankovics, Rebecca M. Jarvis, Zara Morris-Trainor, Jasper R. de Vries, Julie Ingram, Jane Mills, Jenny A. Glikman, Joy Parkinson, Zoltan Toth, Regina Hansda, Rob McMorran, Jayne Glass, Mark S. Reed

Summary: The exponential growth of information allows access to knowledge on almost any question asked, but challenges arise in determining which information is trustworthy. Farmers historically relied on traditional 'experts' for advice on agricultural innovations, but as more turn to online sources, they may be shifting towards peer networks and online information over traditional sources of expertise.

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Integrating ecosystem markets to co-ordinate landscape-scale public benefits from nature

Mark S. Reed, Tom Curtis, Arjan Gosal, Helen Kendall, Sarah Pyndt Andersen, Guy Ziv, Anais Attlee, Richard G. Fitton, Matthew Hay, Alicia C. Gibson, Alex C. Hume, David Hill, Jamie L. Mansfield, Simone Martino, Asger Strange Olesen, Stephen Prior, Christopher Rodgers, Hannah Rudman, Franziska Tanneberger

Summary: Ecosystem markets are growing globally in response to the demand for climate change mitigation and provision of public goods. However, integrating these markets raises challenges, such as the crowding out of private investment and trade-offs between different schemes. This study analyzes eleven European ecosystem markets and identifies three types of markets operating at different scales. The study proposes options for blending public and private funding and outlines a framework for integrating national carbon markets and green finance with regional ecosystem markets, which could increase funding for regenerative agriculture and conservation across multiple habitats and services.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

How research data deliver non-academic impacts: A secondary analysis of UK Research Excellence Framework impact case studies

Eric A. Jensen, Paul Wong, Mark S. Reed

Summary: This study examines the contribution of research data to non-academic impacts through analyzing high-scoring impact case studies from the UK's REF. The findings reveal that the most prevalent type of impact driven by research data is related to practice, followed by impacts on government. It is also highlighted that research data alone rarely generate impacts and necessitate additional interventions such as analysis, curation, and product development.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Geography

Translating community resilience theory into practice: A deliberative Delphi approach

Jayne Glass, Rob McMorran, Margaret Currie, Annie McKee, Annabel Pinker, Mark Reed, Elliot Meador, Marianna Markantoni

Summary: This study utilizes the Delphi technique to collect expert knowledge, resulting in an operational framework for rural community resilience. It also analyzes key factors and potential assessment for community resilience.

SOCIOLOGIA RURALIS (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Re-thinking research impact: voice, context and power at the interface of science, policy and practice

Mark S. Reed, Hannah Rudman

Summary: This article discusses three considerations for rethinking how research can create beneficial impacts on policy and practice: sensitivity to context, representation and legitimization of diverse voices, and the management of power dynamics. By considering the factors of context, power, and voice in the research and impact generation processes, it is possible to envision a just transformation of knowledge systems that prioritizes the knowledge and needs of diverse groups, including historically marginalized groups.

SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geography

Traps, apps and maps: to what extent do they provide decision-grade data on biodiversity?

Hannah Rudman, Ben Hart, Maggie English, Craig Turner, Elisa Fuentes-Montemayor, Mark S. Reed

Summary: This paper presents a case study of novel digital data collection methods used in a nature restoration project in Scotland, and discusses how decision-grade biodiversity data can be produced to meet the requirements of the finance sector.

SCOTTISH GEOGRAPHICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Article Ethics

Rethinking Appropriateness of Actions in Environmental Decisions: Connecting Interest and Identity Negotiation with Plural Valuation

Christopher M. Raymond, Paul Hirsch, Bryan Norton, Andrew Scott, Mark S. Reed

Summary: Issues of interest, identity and values are interconnected in environmental conflicts. To address these challenges, a relational understanding of environmental ethics and the concept of 'appropriateness of actions' are introduced. Success factors for supporting appropriate actions include understanding context and identifying key stakeholders, surfacing diverse interests and building system-level trust, building empathy for different identities grounded in specific places, eliciting diverse values and seeking to understand their links to worldviews and knowledge systems, and seeking out appropriate actions.

ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Trade-offs between the natural environment and recreational infrastructure: A case study about peatlands under different management scenarios

Simone Martino, Jasper O. Kenter, Nora Albers, Mark J. Whittingham, Dylan M. Young, James W. Pearce-Higgins, Julia Martin-Ortega, Klaus Glenk, Mark S. Reed

Summary: The paper examines the importance of recreation in peatlands and the trade-offs between natural properties and recreational infrastructure. The study finds that different types of recreationists have varying landscape preferences, highlighting potential value conflicts. These conflicts need to be considered in net zero climate mitigation strategies.

LAND USE POLICY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Peatland core domain sets: building consensus on what should be measured in research and monitoring

Mark S. Reed, Dylan M. Young, Nigel G. Taylor, Roxane Andersen, Nicholle G. A. Bell, Hinsby Cadillo-Quiroz, Matthew Grainger, Andreas Heinemeyer, Kristell Hergoualc'h, Adam M. Gerrand, Johannes Kieft, Haruni Krisnawati, Erik A. Lilleskov, Gabriela Lopez-Gonzalez, Lulie Melling, Hannah Rudman, Sophie Sjogersten, Jonathan S. Walker, Gavin Stewart

Summary: Lack of data consistency among multiple studies hampers decision-making in policy and practice regarding the conservation and restoration of peatlands. This study proposes a methodological framework and discusses subsequent steps to standardize the measurement and reporting of outcomes in peatland research. These efforts contribute to the creation of reliable datasets that inform evidence-based policy and contribute to the sustainable management of globally significant carbon stores.

MIRES AND PEAT (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Soil-Improving Cropping Systems for Sustainable and Profitable Farming in Europe

Rudi Hessel, Guido Wyseure, Ioanna S. Panagea, Abdallah Alaoui, Mark S. Reed, Hedwig van Delden, Melanie Muro, Jane Mills, Oene Oenema, Francisco Areal, Erik van den Elsen, Simone Verzandvoort, Falentijn Assinck, Annemie Elsen, Jerzy Lipiec, Aristeidis Koutroulis, Lilian O'Sullivan, Martin A. Bolinder, Luuk Fleskens, Ellen Kandeler, Luca Montanarella, Marius Heinen, Zoltan Toth, Moritz Hallama, Julian Cuevas, Jantiene E. M. Baartman, Ilaria Piccoli, Tommy Dalgaard, Jannes Stolte, Jasmine E. Black, Charlotte-Anne Chivers

Summary: Soils are essential for agriculture and ecosystem services, and their management should focus on improving quality and resilience. The SoilCare project developed the concept of soil-improving cropping systems (SICS) as a holistic approach to promote sustainable and profitable soil management. The adoption of SICS by stakeholders was monitored and evaluated for environmental, sociocultural, and economic effects. The project emphasized the importance of understanding local dynamics in Europe-wide assessments and highlighted the role of economic considerations and social factors such as trust in the uptake of SICS. The results pointed to the need for coherent policies to support a transition to more sustainable agricultural practices.
Article Environmental Studies

Perceived Causes and Solutions to Soil Degradation in the UK and Norway

Niki Rust, Ole Erik Lunder, Sara Iversen, Steven Vella, Elizabeth A. Oughton, Tor Arvid Breland, Jayne H. Glass, Carly M. Maynard, Rob McMorran, Mark S. Reed

Summary: Soil quality decline is a global issue with multiple causes and no single solution. Stakeholders' opinions on managing this problem vary. Engaging with diverse stakeholders is crucial in developing socially acceptable and effective policies. A study in the UK and Norway found that stakeholders perceived causes of and solutions to soil degradation differently, with an overarching theme of industrialized agriculture being responsible. Multi-actor approaches can help improve the social acceptance of land use policies to address soil degradation.
Article Management

Evaluating impact from research: A methodological framework

M. S. Reed, M. Ferre, J. Martin-Ortega, R. Blanche, R. Lawford-Rolfe, M. Dallimer, J. Holden

Summary: This study provides a new definition of research impact and impact evaluation, develops a typology of research impact evaluation designs, and proposes a methodological framework to guide evaluations of research impact. The subjective nature of impacts is recognized, leading to the identification of five types of impact evaluation design. Using the proposed guidance, researchers, funders, and stakeholders can select suitable evaluation designs and methods to evidence the impact of research from any discipline.

RESEARCH POLICY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

What makes an operational farm soil carbon code? Insights from a global comparison of existing soil carbon codes using a structured analytical framework

Helaina I. J. Black, Mark S. Reed, Helen Kendall, Robert Parkhurst, Nicola Cannon, Pippa J. Chapman, Matthew Orman, Jenny Phelps, Hannah Rudman, Sarah Whalley, Jagadeesh Yeluripati, Guy Ziv

Summary: This paper presents the first global comparative analysis of farmland soil carbon codes, providing new insights into the range of approaches governing the global marketplace. Codes use a range of mechanisms to manage additionality, uncertainty, and risks, as well as baselines, measurement, reporting, verification, auditing, resale of carbon units, bundling and stacking, stakeholder engagement, and market integrity. The paper concludes by discussing existing approaches and codes that could be adapted for use in the UK and evaluates the need for an over-arching standard for soil carbon codes in the UK and internationally.

CARBON MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Ecology

First measurements of electric field variability during fog events in the United Arab Emirates

Narendra Nelli, Diana Francis, Ricardo Fonseca, Olivier Masson, Mamadou Sow, Emmanuel Bosc

Summary: This study investigates the changes in the atmospheric electric field (Ez) during foggy conditions in the hyperarid region of the United Arab Emirates. The results show that as fog persists, Ez becomes more variable due to the absorption and redistribution of charges by the fog, which alters the ion balance and affects electrical conductivity in the atmosphere.

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2024)

Article Ecology

Neo-taphonomy of striped hyena (Hyaena hyaena) in Israel

Ezra Hadad, Amir Balaban, Jakub Z. Kosicki, Reuven Yosef

Summary: This study investigated whether the prey of striped hyenas has adapted to the change in the natural environment caused by human activities, particularly artificial light at night (ALAN). The results showed that ALAN had no impact on the diet or den distribution of the hyenas in central Israel. The study also found that domestic animals were the most common prey, and there were also some vegetative species in their diet. Overall, the feeding behavior of striped hyenas is influenced by geographical region, habitat, and human activities.

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2024)

Article Ecology

Evaluation of IMERG precipitation product over various temporal scales in a semi-arid region of southern Iran

Rahim Najafi Tireh Shabankareh, Pardis Ziaee, Mohammad Javad Abedini

Summary: This study evaluated the IMERG satellite-based precipitation product in the Fars province of Iran using daily rain gauges as reference data. The results showed that the product tends to overestimate light rainfall and underestimate heavy rainfall, with the best performance in the 40-80 mm/day range. The accuracy of the product varies by month and is less biased in months with milder temperatures. Additionally, there was a higher correlation in mid-elevated areas, positive bias in low-elevated areas, and negative bias in high-elevated areas. Longer time scales showed considerable improvement in the IMERG estimates.

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2024)