Group B saponins in soy products in the US Department of Agriculture-Iowa State University Isoflavone Database and their comparison with isoflavone contents

Isoflavones in soy protein foods are thought to contribute to the cholesterol-lowering effect observed when these products are fed to humans. The group B saponins are another ethanol-soluble phytochemical fraction associated with soy proteins and isoflavones and have also been associated with cholesterol-lowering abilities. We measured the group B soyasaponin concentrations in a variety of soy foods and ingredients in the U.S. Department of Agriculture-Iowa State University Isoflavone Database. We compared the isoflavone and soy saponin concentrations and distributions in intact soybeans, soy ingredients, and retail soy foods. Group B saponins occur in six predominant forms. There appears to be no correlation between saponin and isoflavone concentrations in intact soybeans ranging from 5 to 11 mu mol isoflavones/g soybean and from 2 to 6 mu mol saponin/g soybean. Depending upon the type of processing, soy ingredients have quite different saponins/isoflavones as compared to mature soybeans. In soy foods, the saponin:isoflavone ration ranges from 1:1 to 2:5, whereas in soy protein isolates, the ratio is similar to 5:3. Ethanol-washed ingredients have very low saponins and isoflavones. These very different distributions of saponins and isoflavones in soy products may affect how we view the outcome of feeding trials examining a variety of protective effects associated with soy consumption.