4.5 Article

Community wildfire protection planning: is the Healthy Forests Restoration Act's vagueness genius?

Journal

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF WILDLAND FIRE
Volume 20, Issue 3, Pages 350-363

Publisher

CSIRO PUBLISHING
DOI: 10.1071/WF10038

Keywords

community capacity; policy implementation; wildfire management; wildland-urban interface

Categories

Funding

  1. Joint Fire Science Program [ID 04-S-01]
  2. Northern Research Station

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The Healthy Forests Restoration Act of 2003 (HFRA) encourages communities to develop community wildfire protection plans (CWPPs) to reduce their wildland fire risk and promote healthier forested ecosystems. Communities who have developed CWPPs have done so using many different processes, resulting in plans with varied form and content. We analysed data from 13 case-study communities to illustrate how the characteristics of HFRA have encouraged communities to develop CWPPs that reflect their local social and ecological contexts. A framework for analysing policy implementation suggests that some elements of HFRA could have made CWPP development and implementation problematic, but these potential shortcomings in the statute have provided communities the freedom to develop CWPPs that are relevant to their conditions and allowed for the development of capacities that communities are using to move forward in several areas.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Forestry

Categorizing the Social Context of the Wildland Urban Interface: Adaptive Capacity for Wildfire and Community Archetypes

Travis B. Paveglio, Cassandra Moseley, Matthew S. Carroll, Daniel R. Williams, Emily Jane Davis, A. Paige Fischer

FOREST SCIENCE (2015)

Article Ecology

Rethinking climate change adaptation and place through a situated pathways framework: A case study from the Big Hole Valley, USA

Daniel J. Murphy, Laurie Yung, Carina Wyborn, Daniel R. Williams

LANDSCAPE AND URBAN PLANNING (2017)

Article Ecology

Making sense of 'place': Reflections on pluralism and positionality in place research

Daniel R. Williams

LANDSCAPE AND URBAN PLANNING (2014)

Article Forestry

Organisational influence on the co-production of fire science: overcoming challenges and realising opportunities

Evora Glenn, Laurie Yung, Carina Wyborn, Daniel R. Williams

Summary: This study examines seven co-produced wildland fire projects associated with the US Department of Agriculture Forest Service Rocky Mountain Research Station (RMRS) and provides insights into how organizational structures and cultures influence the co-production of fire science. To institutionalize co-production, research organizations like RMRS can adjust the way they incentivize and evaluate researchers, increase investment in science delivery and personnel, and provide long-term funding to support collaborations.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF WILDLAND FIRE (2022)

Article Ecology

New types of investments needed to address barriers to scaling up wildfire risk mitigation

Laurie Yung, Benjamin J. Gray, Carina Wyborn, Brett Alan Miller, Daniel R. Williams, Maureen Essen

Summary: This study examines different frameworks for addressing the barriers to scaling up wildfire mitigation in the USA. It identifies three framings that prioritize different solutions or investments, including increasing resources, improving agency-agency partnerships, and engaging the public. Investing in collaborative capacity can enable agencies to speed up the pace and scale of mitigation work.

FIRE ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Development Studies

Understanding Perceptions of Climate Change Scenario Planning in United States Public Land Management Agencies

Daniel J. Murphy, Laurie Yung, Courtney Schultz, Brett Alan Miller, Carina Wyborn, Daniel R. Williams

Summary: As climate change poses challenges to traditional decision-making, natural resource management agencies are turning to nontraditional methods like 'futuring.' This article explores the limited uptake of these methods in the US and identifies potential benefits and barriers. Streamlining and mainstreaming are suggested as pathways to integrate scenario processes into decision-making.

SOCIETY & NATURAL RESOURCES (2023)

Article Ecology

Re-Envisioning Wildland Fire Governance: Addressing the Transboundary, Uncertain, and Contested Aspects of Wildfire

Brett Alan Miller, Laurie Yung, Carina Wyborn, Maureen Essen, Benjamin Gray, Daniel R. Williams

Summary: Wildfire is a complex problem involving various actors and landowners, and is influenced by uncertainty and unavoidable trade-offs. Addressing this problem requires governance approaches that fit the nature of wildfire, considering power, authority, and capacity distribution. Additionally, anticipatory governance is necessary to integrate uncertainty into decision-making and manage risk. Lastly, risk governance is important to navigate trade-offs and build legitimacy for actions addressing wildfire risk.

FIRE-SWITZERLAND (2022)

Review Ecology

Adapting Research, Management, and Governance to Confront Socioecological Uncertainties in Novel Ecosystems

Kevin S. McKelvey, William M. Block, Theresa B. Jain, Charles H. Luce, Deborah S. Page-Dumroese, Bryce A. Richardson, Victoria A. Saab, Anna W. Schoettle, Carolyn H. Sieg, Daniel R. Williams

Summary: Wildland research, management, and policy in western democracies have long relied on concepts of equilibrium, which are now being challenged by factors such as climate change, introduction of exotic species, and anthropogenic land conversion. In the face of increasing system novelty, there is a need for a more inclusive paradigm of collaborative governance and multiple forms of knowledge to adapt to constant change.

FRONTIERS IN FORESTS AND GLOBAL CHANGE (2021)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Long-distance hikers and their inner journeys: On motives and pilgrimage to Nidaros, Norway

Odd Inge Vistad, Hogne Oian, Daniel R. Williams, Patricia Stokowski

JOURNAL OF OUTDOOR RECREATION AND TOURISM-RESEARCH PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT (2020)

Article Environmental Studies

Re-placed - Reconsidering relationships with place and lessons from a pandemic

Patrick Devine-Wright, Lais Pinto de Carvalho, Andres Di Masso, Maria Lewicka, Lynne Manzo, Daniel R. Williams

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY (2020)

Article Environmental Studies

Support for regulatory and voluntary approaches to wildfire adaptation among unincorporated wildland-urban interface communities

Catrin M. Edgeley, Travis B. Paveglio, Daniel R. Williams

LAND USE POLICY (2020)

Article Environmental Studies

Between fixities and flows: Navigating place attachments in an increasingly mobile world

Andres Di Masso, Daniel R. Williams, Christopher M. Raymond, Matthias Buchecker, Barbara Degenhardt, Patrick Devine-Wright, Alice Hertzog, Maria Lewicka, Lynne Manzo, Azadeh Shahrad, Richard Stedman, Laura Verbrugge, Timo von Wirth

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY (2019)

Article Geography

A bridge over troubled water: A contextual analysis of social vulnerability to climate change in a riverine landscape in south-east Norway

Vegard Gundersen, Bjorn Petter Kaltenborn, Daniel R. Williams

NORSK GEOGRAFISK TIDSSKRIFT-NORWEGIAN JOURNAL OF GEOGRAPHY (2016)

Article Anthropology

Engaging Communities and Climate Change Futures with Multi-Scale, Iterative Scenario Building (MISB) in the Western United States

Daniel Murphy, Carina Wyborn, Laurie Yung, Daniel R. Williams, Cory Cleveland, Lisa Eby, Solomon Dobrowski, Erin Towler

HUMAN ORGANIZATION (2016)

Article Development Studies

Earth, Wind, and Fire: Wildfire Risk Perceptions in a Hurricane-Prone Environment

Soren M. Newman, Matthew S. Carroll, Pamela J. Jakes, Daniel R. Williams, Lorie L. Higgins

SOCIETY & NATURAL RESOURCES (2014)

No Data Available