4.6 Article

A suitable job?: A qualitative study of becoming a nurse in the context of a globalizing profession in India

Journal

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES
Volume 51, Issue 5, Pages 734-743

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2013.09.009

Keywords

Careers; Gender; Globalisation; India; Migration; Nurses

Categories

Funding

  1. British Sociological Association through the Phil Strong Memorial Prize

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: Research on Indian nurses has focused on their participation as global migrant workers for whom opportunities abroad act as an incentive for many to migrate overseas. However, little is known about the careers of Indian nurses, or the impact of a globalized health care market on nurses who remain and on the profession itself in India. Objectives: To explore nurses' accounts of entry into nursing in the context of the globalisation of the nursing profession in India, and the salience of 'migration' for nurses' individual careers. Design: Qualitative interview study (n = 56). Settings and participants: The study drew on interviews with 56 nurses from six sites in Bangalore, India. These included two government hospitals, two private hospitals, a Christian mission hospital, a private outpatient clinic and two private nursing colleges. Participants Were selected purposively to include nurses from Christian and Hindu backgrounds, a range of home States, ages and seniority and to deliberately over-recruit (rare) male nurses. Methods: Interviews covered how and why nurses entered nursing, their training and career paths to date, plans for the future, their experiences of providing nursing care and attitudes towards migration. Data analysis drew on grounded theory methods. Results: Nursing is traditionally seen as a viable career particularly for women from Christian communities in India, where it has created inter-generational 'nurse families'. In a globalizing India, nursing is becoming a job 'with prospects' transcending traditional caste, class and gender boundaries. Almost all nurses interviewed who intended seeking overseas employment envisaged migration as a short term option to satisfy career objectives - increased knowledge, skills and economic rewards - that could result in long-term professional and social status gains 'back home' in India. For others, migration was not part of their career plan: yet the increases in status that migration possibilities had brought were crucial to framing nursing as a 'suitable job' for a growing number of entrants. Conclusions: The possibility of migration has facilitated collective social mobility for Indian nurses. Migration possibilities were important not only for those who migrate, but for improving the status of nursing in general in India, making it a more attractive career option for a growing range of recruits. (C) 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Interventions promoting employee speaking-up within healthcare workplaces: A systematic narrative review of the international literature

Aled Jones, Joanne Blake, Mary Adams, Daniel Kelly, Russell Mannion, Jill Maben

Summary: Healthcare systems worldwide value the contribution of employee voice in ensuring patient care quality, but some employees may feel unable to speak up and complex system factors influence intervention implementation.

HEALTH POLICY (2021)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Living life in limbo: experiences of healthcare professionals during the HCPC fitness to practice investigation process in the UK

Jill Maben, Linda Hoinville, Dawn Querstret, Cath Taylor, Magdalena Zasada, Ruth Abrams

Summary: The study revealed significant psychological impacts on registrants undergoing the fitness to practice process, mainly due to factors such as lack of information, prolonged process time, and inadequate support leading to feelings of powerlessness and vulnerability. Recommendations for improvement include better psychological support, proportional processes, and consideration of context.

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH (2021)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Realist evaluation of Schwartz rounds® for enhancing the delivery of compassionate healthcare: understanding how they work, for whom, and in what contexts

J. Maben, C. Taylor, E. Reynolds, I. McCarthy, M. Leamy

Summary: Schwartz Center Rounds provide a safe and confidential space for healthcare staff to reflect and support each other, resulting in increased empathy and compassion for colleagues and patients, as well as positive changes to practice and teamwork. The program operates through a series of mechanisms and contextual factors that influence its outcomes, with a focus on trust, storytelling, vulnerability, and reflection.

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH (2021)

Review Nursing

Delegation of medication administration from registered nurses to non-registered support workers in community care settings: A systematic review with critical interpretive synthesis

Colin B. Shore, Jill Maben, Freda Mold, Kirsty Winkley, Angela Cook, Karen Stenner

Summary: This review explores the evidence on delegation of medication administration from registered nurse to non-registered support workers within community settings, aiming to understand the factors influencing the delegation process and its impact on service delivery and patient care. The study finds that delegation is a complex phenomenon influenced by various factors at macro, meso, and micro levels. Clear and consistent regulatory and governance frameworks are crucial for safe medication administration delegation. Further research is needed on implementation, clinical outcomes, and medication errors associated with medication administration delegation.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The (failed) promise of multimorbidity: chronicity, biomedical categories, and public health

Rebecca Lynch, Benjamin Hanckel, Judith Green

Summary: The concept of multimorbidity has been used as a lens for public health to address the burden of ill health in ageing populations. However, its application in integrating healthcare systems and prevention initiatives has led to increased complexity and challenges for service providers and patients. While policy narratives focus on patient self-management, those living with multiple conditions prefer a relational model of health.

CRITICAL PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Article Nursing

The impact of COVID-19 on the wellbeing of the UK nursing and midwifery workforce during the first pandemic wave: A longitudinal survey study

Keith Couper, Trevor Murrells, Julie Sanders, Janet E. Anderson, Holly Blake, Daniel Kelly, Bridie Kent, Jill Maben, Anne Marie Rafferty, Rachel M. Taylor, Ruth Harris

Summary: This study aimed to determine the psychological impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the UK nursing and midwifery workforce and identify potential factors associated with signs of post-traumatic stress disorder. The results of the survey showed a negative psychological impact among the nursing and midwifery workforce 3 months after the first wave of the pandemic. Both personal and workplace factors were found to be associated with adverse psychological effects linked to the COVID-19 pandemic.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2022)

Article Nursing

'You can't walk through water without getting wet' UK nurses' distress and psychological health needs during the Covid-19 pandemic: A longitudinal interview study

J. Maben, A. Conolly, R. Abrams, E. Rowland, R. Harris, D. Kelly, B. Kent, K. Couper

Summary: Pre-COVID-19 research highlighted the high risk of burnout, PTSD, and suicide among nurses worldwide. The Impact of COVID-19 on Nurses (ICON) interview study examined the impacts of the pandemic on nurses' psychosocial and emotional well-being. The study found that nurses have experienced emotional distress, and there is an urgent need for stigma reduction and a national nursing workforce recovery strategy.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2022)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Why do acute healthcare staff engage in unprofessional behaviours towards each other and how can these behaviours be reduced? A realist review protocol

Jill Maben, Justin Avery Aunger, Ruth Abrams, Mark Pearson, Judy M. Wright, Johanna Westbrook, Russell Mannion, Aled Jones

Summary: Introduction Unprofessional behaviours in healthcare staff, such as bullying, harassment, and microaggressions, have negative impacts on work performance, psychological safety, and patient care. This study aims to go beyond existing analyses by exploring the range, causes, and effects of unprofessional behaviours, as well as the effectiveness of mitigation strategies in different contexts and for different groups. The study will use a realist review methodology and involve stakeholder input. The findings will contribute to the development of contextually-sensitive strategies to reduce unprofessional behaviours and will be disseminated through various channels.

BMJ OPEN (2022)

Editorial Material Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Rethinking chronicity: public health and the problem of temporality

Judith Green, Rebecca Lynch

CRITICAL PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Editorial Material Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

The publics of public health: learning from COVID-19

Judith Green, Edward F. Fischer, Des Fitzgerald, T. S. Harvey, Felicity Thomas

Summary: This commentary reflects on the lessons learned from government and public health responses to COVID-19, highlighting the tension between conventional public health approaches and the potential for a paradigm shift towards a "healthy publics" approach. The authors discuss the ways in which diverse publics have been involved or created during the pandemic, which have often been ignored or erased by public health agencies in order to maintain certainty and public confidence. They conclude with five principles for reorganizing pandemic responses around a more contextualized and diverse understanding of "the public".

CRITICAL PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

The Impact of Colleague Suicide and the Current State of Postvention Guidance for Affected Co-Workers: A Critical Integrative Review

Hilary Causer, Johanna Spiers, Nikolaos Efstathiou, Stephanie Aston, Carolyn A. Chew-Graham, Anya Gopfert, Kathryn Grayling, Jill Maben, Maria van Hove, Ruth Riley

Summary: People bereaved by suicide are affected psychologically and physically, and the area of colleague suicide has been neglected with poorly developed postvention guidance. This critical review explores the impact of colleague suicide on surviving co-workers and the need for robust postvention support.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2022)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Case study research and causal inference

Judith Green, Benjamin Hanckel, Mark Petticrew, Sara Paparini, Sara Shaw

Summary: Case study methodology can contribute to understanding causal relationships by providing evidence on system actors' own theories of causality, demonstrative examples of causal relationships, evidence on causal mechanisms and the conditions under which they operate, and inference about causality in complex systems. Enhancing transparency in reporting and drawing on methods from other disciplines can strengthen the contribution that case studies make to the evidence base for public health and health services interventions.

BMC MEDICAL RESEARCH METHODOLOGY (2022)

Article Nursing

Speaking up during the COVID-19 pandemic: Nurses' experiences of organizational disregard and silence

Ruth Abrams, Anna Conolly, Emma Rowland, Ruth Harris, Bridie Kent, Daniel Kelly, Keith Couper, Jill Maben

Summary: This longitudinal qualitative study critically examines nurses' experiences of speaking up during COVID-19 and the consequences of doing so. The study found that nurses focused on speaking up about personal protective equipment (PPE), patient safety, and redeployment. However, their opportunities to speak up were often thwarted by the organizations' pandemic response policies. This missed opportunities to learn from those on the front line. Therefore, speaking up interventions should focus on enhancing the skills to speak up and respond appropriately.

JOURNAL OF ADVANCED NURSING (2023)

Article Otorhinolaryngology

Common challenges in cochlear implant surgery performed under local anaesthesia and how to overcome them: the experience of UK surgeons

R. Abrar, E. Stapleton

Summary: This study provides a comprehensive analysis of the national experience of cochlear implantation performed under local anesthesia in the UK. The study suggests that local anesthesia can be offered to eligible adult patients with favorable anatomy. The study also offers recommendations for managing common challenges and optimizing patient comfort and communication.

JOURNAL OF LARYNGOLOGY AND OTOLOGY (2023)

Article Nursing

'Pretty cathartic actually': Reflections on the attempt to reduce re-traumatization of researchers and nurses taking part in a longitudinal interview study

Anna Conolly, Emma Rowland, Ruth Abrams, Ruth Harris, Daniel Kelly, Bridie Kent, Jill Maben

Summary: This study critically evaluates the concepts of harm and re-traumatization in research and explores the ethical implications of conducting research on distressing topics using nurses' experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic as an example. By establishing a collaborative and team-based approach with participant autonomy and researcher reflexivity, the study successfully reduces potential harm and generates valuable data on nurses' working experiences.

JOURNAL OF ADVANCED NURSING (2023)

Article Nursing

Enhancing skin health and safety in aged care (SKINCARE trial): A cluster-randomised pragmatic trial

Bettina Voelzer, Monira El Genedy-Kalyoncu, Alexandra Fastner, Tsenka Tomova-Simitchieva, Konrad Neumann, Kathrin Hillmann, Ulrike Blume-Peytavi, Elisabeth Hahnel, Janna Sill, Katrin Balzer, Jan Kottner

Summary: The study aimed to evaluate the effects of implementing a skincare and prevention package on older nursing home residents. The results indicate that tailored and evidence-based nursing routines can improve skin health and safety in residential long-term care, but there was no significant impact on the skin barrier function.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2024)

Review Nursing

Risk prediction models for deep venous thrombosis in patients with acute stroke: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Han Fu, Dongjiang Hou, Ran Xu, Qian You, Hang Li, Qing Yang, Hao Wang, Jing Gao, Dingxi Bai

Summary: This study systematically reviewed published studies on risk prediction models for DVT in patients with acute stroke and found a high risk of bias. Future studies should focus on developing new models with larger samples, rigorous study designs, and multicenter external validation.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2024)

Article Nursing

Association of nurse understaffing and limited nursing work experience with in-hospital mortality among patients: A longitudinal register-based study

Laura Peutere, Jaana Pentti, Annina Ropponen, Mika Kivimaki, Mikko Harmae, Oxana Krutova, Jenni Ervasti, Aki Koskinen, Marianna Virtanen

Summary: Nurse understaffing and limited nursing work experience are associated with patient mortality during hospital stays, especially among patients with comorbidities. The use of administrative data to monitor and improve nurses' working conditions is crucial for reducing in-hospital mortality.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2024)

Review Nursing

Predictors of inadequate bowel preparation in older patients undergoing colonoscopy: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Yuanyuan Zhang, Lining Wang, Wenbi Wu, Shi Zhang, Min Zhang, Wenjing She, Qianqian Cheng, Nana Chen, Pengxia Fan, Yuxin Du, Haiyan Song, Xianyu Hu, Jiajie Zhang, Caiyan Ding

Summary: This meta-analysis identifies comorbid factors and behavioral factors that are significantly associated with inadequate bowel preparation in older adults undergoing colonoscopy.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2024)

Article Nursing

Effects of an online family-focused parenting support intervention on preterm infants' physical development and parents' sense of competence and care ability: A randomized controlled trial

Long Huang, Bing-yue Zhao, Xiao-ting Li, Shui-xiu Huang, Ting-ting Chen, Xiao Cheng, Si-jia Li, Hao Li, Rong -fang Hu

Summary: This study investigated the impact of a family-focused online parenting support intervention on parents' well-being and preterm infants' outcomes. The intervention showed significant improvements in parents' sense of competence, caregiving ability, depression, and social support. However, there were no significant differences in preterm infants' weight and length, or in family functioning.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES (2024)