4.6 Article

A DEA-BASED APPROACH TO RANKING MULTI-CRITERIA ALTERNATIVES

Publisher

WORLD SCIENTIFIC PUBL CO PTE LTD
DOI: 10.1142/S0219622009003259

Keywords

Data envelopment analysis; multi-objective; integer programming

Ask authors/readers for more resources

We propose a data envelopment analysis (DEA)-based approach to ranking multi-criteria alternatives. We call it the area of the efficiency score graph (AES) approach. Unlike the classical DEA score and D(k) measure that counts the number of DMUs (alternatives in DEA terminology) that should be removed from the set for each DMU k to become efficient, AES is not fully dependent on relative values of inputs/outputs of the alternatives in the set. It considers the change in efficiency scores of the alternatives while we delete 0, ... , D(k) number of alternatives from the set. The method avoids the negative effect of outliers and crowding in certain areas. It favors DMUs that manage to improve their efficiency scores quickly as we delete units from the set, and also alternatives that maintain high levels of efficiency scores as we delete units. We propose inclusion of weight restrictions into AES to incorporate decision maker preferences into the analysis. We apply our approach to ranking MBA programs. We provide rank lists of MBA programs by both AES and another DEA-based method for comparison. We also use AES scores to place programs in a small number of classes that are preference ordered from the best to the worst.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Management

Finding a representative nondominated set for multi-objective mixed integer programs

Gokhan Ceyhan, Murat Koksalan, Banu Lokman

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2019)

Article Management

An MCDM-integrated maximum coverage approach for positioning of military surveillance systems

Fatma Carman, Ceren Tuncer Sakar

JOURNAL OF THE OPERATIONAL RESEARCH SOCIETY (2019)

Article Management

Interactive approaches for biobjective problems with progressively changing solution sets

Gulsah Karakaya, Murat Koksalan

Summary: The study develops interactive approaches to help decision makers find satisfactory alternatives in a quasiconvex preference function environment, continuously searching alternative sets and estimating the decision maker's preference function to converge on the preferred alternative. Testing on multi-item, multi-round auction problems shows the approaches work well in obtaining solutions with preferred preference function values and minimal preference information needed.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2021)

Article Management

A new DEA approach to fully rank DMUs with an application to MBA programs

Melike Kubra Ekiz, Ceren Tuncer Sakar

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2020)

Article Operations Research & Management Science

Estimating criteria weight distributions in multiple criteria decision making: a Bayesian approach

Barbaros Yet, Ceren Tuncer Sakar

ANNALS OF OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2020)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

An interactive approach with filtering to find a preferred solution of a decision maker

Ceren Tuncer Sakar, Gulsah Karakaya

JOURNAL OF THE FACULTY OF ENGINEERING AND ARCHITECTURE OF GAZI UNIVERSITY (2019)

Article Management

An interactive algorithm for multiobjective ranking for underlying linear and quasiconcave value functions

Diclehan Tezcaner Ozturk, Murat Koksalan

Summary: The study introduces interactive algorithms to find a strict total order for a set of discrete alternatives based on linear and quasiconcave value functions. The algorithms iteratively update preference matrix to elicit preference information from the decision maker until termination conditions are met, showing efficient convergence to the exact total order for both value functions.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2021)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Estimating the form of a decision maker's preference function and converging towards preferred solutions

Gulsah Karakaya, Murat Koksalan

IISE TRANSACTIONS (2020)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

A flexible reference point-based multi-objective evolutionary algorithm: An application to the UAV route planning problem

Erdi Dasdemir, Murat Koksalan, Diclehan Tezcaner Ozturk

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2020)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

A New Interactive Algorithm for Continuous Multiple Criteria Problems: A Portfolio Optimization Example

Gulsah Karakaya, Ceren Tuncer Sakar

Summary: A novel interactive algorithm is proposed to guide decision makers in finding highly-preferred solutions in continuous multiple criteria problems, with experiments showing promising results.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & DECISION MAKING (2021)

Article Management

A multi-objective open vehicle routing problem with overbooking: Exact and heuristic solution approaches for an employee transportation problem

Erdi Dasdemir, Guldal Guleryuz, Murat Caner Testik, Diclehan Tezcaner Ozturk, Ceren Tuncer Sakar, Ozlem Testik

Summary: This paper addresses a bus routing problem and proposes a solution using mixed integer programming and heuristic approaches. The experiments show that the heuristics perform well in solving both small-scale and moderate-scale problems.

OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Reducing the question burden of patient reported outcome measures using Bayesian networks

Hakan Yuceturk, Halime Gulle, Ceren Tuncer Sakar, Christopher Joyner, William Marsh, Edibe Unal, Dylan Morrissey, Barbaros Yet

Summary: Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) are questionnaires completed by patients about their health status and are crucial for learning health systems. Using Bayesian Networks (BNs) for Computerized Adaptive Testing (CAT) can efficiently and accurately select questions, with results showing good predictive performance.

JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL INFORMATICS (2022)

Article Business

A Multicriteria Method to Form Optional Preventive Maintenance Plans: A Case Study of a Large Fleet of Vehicles

Gurkan Guven Guner, Ceren Tuncer Sakar, Barbaros Yet

Summary: This study proposes a systematic method to determine critical parts and create maintenance plans with different cost and capacity levels. The case study demonstrates that optional preventive maintenance packages can decrease costs while adhering to capacity limitations.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Assessing Serious Spinal Pathology Using Bayesian Network Decision Support: Development and Validation Study

Adele Hill, Christopher H. Joyner, Chloe Keith-Jopp, Barbaros Yet, Ceren Tuncer Sakar, William Marsh, Dylan Morrissey

Summary: This study aimed to improve the identification of serious spinal pathology (SSP) using a Bayesian network (BN) decision support tool. The study successfully developed and validated the BN, showing good performance in predicting SSP. This research provides a crucial first step in improving the ability to predict outcomes in low back pain by considering the problem of SSP.

JMIR FORMATIVE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

A Bayesian Network Decision Support Tool for Low Back Pain Using a RAND Appropriateness Procedure: Proposal and Internal Pilot Study

Adele Hill, Christopher H. Joyner, Chloe Keith-Jopp, Barbaros Yet, Ceren Tuncer Sakar, William Marsh, Dylan Morrissey

Summary: This study proposes a method to construct a Bayesian network representative of expert clinical reasoning for LBP and reports lessons learned from an internal pilot. The process was successful with the need for careful operational definition of terms and software support for remote training.

JMIR RESEARCH PROTOCOLS (2021)

No Data Available