4.3 Article

Medicine's inconvenient truth: the placebo and nocebo effect

Journal

INTERNAL MEDICINE JOURNAL
Volume 44, Issue 4, Pages 398-405

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/imj.12380

Keywords

placebo; nocebo; context effect; medical therapeutics; medical practice; medical ethics

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Placebo and nocebo effects are often regarded by clinicians as either a quaint reminiscence from the pre-therapeutic era, or simply as a technique for establishing the efficacy of therapeutic interventions within the locus of evidence-based practice. However, neither of these explanations sufficiently account for their complexity or their persistence and impact in clinical medicine. Placebo and nocebo effects are embedded in the very fabric of therapeutic relationships and are both a manifestation and outcome of the rituals that characterise clinical practice. They are also a stark reminder of the many personal and environmental factors, including the attitudes, beliefs and expectations of both doctor and patient, that shape the outcomes of health professional-patient interactions. We describe how recent biological and neuropsychiatric data have clarified the operation of placebo and nocebo effects in clinical practice - demonstrating the ability of the therapeutic context to modulate endogenous biological processes in a targeted manner. This, in turn, illustrates the potent philosophical and sociocultural aspects of medical praxis.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Editorial Material Oncology

Clearing the air: towards agreement about access to high cost cancer medicines

W. Lipworth, I. Kerridge, N. Ghinea, J. Zalcberg

ANNALS OF ONCOLOGY (2019)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

The My Health Record debate: ethical and cultural issues

Paul A. Komesaroff, Ian Kerridge

INTERNAL MEDICINE JOURNAL (2018)

Article Emergency Medicine

Autistic Man Falling Through the Cracks: Advanced Patient Transport and the Pop-up Recovery Ward

Peter Brendt, Alexander Mathews, Randall Greenberg, Mark Arnold

PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE (2019)

Article Immunology

A survey of infectious diseases and vaccination uptake in long-term hematopoietic stem cell transplant survivors in Australia

Gemma Dyer, Nicole Gilroy, Lisa Brice, Masura Kabir, David Gottlieb, Gillian Huang, Megan Hogg, Louisa Brown, Matt Greenwood, Stephen R. Larsen, John Moore, Mark Hertzberg, Jeff Tan, Christopher Ward, Ian Kerridge

TRANSPLANT INFECTIOUS DISEASE (2019)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

The 'autoimmune screen' More informed but no more enlightened

Mark H. Arnold

AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF GENERAL PRACTICE (2019)

Editorial Material Ethics

By Various Ways We Arrive at the Same End

Mark Henderson Arnold, Ian Kerridge

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOETHICS (2020)

Letter Medicine, General & Internal

The management of diverticulitis: a review of the guidelines

Mark H. Arnold

MEDICAL JOURNAL OF AUSTRALIA (2020)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Understanding the ethical implications of the rituals of medicine

Mark H. Arnold, Paul Komesaroff, Ian Kerridge

INTERNAL MEDICINE JOURNAL (2020)

Article Ethics

Accelerating the De-Personalization of Medicine: The Ethical Toxicities of COVID-19

Mark Arnold, Ian Kerridge

JOURNAL OF BIOETHICAL INQUIRY (2020)

Article Ethics

Teasing out Artificial Intelligence in Medicine: An Ethical Critique of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning in Medicine

Mark Henderson Arnold

Summary: The rapid integration of artificial intelligence in medicine introduces potential advantages and challenges for patients and physicians, involving issues of ontology, epistemology, and morality. The unclear legal relationship between AI and its users highlights the need for ongoing discourse and iterative development of future care models.

JOURNAL OF BIOETHICAL INQUIRY (2021)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

Australia needs to implement a national health strategy for doctors

Chanaka Wijeratne, Margaret P. Kay, Mark H. Arnold, Jeffrey C. L. Looi

MEDICAL JOURNAL OF AUSTRALIA (2022)

Review Ethics

The Ethics of Overlapping Relationships in Rural and Remote Healthcare. A Narrative Review

Rafael Thomas Osik Szumer, Mark Arnold

Summary: It is uncertain if there is an established rural ethics for managing professional boundaries, and if so, what theoretical approaches can help practitioners handle overlapping relationships. To effectively practice in rural and remote healthcare settings while being part of the community, practitioners need to establish and maintain safe, ethical, and sustainable therapeutic relationships. A narrative review found a significant amount of qualitative and theoretical literature that explores the prevalence of dual relationships among healthcare workers in rural and remote healthcare. Rather than condemning dual relationships, contemporary work focuses on understanding the experiences of healthcare workers and finding approaches that protect the therapeutic relationship while acknowledging the unique nature of rural and remote healthcare practice. It is concluded that practitioners need an ethics framework that is contextualized to their specific setting.

JOURNAL OF BIOETHICAL INQUIRY (2023)

Article Education, Scientific Disciplines

An Exploration of Knowledge and Attitudes of Medical Students and Rheumatologists to Placebo and Nocebo Effects: Threshold Concepts in Clinical Practice

Mark H. Arnold, Damien Finniss, Georgina M. Luscombe, Ian Kerridge

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL EDUCATION AND CURRICULAR DEVELOPMENT (2020)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

'Treat them into the grave': cancer physicians' attitudes towards the use of high-cost cancer medicines at the end of life

Miriam Wiersma, Narcyz Ghinea, Ian Kerridge, Wendy Lipworth

SOCIOLOGY OF HEALTH & ILLNESS (2019)

No Data Available