4.4 Article

Improving taxonomic resolution in large-scale freshwater biodiversity monitoring: an example using wetlands and Odonata

Journal

INSECT CONSERVATION AND DIVERSITY
Volume 12, Issue 1, Pages 9-17

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/icad.12323

Keywords

Alberta; aquatic macroinvertebrates; larvae; OdonataCentral; species identification; taxonomic resolution; wetlands

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Immature aquatic insects are a major source of taxonomic difficulty in large-scale freshwater biodiversity monitoring. Adult stages could improve taxonomic resolution for assessing distributions and trends of biodiversity. Odonata (dragonflies and damselflies) have accessible adult stages that should greatly enhance the amount of species-level information. We used Odonata and a wetland monitoring programme in Alberta, Canada to illustrate how much taxonomic information can be lost in larval collections, and an extensive adult records database to estimate what could be gained from adult surveys. Despite processing 22 638 odonate specimens from 975 wetlands throughout Alberta, larval monitoring failed to collect or identify almost 60% of the lentic-breeding Odonata species known from adult records. A total of 25 lentic-breeding dragonfly species and 12 lentic-breeding damselfly species were present in adult records and not the larval data, including species of conservation concern. Due to the abundance of early instars, a substantial 82% of the processed damselfly collection and 62% of the processed dragonfly collection was left at suborder. We recommend supplementing aquatic sampling with adult rearing, collecting, and observing (at least Odonata) to improve the basic inventory and overall status assessment in large-scale freshwater biodiversity monitoring. This is especially true when aquatic sampling is restricted to a suboptimal time of year for species identifications.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

A framework for linking competitor ecological differences to coexistence

Brittany H. Ousterhout, Mabel Serrano, Jason T. Bried, Adam M. Siepielski

JOURNAL OF ANIMAL ECOLOGY (2019)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Large-scale probabilistic identification of boreal peatlands using Google Earth Engine, open-access satellite data, and machine learning

Evan Ross Delancey, Jahan Kariyeva, Jason T. Bried, Jennifer N. Hird

PLOS ONE (2019)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Breeding thresholds in opportunistic Odonata records

Michael A. Patten, Emily A. Hjalmarson, Brenda D. Smith-Patten, Jason T. Bried

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2019)

Article Biology

Why do bugs perish? Range size and local vulnerability traits as surrogates of Odonata extinction risk

Maya Rocha-Ortega, Pilar Rodriguez, Jason Bried, John Abbott, Alex Cordoba-Aguilar

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2020)

Article Biology

Towards Global Volunteer Monitoring of Odonate Abundance

Jason Bried, Leslie Ries, Brenda Smith, Michael Patten, John Abbott, Joan Ball-Damerow, Robert Cannings, Adolfo Cordero-Rivera, Alex Cordoba-Aguilar, Paulo De Marco, Klaas-Douwe Dijkstra, Ales Dolny, Roy Van Grunsven, David Halstead, Filip Harabis, Christopher Hassall, Martin Jeanmougin, Colin Jones, Leandro Juen, Vincent Kalkman, Gabriella Kietzka, Celeste Searles Mazzacano, Albert Orr, Mary Ann Perron, Maya Rocha-Ortega, Goran Sahlen, Michael Samways, Adam Siepielski, John Simaika, Frank Suhling, Les Underhill, Erin White

BIOSCIENCE (2020)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Taxonomic distinctness poorly reflects floristic quality in a wetland study system

Suneeti K. Jog, Jason T. Bried

Summary: This study explored the relationship between taxonomic diversity and evolutionary structure in vascular plant assemblages, finding positive correlations between ecological conservatism and native richness with average taxonomic distinctness, and a negative correlation with exotic species. However, the ambiguity and nonlinear relationship of richness suggest that it may not be a suitable bioindicator for wetlands. Further research is needed to understand how evolutionary structure plays a role in bioassessment.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Predicting the distributions of regional endemic dragonflies using a combined model approach

Wade A. Boys, Adam M. Siepielski, Brenda D. Smith, Michael A. Patten, Jason T. Bried

Summary: This study combined the predictions of two machine learning algorithms to estimate the current and future distributions of two endemic dragonflies in the Ozark-Ouachita Interior Highlands region, showing the utility of these models in guiding field surveys. Future projections under climate change scenarios support maintaining current suitable areas. The results suggest that combining outputs of multiple species distribution models is a useful tool for informing the distributions of geographically limited or rare species.

INSECT CONSERVATION AND DIVERSITY (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Calculating population reductions of invertebrate species for IUCN Red List assessments

H. Resit Akcakaya, Axel Hochkirch, Jason T. Bried, Roy H. A. van Grunsven, John P. Simaika, Geert De Knijf, Sergio Henriques

Summary: Researchers argue that standardized methods for calculating population reductions should be consistently applied to assess extinction risk faced by invertebrate species, rather than relying on alternative approaches involving expert opinion. Consistent application of these methods allows for robust and objective assessments of extinction risk.

JOURNAL OF INSECT CONSERVATION (2021)

Article Plant Sciences

Linking functional diversity, trait composition, invasion, and environmental drivers in boreal wetland plant assemblages

Brandon E. Allen, Ermias T. Azeria, Jason T. Bried

Summary: The study found that landscape matrix and invasion intensity were the primary drivers of functional diversity, while invasion intensity was influenced by physicochemistry and functional diversity. The trait-environment patterns clearly separated wetlands by invasion status, with uninvaded wetlands surrounded by lowland conifers and stress-tolerant traits, and invaded wetlands containing traits associated with disturbance, high resource availability, and reproduction rates.

JOURNAL OF VEGETATION SCIENCE (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Improved detection of mass effect species assembly for applied metacommunity thinking

Jason T. Bried, Annika Vilmi

Summary: This article discusses the challenges and opportunities of dispersal mass effects in applied metacommunity ecology. The authors propose a new detection framework and test its applicability on a stream diatom survey. They find evidence of mass effects in the diatom groups, but due to data uncertainties, they suggest an alternate framework for more precise and robust detection.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Searching for Indicator Species of High Floristic Quality Depressional Wetlands in the US Southern Plains

Jason T. Bried, Tommi S. Fouts, Suneeti K. Jog

Summary: This study investigated the potential existence of floristic quality indicator species in wetlands, identifying candidate indicators for high floristic quality depressional wetlands. While some indicators showed promise, there were shortcomings in certain criteria, suggesting further research in other regions is necessary to determine the usefulness of indicator species in practice.

WETLANDS (2021)

Article Ecology

Nonnative Species Limitation of Floristic Quality Scores in Wetland Mitigation Performance and Multimetric Health assessment

Jason T. Bried, Suneeti K. Jog

Summary: Nonnative species can limit floristic quality scores, affecting wetland restoration and ecological health goals. However, their impact may be less significant in multimetric situations.

WETLANDS (2022)

Article Ecology

The potential of trait data to increase the availability of bioindicators: A case study using plant conservatism values

Varina E. Crisfield, Cari D. Ficken, Brandon E. Allen, Suneeti K. Jog, Jason T. Bried

Summary: Biological indicators are commonly used to evaluate ecosystem condition, but their use is often constrained by the availability of species-specific indicator values. This study tests the potential of approximating missing bioindicator values using publicly accessible trait data. The results show consistency between trait values and expert-assigned ecological conservatism scores (C-scores), suggesting traits can be used to predict C-scores.

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS (2023)

Article Entomology

Odonata species diversity, distributions, and status in a rare sand prairie-savanna wetscape

Jason T. Bried

Summary: The study conducted in a sand prairie-savanna wetscape in Illinois revealed a high diversity of odonate species and highlighted the importance of wetland networks for aquatic insects. Different types of sites within the wetscape contributed significantly to beta diversity, with breeding occurrences playing a key role. The distribution and abundance of various odonate species in the area were found to be influenced by spatial and temporal factors, resulting in the classification of common, uncommon, and rare species across the wetscape.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ODONATOLOGY (2021)

No Data Available