4.0 Article

Strategic outsourcing decisions for manufacturers competing on product quality

Journal

IIE TRANSACTIONS
Volume 46, Issue 4, Pages 313-329

Publisher

TAYLOR & FRANCIS INC
DOI: 10.1080/0740817X.2012.761368

Keywords

Channel structure; game theory; horizontal and vertical differentiation; quality improvement; outsourcing

Funding

  1. National Natural Science Foundation of China [71371093, 70971060, 71071073]
  2. National Planning Office of Philosophy and Social Science [11ZD169]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This article examines strategic outsourcing decisions for two competing manufacturers whose key components have quality improvement (QI) opportunities. We consider the effects of vertical and horizontal product differentiation on demand. In deriving the Subgame Perfect Nash Equilibria (SPNE), it is shown that either a symmetric outsourcing strategy (i.e., both manufacturers outsource) or an asymmetric sourcing strategy profile (i.e., manufacturers use different sourcing strategies) can be an SPNE. Insights are provided into how sourcing strategies are affected by the factors such as fixed setup cost, unit production cost, QI efficiency, and horizontal and vertical differentiations. It is found that larger horizontal differentiation expands the range over which symmetric outsourcing is an equilibrium. In addition, the outsourcing manufacturer may provide a higher QI level, produce a higher quantity, and offer a lower retail price than the insourcing one in the asymmetric sourcing setting. On the other hand, the insourcing manufacturer should pay more attention to the effect of the rival's sourcing strategy on the QI level than the outsourcing one. Finally, it is shown that all players have an incentive to determine sourcing partner relationships before the wholesale price contract is offered.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.0
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Economics

Analysis of cold-chain service outsourcing modes in a fresh agri-product supply chain

Yunlong Yu, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This paper examines the impact of outsourcing modes on supply chain decisions and profits in a fresh agri-product supply chain. The study finds that the preferred outsourcing mode depends on service cost and market size, with the possibility of a common preference between supplier and retailer. Retailer-outsourcing is more profitable for logistics providers, with quantity discounts and service levels being important factors. The decision sequence between supplier and retailer is crucial in determining the beneficial outsourcing mode.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART E-LOGISTICS AND TRANSPORTATION REVIEW (2021)

Article Management

Pricing and entry strategies for competitive firms with optimistic entrant

Peng Xu, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: The optimism of entrepreneurs can affect the entry and pricing strategies in the market. High optimism of the entrant may lead to incorrect decisions, while different levels of optimism can result in varying outcomes that impact both the entrant and the incumbent. Asymmetric information and pre-entry pricing settings may also influence the decision-making process and outcomes in the market.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Management

Channel differentiation strategy in a dual-channel supply chain considering free riding behavior

Chen Tian, Tiaojun Xiao, Jennifer Shang

Summary: This research investigates the channel differentiation strategy that a manufacturer should adopt when facing free riders in the emergence of e-commerce. The study finds that consumers are more likely to engage in free riding when faced with differentiated products, and provides optimal strategies for manufacturers. Furthermore, through an agent-based model, the research derives managerial insights for more complex situations.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

PREANNOUNCEMENT STRATEGY OF PLATFORM-TYPE NEW PRODUCT FOR COMPETING PLATFORMS: TECHNICAL OR MARKETING INFORMATION

Ye Jiang, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: The message released to consumers and developers plays a significant role in the preannouncement strategy of platforms' new product. By considering the perspectives of consumers and developers' information perceptions, we have developed a game model that describes the impact of information preannouncement on consumers, developers, and platforms behavior in a competitive environment. Our findings reveal that the nature of the preannouncement strategy depends on the heterogeneity of development capability and competitive advantage of the platforms.

JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL AND MANAGEMENT OPTIMIZATION (2022)

Article Engineering, Manufacturing

Managing hospital platelet inventory with mid-cycle expedited replenishments and returns

Kebing Chen, Jing-Sheng Song, Jennifer Shang, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This article introduces an inventory system with a three-period shelf life for perishable products in small and medium-sized hospitals. It proposes an optimal regular replenishment policy and a mid-cycle inventory adjustment policy. The article also analyzes the optimal policy parameters for expedited orders with different types of platelets and reveals the structural properties of the optimal policy using anti-multimodularity techniques.

PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Operations Research & Management Science

Contract design for technology sharing between two farmers

Qing Zhang, Juan Li, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This article investigates the motivation of technology sharing among farmers and provides suggestions on contract design. The study finds that under a fixed-fee contract, both farmers benefit when the technology sharing ratio exceeds a threshold. Under a royalty-fee contract, the licensor only shares technology with similar production costs. In a supply chain setting, a win-win outcome is possible under a fixed-fee contract if the technology sharing ratio is below a certain threshold.

ANNALS OF OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Pricing strategy and collection rate for a supply chain considering environmental responsibility behaviors and rationality degree

Danping Wen, Tiaojun Xiao, Mehdi Dastani

Summary: This study investigates the optimization of pricing strategy and collection rate in a supply chain considering environmental responsibility behaviors. Game-theoretical models are developed to explore this issue under perfect rationality and bounded rationality scenarios. The study finds that different pricing strategies have different impacts on the profitability of the manufacturer and retailer, and the consumers' acceptance degree of remanufactured products plays a crucial role in determining the optimal strategy.

COMPUTERS & INDUSTRIAL ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Business

Retailer's decoy strategy versus consumers' reference price effect in a retailer-Stackelberg supply chain

Yichao Yuan, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: "The decoy strategy for bundling is an important marketing option that leverages consumers' reference price effect. This study develops a game-theoretic model to analyze the joint decisions on pricing and decoy strategies in a supply chain. The findings reveal that both the retailer and manufacturer benefit from consumers' low reference price effect under both decoy strategies, while the high reference price effect negatively impacts their profits."

JOURNAL OF RETAILING AND CONSUMER SERVICES (2022)

Article Business

Quality, Greenness, and Product Line Choices for a Manufacturer With Environmental Responsibility Behaviors

Tiaojun Xiao, Tsan-Ming Choi

Summary: This article investigates the decisions of green manufacturers on product quality, greenness, and product line choices, and explores the impact of product line length on environmental performance. The study found that when relevant costs are low, manufacturers may extend their product lines, potentially improving environmental performance and manufacturer utility.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Business

Choice of Cost Reduction Mode in a Contract Manufacturing Supply Chain with Substitutable Products

Yunlong Yu, Tiaojun Xiao, Caichun Chai

Summary: This article investigates the choice of cost reduction mode in a supply chain and finds that the choice of the original brand manufacturer (OBM) and the contract manufacturer (CM) can affect each other's interests. The CM may be worse off with strong spillover from the OBM's investment. The OBM is more likely to reduce common cost if the common component is costly and the spillover is weak.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Management

Analysis of online rebates and commission formats in a retailer-Stackelberg supply chain with cashback website

Peng Xu, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This study examines the online rebate and commission format selection strategies in a retailer-Stackelberg supply chain with an e-tailer, a manufacturer, and a cashback website. The research highlights the importance of product valuation and consumer characteristics in shaping these strategies. The results suggest that rebates can improve supply chain performance but may also trap consumers, and that the choice of commission format depends on product valuation and consumer preferences. The findings also reveal that temporary rebate promotions can create a triple win situation for the manufacturer, e-tailer, and consumers, particularly when the manufacturer acts as the leader.

DECISION SCIENCES (2022)

Article Management

Quality disclosure and unauthorized channel choice

Xiaohui Yu, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This paper investigates the quality disclosure strategy of a manufacturer facing an unauthorized channel and develops game models. The research finds that when the cost of creating an unauthorized channel is high or consumer acceptance of gray market products and the difference in willingness to pay between markets are low, the manufacturer should conceal quality information. When the parameters are moderate, the manufacturer should disclose quality information, with a possibility of the retailer creating an unauthorized channel. When the cost is low or consumer acceptance and market differences are high, the manufacturer should conceal quality information to save disclosure costs and allow the unauthorized channel to exist.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Management

Sales manipulation strategies of competitive firms on an e-commerce platform: Beneficial or harmful?

Qing Zhang, Juan Li, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This study investigates sales manipulation strategies of high-quality and low-quality firms on a platform using game theoretical models. The findings show that a small amount of sales manipulation can harm each firm, and when only one firm manipulates its sales volume, it affects the total market share and the profit of the other firm. The study also reveals the conditions for firms' sales manipulation and its impact on the platform's profit.

DECISION SCIENCES (2023)

Article Economics

Green level and environmental labeling strategies in a dual-channel green supply chain considering consumer trust

Zhengzheng Chen, Tiaojun Xiao

Summary: This paper examines environmental labeling strategies in a green supply chain and finds that consumer trust in environmental labeling, green R&D cost, and the demand share of the direct channel are crucial factors for supply chain decision making. Additionally, external certified labeling leads to higher profits for the retailer, and risk-averse retailers prefer external certified environmental labeling.

MANAGERIAL AND DECISION ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

EVOLUTION OF REVENUE PREFERENCE FOR COMPETING FIRMS WITH NONLINEAR INVERSE DEMAND

Caichun Chai, Tiaojun Xiao, Zhangwei Feng

Summary: This paper examines evolutionarily stable preferences of competing firms in independent markets, finding different evolutionarily stable strategies under varying pricing capabilities. Important conclusions are drawn regardless of whether preferences are discrete or continuous.

JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL AND MANAGEMENT OPTIMIZATION (2022)

No Data Available