4.4 Article

The bit in the middle: a synthesis of global health literature on policy formulation and adoption

Journal

HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING
Volume 29, Issue -, Pages 23-34

Publisher

OXFORD UNIV PRESS
DOI: 10.1093/heapol/czu060

Keywords

Policy adoption; policy formulation; policy process

Funding

  1. Alliance for Health Policy and Systems Research

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Policy formulation and adoption are poorly understood phases of the health policy process. We conducted a narrative synthesis of 28 articles on health policy in low- and middle-income countries to provide insight on what kinds of activities take place in these phases, the actors crafting policies and the institutions in which policy making occurs. The narrative synthesis involved an inductive process to identify relevant articles, extract relevant data from text and reach new understandings. We find that actors exercising decision-making power include not just various governmental entities, but also civil society, commissioners, nongovernmental organizations and even clergy. We also find that most articles identified two or more distinct institutions in which policy formulation and adoption occurred. Finally, we identify seven distinct activities inherent in policy formulation and adoption: generation of policy alternatives, deliberation and/or consultation, advocacy of specific policy alternatives, lobbying for specific alternatives, negotiation of policy decisions, drafting or enacting policy and guidance/influence on implementation development. Health policy researchers can draw on these categories to deepen their understanding of how policy formulation and adoption unfolds.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Implementing effective salt reduction programs and policies in low- and middle-income countries: learning from retrospective policy analysis in Argentina, Mongolia, South Africa and Vietnam

Jacqui Webster, Joseph Alvin Santos, Martyna Hogendorf, Kathy Trieu, Emalie Rosewarne, Briar McKenzie, Lorena Allemandi, Batsaikhan Enkhtungalag, Ha Thi Phuong Do, Pamela Naidoo, Clare Farrand, Temo Waqanivalu, Laura Cobb, Kent Buse, Rebecca Dodd

Summary: The implementation of salt reduction interventions in low- and middle-income countries is influenced by various factors. Important drivers include global targets, regional consultations, local research and advocacy, support from international experts, government leadership, and regulatory processes. All countries have population-level targets and strategies to reduce salt consumption, and prioritize engaging the food industry. However, barriers such as lack of funding and technical support, absence of reliable local data, and changes in leadership hinder effective implementation. None of the countries have a comprehensive approach to surveillance or regulation for labeling, and opinions on the potential benefits of low sodium salts are mixed.

PUBLIC HEALTH NUTRITION (2022)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

England's privatised water: profits over people and planet

Kent Buse, Kate Bayliss

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

Food security, gender, and sexual and reproductive health and rights: a fragile golden thread

Traci L. Baird, Kent Buse

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

Tedros calls for a paradigm shift-what next on this political agenda?

Kent Buse

Summary: In an unprecedented call, the World Health Organization's director general urges countries to reorient and rebalance their health systems. Here are five ways to support this inspiring, timely, and challenging task of creating healthy societies.

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Taking on the Commercial Determinants of Health at the level of actors, practices and systems

Jennifer Lacy-Nichols, Alexandra Jones, Kent Buse

Summary: Addressing the Commercial Determinants of Health (CDoH) is crucial for achieving health equity and meeting the health-related targets of the SDGs. This study presents a visual heuristic of three core aspects of CDoH and highlights the need for more research and evidence from the Global South, particularly on effective strategies to curb harmful impacts. It also proposes an agenda and actions for different stakeholders to address CDoH, emphasizing the importance of focusing on system-level changes to improve health equity.

FRONTIERS IN PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Letter Medicine, General & Internal

WHO regional elections-more transparency and scrutiny essential

Kent Buse, J. V. R. Prasada Rao, Vivian Lin

LANCET (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Fifty shades of partnerships: a governance typology for public private engagement in the nutrition sector

Dori Patay, Rob Ralston, Aliyah Palu, Alexandra Jones, Jacqui Webster, Kent Buse

Summary: This paper introduces the Governance Typology for Public Private Engagement in the Nutrition Sector, which conceptualizes different forms of engagement with the food industry in tackling diet-related noncommunicable disease. The typology covers different levels of industry and civil society actor engagement, types of industry actors being engaged, and the substantive policy focus of engagement. It aims to inform national level nutrition policy makers on good engagement practices and can be extended to other industries that profit from products detrimental to human and planetary health.

GLOBALIZATION AND HEALTH (2023)

Article Nutrition & Dietetics

Do Food and Nutrition Policies in Ethiopia Support the Prevention of Non-Communicable Diseases through Population-Level Salt Reduction Measures? A Policy Content Analysis

Dejen Yemane Tekle, Emalie Rosewarne, Joseph Alvin Santos, Kathy Trieu, Kent Buse, Aliyah Palu, Anne Marie Thow, Stephen Jan, Jacqui Webster

Summary: Despite slow policy adoption and high sodium consumption, this analysis aims to identify gaps and opportunities for salt reduction in Ethiopia by examining relevant policy documents. The study found that while the government has established policy frameworks, there is room for improvement in implementation and addressing inequities.

NUTRIENTS (2023)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

Advance the African Medicines Agency to benefit health and economic development

Michel Sidibe, Abdoul Dieng, Kent Buse

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2023)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

The dearth of disaggregated health data: a political rather than a technical challenge

Kent Buse, Abhishek Gautam, Unsia Hussain, Victoria Olarewaju

Summary: The inability to break down population datasets hinders efforts to achieve health equity and ensure government accountability for progress.

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2023)

Review Endocrinology & Metabolism

Changing the global obesity narrative to recognize and reduce weight stigma: A position statement from the World Obesity Federation

Sarah Nutter, Laura A. Eggerichs, Taniya S. Nagpal, Ximena Ramos Salas, Christine Chin Chea, Shubo Saiful, Johanna Ralston, Olivia Barata-Cavalcanti, Claudia Batz, Louise A. Baur, Susie Birney, Sheree Bryant, Kent Buse, Michelle I. Cardel, Aastha Chugh, Ada Cuevas, Mychelle Farmer, Allison Ibrahim, Ishu Kataria, Catherine Kotz, Ted Kyle, Sara le Brocq, Vicki Mooney, Clare Mullen, Joe Nadglowski, Margot Neveux, Karin Papapietro, Jaynaide Powis, Rebecca M. Puhl, Bernardo Rea Ruanova, Jessica F. Saunders, Fatima Cody Stanford, Ogweno Stephen, Kwang Wei Tham, Agbo Urudinachi, Lesly Vejar-Renteria, Danielle Walwyn, John Wilding, Saifullah Yusop

Summary: This article discusses the definition and significance of weight stigma and presents nine recommendations for reducing harmful obesity narratives on a global scale.

OBESITY REVIEWS (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Protecting and promoting the rights of the 'reserve army of labour': a policy analysis of structural determinants of migrant worker health in Pakistan and Qatar

Sarah Hawkes, Mireille Evagora-Campbell, Aysha Zahidie, Fauziah Rabbani, Kent Buse

Summary: Labour migrants often face health inequities due to social and structural determinants. This study examined the labour migrant health ecosystem between Pakistan and Qatar and assessed the policies in both countries in relation to global guidance, equity, and accountability. The findings revealed limited implementation potential, minimal consideration of gender, equity, and rights, and a lack of coordination among stakeholders. Effectively addressing health determinants for labour migrants requires a shift in government attitudes towards migrants as deserving equality and rights.

HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

How to do (or not to do) horizontal ellipsis how to embed equity in the conduct of health research: lessons from piloting the 8Quity tool

Misimi Kakoti, Devaki Nambiar, Amy Bestman, Damian Garozzo-Vaglio, Kent Buse

Summary: Global health research should aim to address power imbalances and inequities in health systems and societies. The integration of equity considerations in research practices aligns with efforts to promote equitable partnerships among researchers and communities impacted by their research. Lessons from a pilot study using the '8Quity' tool, which assesses the integration of equity in research practices, are described. The tool comprises eight domains of equity and provides practical resources for each domain. While tools like 8Quity are helpful, broader societal changes are necessary to ensure equity in research.

HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Integrating HIV and substance misuse services: a person-centred approach grounded in human rights

Victoria Haldane, Anne-Sophie Jung, Chuan De Foo, Pami Shrestha, Elena Urdaneta, Eva Turk, Juan Gaviria, Jesus Boadas, Kent Buse, J. Jaime Miranda, Steffanie A. Strathdee, Ashley Barratt, Michel Kazatchkine, Martin McKee, Helena Legido-Quigley

Summary: Integrating HIV-related care with treatment for substance use disorder allows for better care for individuals with these conditions, but current models have gaps in considering human rights and structural factors. Successful integration requires a person-centered approach and a focus on social, economic, and political inequalities.

LANCET PSYCHIATRY (2022)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Promoting labour migrant health equity through action on the structural determinants: A systematic review

Mireille Evagora-Campbell, Aysha Zahidie, Kent Buse, Fauziah Rabbani, Sarah Hawkes

Summary: This study highlights the lack of research on addressing the structural determinants of health inequities in labor migrants, despite their higher health risks. The research community needs to focus on working across disciplines and sectors to address these structural factors of health inequities.

JOURNAL OF MIGRATION AND HEALTH (2022)

No Data Available