Reviewer Roulette

Comment

Peer Review Antagonist Mean-spirited Physics

This paper, although is well written, does not contain any physics, and therefore, is not suitable for publication in PRE. Moreover, from communication systems' point of view the paper does not address any communication system. This is yet another paper on chaos base communication which offers nothing.

- Comment from Physical Review E reviewer

Context by Author

This comment shows how reviewers can, sometimes, be mean spirited. That was the first paper I submitted without my former colleagues (supervisors at that time). I got really sad, because they misinterpreted my work and were very mean in their comments. I got over it and learnt much more about the subject because of that, but I will never forget.