Verified Reviews - PeerJ
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

ybjgw 2023-05-24

From submission to acceptance, it took 11 months.

JointWmt 2023-05-18

Trouble asking two questions:
Do all authors agree before starting the review process?
Is this an advance payment for the layout fee? After submitting the manuscript, there is a fee of 1549 to be paid.

gaizaoziwogao 2023-04-27

May I ask the original poster if they have received the first-instance result? It has been over 20 days since I submitted my manuscript, and the status has always been "In Review," indicating that they are still looking for an academic editor. Can I request an update?

gaizaoziwogao 2023-04-27

May I ask how long it took for the original poster to receive the result of the first trial? It has been 3 weeks under review, can we urge them?

nienuk 2023-03-17

Received the first review result after submitting the manuscript for over a month. Made major revisions, which took about half a month. After resubmitting, received an acceptance notice in nearly a month.

Memerey 2023-02-23

Hello, any progress? It has been the same situation for a month, feeling anxious...

Memerey 2023-02-23

Can we expedite the review process, which has been ongoing for a month?

Memerey 2023-02-23

Can you expedite the "in review" status within a month?

德云小生 2023-01-14

The layout fee is getting higher and higher. It used to be $1095 when submitting articles, then it increased to $1195, and now it has unexpectedly risen to $1595. It is estimated that it will continue to increase in the future! The cost-effectiveness is not as good as before! It is better to submit to other open access or non-open access platforms! Indeed, the end of open access is constantly increasing article processing charges (APC)!

flyawaking 2023-01-13

6 months, from submission to acceptance, it's not as fast as expected. The data verification in the process is quite strict.

petshi530 2022-12-29

Submitted basic experimental research twice in a row, once because of raising animal ethics issues, and once because of requesting the original full experimental figures. Although the impact factor is average, I still feel that I have worked hard to be meticulous.

暮夏钟鼓1 2022-11-22

May I ask if all authors need to agree? Thank you for answering!

暮夏钟鼓1 2022-11-22

OP, may I ask if all authors need to agree on the submission? Thank you!

暮夏钟鼓1 2022-11-22

Do all authors need to agree, please?

暮夏钟鼓1 2022-11-22

"OP, may I ask if all authors need to agree?"

暮夏钟鼓1 2022-11-22

May I ask if all authors need to agree?

暮夏钟鼓1 2022-11-22

May I ask about the current status of the host's manuscript? Do all the authors need to agree?

红果果 2022-11-12

Yes, the agreement of all authors is required.

尔尔 2022-11-08

Do you need the consent of all authors before starting the review process?

冲冲冲10000 2022-10-06

Posted on March 2nd, two months later, major revision suggestions were given. The reviewer was relatively professional and asked some key questions, but they were not fatal flaws. After returning, the next step was minor revisions. The editor said that the academic issues were resolved, only language issues were left and needed polishing. Regarding language issues, there were three rounds of revisions back and forth, which was quite troublesome. It felt like maybe I encountered the editor-in-chief, as he seemed more responsible. Finally, it was accepted on October 5th.

勇往直前 2022-09-27

2022.5.14 Submission
5.18 Review
7.13 Major revision
8.9 Resubmission after revision
9.2 Acceptance
9.2 Payment
9.13 Proofreading
9.20 Finalize publication date

The magazine has high requirements for the rigor of data analysis and the speed of editorial processing.

库里在青岛 2022-09-05

Excuse me, do all authors need to confirm before finding an academic editor? It has been two weeks and we still haven't found an academic editor.

QQ3 2022-08-23

Why do you say that?

忽然慧慧都 2022-08-17

Have you hired a proofreading company to proofread?

coco2022 2022-07-07

May I ask what "in review" means? It has been several days already.

2022-07-06

Hello, may I trouble you to ask how long it took for your academic editing invitation?

笑纳接受 2022-06-20

I submitted the article on April 25, 2022; received minor revisions on May 12; submitted the revised draft on May 21; and accepted on June 6 (although it should have been faster, as several resubmissions were not approved by the editor due to various minor issues, and the resubmitted draft was only successfully submitted on May 27). Overall, the experience was good, with a fast turnaround time, responsible editors, and diligent external reviewers. I would recommend submitting to journals of similar caliber.

木棉咿呀哟 2022-05-11

Is "awaiting revision" rejected? Because of the issue with the author's email, I don't want to submit to this journal anymore.

木棉咿呀哟 2022-05-11

Can I ask if "awaiting revision" means the submission has been rejected?

菲菲最棒啦 2022-03-31

First submission in November 2021.
Accepted on March 15, 2022 and published on March 30.
After undergoing major and minor revisions, the reviewer asked detailed questions and emphasized the use of statistical methods. The submission required uploading raw data, and it was sufficient to carefully answer and supplement the data. Fortunately, this coincided with my graduation, which is a great relief!

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now