一朵小红花cup 2023-04-13

2022.12.19 submission - Submitted on December 19, 2022.
2022.12.21 with editor - Under review by the editor on December 21, 2022.
2022.12.23 under review - Currently under review on December 23, 2022.
2023.1.21 required reviews completed - Required reviews have been completed on January 21, 2023.
2023.1.28 decision in process - Decision is being processed on January 28, 2023.
2023.2.1 major revision - Major revisions are required on February 1, 2023.
2023.3.9 re-submission - Re-submitted on March 9, 2023.
2023.3.10 with editor - Under review by the editor on March 10, 2023.
2023.3.19 under review - Currently under review on March 19, 2023.
2023.4.10 required reviews completed - Required reviews have been completed on April 10, 2023.
2023.4.12 minor revision - Minor revisions are required on April 12, 2023.
2023.4.12 re-submission - Re-submitted on April 12, 2023.
2023.4.13 accepted - Accepted on April 13, 2023.
Thank you to the four reviewers for their valuable comments and to Prof Pan for providing the opportunity to make revisions. The quality of the article has greatly improved.

999geochemoeng 2023-03-24

The journal has developed rapidly in recent years and is no longer the low-quality journal that people talked about five years ago.

The journal's review process is strict and standardized. From the associate editor to the executive editor, editorial supervisor, and editor-in-chief, the quality control is relatively strict, which shows the journal's determination to develop at a high level.

There are three rounds of review, and the reviewers can be quite strict. Sometimes their opinions are not very professional, but the editors are responsible and make decisions based on their own judgment. I don't know why, but now the review period is generally longer (more than 5 months), which can be frustrating.

After the name change this year, the journal may not be indexed for two years (this is usually the case, but it is not certain). The source of submissions may be affected. However, the research field of the journal is timely and promising, making it worth investing in.

寻欢 2023-03-22

Changed the name, gas science and engineering, but still sci.

叶小乐 2023-03-22

I heard that you were kicked out of SCI? Is it true?

tygq 2023-03-21

2022.10.30 Submission
2022.10.31 With editor
2022.11.09 Assigned to an editor
2022.11.30 Under review
2022.12.19 Required reviews completed
2023.01.04 Revision
2023.01.29 Re-submission; With editor
2023.01.30 Under review
2023.02.15 Required reviews completed
2023.03.06 Decision in Process
2023.03.07 Minor Revision
2023.03.14 Accepted

Translation:

2022.10.30 Submission
2022.10.31 With editor
2022.11.09 Assigned to an editor
2022.11.30 Under review
2022.12.19 Required reviews completed
2023.01.04 Revision
2023.01.29 Re-submission; With editor
2023.01.30 Under review
2023.02.15 Required reviews completed
2023.03.06 Decision in Process
2023.03.07 Minor Revision
2023.03.14 Accepted

小xiao赵同学 2023-02-23

What happened after "under editor evaluation" and "decision in process"? I also submitted my work a couple of days ago and it's still like that. I'm getting worried.

fighting 2023-02-19

The partition is unclear, but it is still included in SCI. Due to the recent name change, the WOS system has not been updated yet. You can focus on the updates of the past few months. As long as the new journal name is updated in the WOS system, the corresponding articles will be retrievable.

Doctor Zhang 2023-02-18

The journal is good, but unfortunately it underwent a name change. The renamed journal only obtained impact factor and ranking two years later, so this article can be considered wasted.

寻欢 2023-01-31

Second trial, twenty-eight days, minor repairs.

FengX 2023-01-31

After changing the name, can I still obtain a retrieval certificate? Are the articles published under the new journal name still considered SCI and included in the second district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences? I noticed that the ISSN has changed.

FengX 2023-01-31

Can I still retrieve proof after changing the name? Are the articles published under the new title still considered SCI and in the second district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences? I noticed that the ISSN has changed.

bigVger 2022-12-23

Received at Editorial Office 5 Sep 2022
Article revised 15 Nov 2022
Article accepted for publication 6 Dec 2022
Overall, it was quite fast. After acceptance, I received a message stating that the journal will be renamed to Gas Science and Engineering starting from January 2023. This is the first time I have encountered a journal renaming.

寻欢 2022-12-01

Returned after one month of initial review, with four reviewers, two of whom had no comments, only one positive evaluation. One gave minor revisions. The final review was quite negative. The final editor requested major revisions, with a deadline of 20 days. Good luck!

hahajing321 2022-10-02

6.5 months, feeling uncomfortable.

鑫~fighting 2022-09-07

March 30, 2022 Submitted to Journal
April 1, 2022 With Editor
April 13, 2022 Under Review
June 6, 2022 Review Complete
June 28, 2022 Major Revision
July 18, 2022 ReSubmitted to Journal
July 18, 2022 With Editor
July 23, 2022 Under Review
September 5, 2022 Review Complete
September 6, 2022 Decision in Process
September 6, 2022 Accept

hahajing321 2022-08-10

It's really slow, I remember it has been with the editor for more than 40 days, and then required reviews completed took about a month as well. It was submitted in early March, and now it has been 5 months, but it's still stuck at "Decision in process" and hasn't made any progress.

爱吃菠萝的猪猪女孩 2022-07-10

Does this journal check for plagiarism before submission? Is the requirement for similarity rate strict?

hjl1998 2022-05-20

What are the different stages that one will go through when accepting repairs?

CK柠檬 2022-05-11

May I ask if all authors need to agree after submitting a manuscript to this journal?

CUGB 2022-04-13

2021.12.6 submitted
2022.3.6 received notice of major revision
2022.3.30 returned revised manuscript
2022.4.13 accepted directly
It took 4 months. However, the previous one took 7 months, including major and minor revisions. The review speed is not stable.

wuy 2022-03-24

After appealing to the editor-in-chief, a major revision was given. The Australian editor's handling was extremely slow, taking over a month for each decision. It took nearly a year and two months in total, but finally, I was hired.

西游菜鸟 2022-03-22

What happened later? I also received a decision in process directly after being with the editor. I feel like my submission is going to be rejected.

CUGB 2022-03-19

It took 7 months and 3 days, and finally, today, I was officially hired.
The first review took 3 months, with major revisions.
The second review took 2 months, with minor revisions.
The third review took 20 days, and after the revised manuscript was returned, it was accepted on the 17th day.
The speed was really slow, it was torturous. The review process was unstable, and it had a lot to do with the editor.

xiaoyan fux 2022-03-16

May I ask how long it takes to review the submission?

zmx-ly 2022-03-07

Did you return it to the reviewer after making the revisions?

zmx-ly 2022-03-07

How long did it take for your second review?

hedilict 2022-03-01

From August 25th, 2021, to February 28th, 2022, after going through three revisions (major revision in the first review, minor revisions in the second and third reviews), it was finally accepted.

华东大铭哥 2022-01-05

Directly received after major repairs, thank you Teacher Yan Wei for editing!

xinmeng 2021-12-22

The editor is very serious and responsible, and the review speed is also fast. The review comments are sincere and positive.
During the first review, there was a major revision and a minor revision.
During the second review, one reviewer requested a change in the coordinates of the graph (from double logarithmic to single logarithmic). We explained in detail why we did not make the modification, and in the second round, this reviewer agreed and accepted it directly.
Two rounds took more than two months.
Looking forward to entering the first district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences as soon as possible.

XXDBB 2021-12-22

Second revision, in the hands of the editor.