Verified Reviews - Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

李上网来呀 2023-08-09

I submitted it on July 31st, and around August 4th, it changed from initial assessment to With Editor. The editors should all be there. I suggest waiting a bit longer.

oathkeeperleo 2023-08-09

Submitted on July 29th
Converted to initial assessment on July 29th
Still in initial assessment status as of August 9th...
Has the editor been on vacation recently? I want to know if everyone's status updates have been slow lately.
Should we send a reminder letter to urge them to submit the manuscript?

oathkeeperleo 2023-08-05

How are you doing now?

黄老三 2023-07-20

Posted on July 5th, still with editor as of July 20th.

Debra_Ann 2023-07-13

Received on 7.12!!! Wishing JMCA to continue prospering~~~ Hope my next article will also go smoothly!!!

糖糖糖123456 2023-07-12

4.16 Submit
6.5 Major renovation
6.25 Submit
7.4 Minor repair
7.5 Submit
7.11 Receive

Debra_Ann 2023-07-07

The second day after the distribution, the edited content is submitted for review.

Debra_Ann 2023-07-07

Distribute and edit for review the next day.

Debra_Ann 2023-07-07

5.4 Submission
5.5 Editor's office
5.10 Editor assignment
5.26 First major revision
6.7 Manuscript returned
6.20 Second major revision
7.1 Manuscript returned

多兰 2023-07-06

6.23 major revision (suggested one comment)
6.24 submitted
7.6 accepted

剑兰 2023-07-03

4.4 submitted
6.10 major revision 2 revision 1 reject
6.16 submitted
6.21 in peer review
7.4 accept

Translation:
4.4 was submitted.
On 6.10, there was a major revision, followed by two revisions and one rejection.
6.16 was submitted.
On 6.21, it was in the peer review process.
On 7.4, it was accepted.

多兰 2023-06-24

6.23 major revision (suggested a comment)
6.24 submitted

多兰 2023-06-19

Although I really wish, it is not possible to go back.

琦y 2023-06-14

May I ask how long will it take for witheditor to be available? Is there any update now?

QPH 2023-06-14

Excuse me, which editor should I submit a computational article to?

多兰 2023-06-12

The next day, we had an external audit.

琦y 2023-06-12

May I ask how many days it takes for your manuscript to move from "with editor" to "in peer review"?

多兰 2023-06-10

4.29 submission
4.30 initial
5.6 with editor
5.25 major revision
6.6 resubmission for revision

晓风*残月 2023-06-08

Two reviewers, one positive and one negative, although the degree of negativity is not high. The editor sought a third reviewer for a final decision, and after major revisions, it was successfully accepted.

Super炫King 2023-06-08

It means "indicates low innovativeness" in English.

nhleocn 2023-06-01

Pure computational chemistry. The two reviewers feel that their understanding of computational chemistry is not extensive, and their comments on the article are mostly focused on comparing it with previously obtained results in similar systems.

Submitted on December 6, 2022.
First major revision on February 13, 2023.
Revision submitted on March 14, 2023.
Second major revision on April 8, 2023.
Revision submitted on May 10, 2023.
Accepted with minor revision on May 29, 2023.

龙在天 2023-05-30

May I ask, how is your article now?

多兰 2023-05-18

What is the result?

星月夜 2023-05-17

We typeset it ourselves using a template.

陈sir 2023-05-16

3.9 Submit
3.11 Review and Submit
4.3 Edit and return major revisions based on the review comments
4.27 Revise the manuscript based on major revisions
5.3 Submit again
5.15 Accept

SCI* 2023-05-11

It has been a week since the submission, but I am still wondering what the preliminary evaluation is all about...

emmmua 2023-05-10

Senior, may I ask if you typeset the submission yourselves?

emmmua 2023-05-10

Senior, may I ask if you typeset your submissions yourself?

emmmua 2023-05-09

May I ask how you modified the journal format when submitting your manuscript?

emmmua 2023-05-09

May I ask, how do you modify the journal format when submitting articles?

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript

Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.

Search