Verified Reviews - Journal of Central South University
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

逐光者 2023-05-02

Submission on January 3rd
Currently under review.

cumter 2023-04-09

2023.01.23: submitted
2023.01.27: under review
2023.03.31: awaiting editor's recommendation
2023.04.01: major revision (2 reviewers, 21 comments, relatively easy to respond to)
2023.04.04: Submitted revised version
2023.04.04: under review

cumter 2023-04-02

2023.01.23: submitted
2023.01.27: under review
2023.03.31: awaiting ed recommendation
2023.04.01: Major Revision (2 reviewers, 21 comments, relatively easy to address)

cumter 2023-04-02

2023.01.23: submitted
2023.01.27: under review
2023.03.31: awaiting editor's recommendation
2023.04.01: Major Revision (2 reviewers, 21 suggested changes, relatively easy to address)

cumter 2023-03-31

2023.01.23: Submitted
2023.01.27: Under Review
2023.03.31: Awaiting ED Recommendation

twobttle 2023-03-28

May I ask what the situation is then?

jiaotong23seu 2023-01-28

Suitable for filling up with nonsense when there is an urgent need for an article.

trans11 2023-01-06

How long does it take to submit for review? Has the first review comment been released yet?

Luckier 2022-11-30

Yesterday it showed "Under Review," the long wait has begun.

Luckier 2022-11-25

After submission, it will be in the status of "Awaiting Admin Processing" for another month. Then it will change to "Awaiting DEIC Review". Does this mean it's going to be rejected?

Luckier 2022-11-22

It has been 1 month since submission, still Awaiting Admin Processing.

独行侠 2022-11-16

It's about the same. I don't have much impression, but it took about two and a half months from submission to receiving the first feedback. I don't remember the exact time of when it was sent for review.

cainiao1hao 2022-11-14

May I ask how long it will take for the editorial department to handle this journal? It has been two weeks since I submitted my contribution, but there has been no change.

cainiao1hao 2022-11-14

Is it normal that my submission has not been processed after two weeks?

独行侠 2022-11-14

1. Be prepared, even if the reviewers have no issues, there may be editors who are not knowledgeable and will keep asking you to make changes.
2. It is an Open Access (OA) journal, which requires page fees, but if your boss is willing to invest, they will also be willing to pay.
3. It is the first time encountering a journal where you have to do your own typesetting, completely by yourself, and then indicate at the end that it was edited by you.
4. It is not recommended to wait for this graduation because the process is very long. Just the peer review alone may take more than two months. I have seen some articles in this journal that took up to one and a half years from submission to acceptance.

滕海灏 2022-09-13

September 13th, submission record.

跟你说趁早你不听 2022-08-27

Amazing publication! The reviewer's comments involved making some changes to the sequence of illustrations, and during the proofreading, there was a hint about whether to include the team leader, Principal X, from a certain school. The English versions of domestic journals are almost always a mess. This comprehensive journal accepts submissions from various disciplines such as science, engineering, agriculture, medicine, humanities, law, and sports, as long as your writing resembles SCI publications. It's even better if you can include influential figures, you know what I mean. If accepted, there is also a requirement to pay a publication fee of 6k.

devil 2022-08-19

All of them have been rejected multiple times by overseas journals, so they had no choice but to submit their articles to this journal.

我爱如月 2022-04-02

Brother, what are you talking about? Speak the truth.

明天 2022-02-07

The Chinese Academy of Sciences wants to make you a first-tier researcher, as long as you pay. Haven't you seen that MDPI immediately removed the warning period journal as soon as they paid.

迪厅小王子 2021-08-11

This journal is really disappointing, and the editors are particularly arrogant. Everyone should really avoid submitting to it and consider submitting to other journals instead.

木头人123 2021-07-28

The previous comment!! Correct answer, and also need to pay a layout fee of 4000 yuan!

迪厅小王子 2021-07-26

Quite a pitfall journal, a pitfall among domestic journals. After revising the paper, the peer reviewers had no comments, but the editorial department kept requesting modifications, claiming that the structure was unclear and the hierarchy was not clear. They did not provide specific suggestions and left the typesetting completely up to me. Even the final draft only received vague feedback. Everyone should not submit to this journal, it's simply a waste of time. They even rejected the final draft because the editorial department was not satisfied.

songfangnian 2021-04-05

Two months and it was rejected, very fast.

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now