年轮 2023-05-15

Excuse me, have you received the first-instance opinion? It has been more than a year for me, and I still haven't received the first-instance opinion.

年轮 2023-05-15

The corresponding author's email is available, you can just check it, and recently it has been accessible for login.

发方法发 2023-05-13

The initial review requirements are very strict, but the response speed is very fast. However, recently, I cannot log into the system. It shows an account password error. It has been a month already, and I don't even know how to withdraw my submission.

超级神机军师 2023-02-19

Everyone is for me, and I am for everyone. I'm here to share my submission experience. After graduation, I no longer want to engage in scientific research.

2020-09-02 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2020-09-26 One Reviewer agreed (to reviewer)
2020-11-09 Add Reviewers
2020-11-25 Review Result Good / Major Change
2021-04-26 Review Result Average / Major Change
2021-07-08 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2021-07-08 Review Result Good / Minor Change
2021-08-08 Review Result Good / Accept
2021-10-22 Final Review Accepted

小白虎 2023-01-04

I submitted my manuscript on December 6th last year, and until today, they are still adding reviewers. I have been urging them to review my manuscript, and the editor even suggested withdrawing it. I said, "I have been waiting for a year, why withdraw it now? If you cannot find a reviewer, I can recommend one." The editor said they have already found a second reviewer who is currently reviewing it, but today they are still adding reviewers. What on earth is going on here?

leon815 2022-11-23

There has been no news since submitting in March, and the status has always been "adding reviewers". It's really disappointing.

turboshi 2022-11-18

Hello, may I ask if you have received any updates? Mine also shows that there are updates in the system, but I haven't received any emails.

turboshi 2022-11-18

Hello, may I ask if you have received any updates? Mine also shows that there are messages in the system, but I haven't received any emails.

xiaoxin 2022-11-13

Try adding a "C" at the end of the account, if it doesn't work, send an email to the editor, they should regenerate the account.

洗漱霸王 2022-11-12

The day after submission, when I tried to log in with the account provided by the journal, the system displayed "No Results Found." I emailed the editor and publisher to inquire about the reason, but received no response. When I attempted to re-upload the manuscript, the system indicated that I had already submitted the article. Has anyone else encountered this situation?

turboshi 2022-11-12

Please provide more context or clarify your request. The text "求交流qun" does not have a clear meaning in English.

halt 2022-11-07

Everyone can communicate with each other.

halt 2022-11-07

I feel that we can create a group to share our submission experiences.

halt 2022-11-07

13 months?????? I was initially fast, and on September 7th, it showed "sent to reviewer" (7). Now it has been two months, and still no news.

岩土狗 2022-11-05

Waited for 13 months without receiving any first-instance opinions. It is recommended to cut losses in a timely manner.

大雁塔老实人 2022-11-02

Mine too, there has been no news for two months. Have you sent an email to inquire?

halt 2022-10-25

I haven't received any news for two months.

ruiwang1995 2022-09-22

Can someone knowledgeable guide me? Is the corresponding author automatically listed first in this journal?

enhhhh 2022-07-12

Hello, is there any follow-up news?

岩土狗 2022-06-16

Already submitted for 9 months, received two review comments, reminded for review three times in between, currently still adding reviewers, it is really slow.

xiaoxin 2022-06-12

My situation is the same as yours. It has been two months, but there has been no reaction. May I ask how long this has been going on for you?

xiaoxin 2022-06-12

2022-02-24 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2022-02-25 Preliminary Check Revise required
2022-02-27 Manuscript Resubmission Complete
2022-03-02 Preliminary Check OK
2022-03-02 Manuscript ID Renamed Confirm Mail - Sent
2022-04-12 Add Reviewers
2022-04-13 Add Reviewers
2022-04-13 Add Reviewers
2022-04-14 Add Reviewers
2022-04-14 Add Reviewers
2022-04-14 Add Reviewers
2022-04-14

How long will this status last? It's been two more months and the review hasn't started yet?

岩土狗 2022-03-21

Sent a reminder email but no response.

falling 2022-03-21

"Ask directly by sending an email."

岩土狗 2022-03-13

2021-09-22 Manuscript Submission Confirm Mail - Sent
2021-09-23 Manuscript Submission Confirmed by author
2021-10-11 Preliminary Check OK
2021-10-11 Manuscript ID Renamed Confirm Mail - Sent
2021-10-11 One Reviewer agreed (to reviewer)
2021-10-12 Two Reviewer agreed (to reviewer)
2021-10-28 Review Result Good / Major Change
2021-11-01 Review Result Good / Minor Change
2021-12-23
2021-12-24
2022-01-12
2022-02-05
2022-03-02

The system shows that the manuscript has been reviewed, but the editor has not sent any emails for several months now. It has been a blank status, and I don't know what's going on.

达朗贝尔 2022-01-18

Ah, I won't say much more. Those who have submitted know it well. It's truly a long wait. The review process isn't very strict. This journal has both fast and slow publications. My roommate got accepted in just two months, while I have been working on mine for ten months. It's frustrating when you encounter idiotic reviewers who delay the process and leave you speechless.

lxfbym@163.com 2021-11-29

Trash magazine, it has been reviewed for over half a year and there is still no news. This journal has really low efficiency.

热心市民乐乐 2021-06-07

Ask the original poster, where can I see the comments from the reviewer? I only know that modifications are required, but where can I see the expert's comments? I haven't received any email notifications, it's very strange.

松小哥 2021-06-01

The requirements for formatting and reference citation are very strict. The initial formatting review has been revised several times. If the initial review is rejected, it can be modified and resubmitted. The speed of the review is extremely frustrating. The first expert provided results after 2 months, but there has been no news from the second expert for 10 months. It is advisable for anxious graduating students not to submit their work.

lu217 2021-04-01

May I ask if the meaning of "review result good/major change" is to have your work extensively revised? Did you revise your article and then submit it for re-evaluation? I am currently experiencing the same "review result" status and I'm not sure what it means.