Fantasy528 2023-07-05

03-Jul-2023 Major revision

Translation: Major revision on July 3, 2023.

Fantasy528 2023-06-29

29-Jun-2023 Pending Recommendation

This means that as of June 29, 2023, a recommendation is currently being considered or awaited.

Fantasy528 2023-06-20

06-Jun-2023 Undergoing initial checking
06-Jun-2023 Under Review

Translation: Both phrases indicate that a process is currently taking place. The first phrase suggests that an initial inspection or examination is being conducted, while the second phrase implies that something is currently being evaluated or considered.

纳兰 2023-04-24

Submitted on March 20th, still under review. Can I email the editor to inquire about this situation? Any fellow waiting for news together, let's DM each other and wait together. Being a researcher is really tormenting.

君白被占用 2022-11-22

I have one article submitted on October 20th and feedback was given on November 28th. Another article was submitted on December 15th and feedback was received on February 4th.

君白被占用 2022-11-22

Posted on October 20, 2021, the major revision comments were given on November 28th. The revised version was submitted on February 2, 2022, and minor revision comments were given on March 15th. The revised version was submitted on April 4th, and it was accepted on April 19th.

During this period, there were two sets of review comments. The first set of comments was extremely positive, while the second set provided numerous suggestions for modifications and offered some suggestions for the methodology. After the major revision, the first set of comments was not reviewed again, and the second set of comments expressed satisfaction with the modifications and provided a few minor revision suggestions.

Overall, the editor seemed responsible, and the reviewers were professional. They were also familiar with the aspects of my work.

I saw comments mentioning that the pending part took a long time. A senior colleague of mine has been waiting for about six months without any updates.

苦草黑藻狐尾藻 2022-10-04

4.26 submitted to journal
4.28 under review
7.5 Pending Recommendation
7.8 Major Revision
9.15 a revision1 has been submitted
9.16 under review
9.16 Pending Recommendation
9.22 Pending Decision
9.22 Minor Revision
9.26 a revision2 has been submitted
9.26 Pending Recommendation
9.30 Accept

Translation:
4.26 submitted to journal
4.28 under review
7.5 Pending Recommendation
7.8 Major Revision
9.15 a revision1 has been submitted
9.16 under review
9.16 Pending Recommendation
9.22 Pending Decision
9.22 Minor Revision
9.26 a revision2 has been submitted
9.26 Pending Recommendation
9.30 Accept

哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 2022-10-04

Last year, I got one article published in September, and this year, I got another one published in September again. The review process was quick and efficient.

苦草黑藻狐尾藻 2022-09-20

My pending has also been going on for a long time. Has yours ended?

IMZ 2022-09-19

20 April 2022 Submitted
22 April 2022 Assigned to Editor
03 May 2022 Reviewer(s) Assigned
25 May 2022 Review(s) Completed, Editorial Evaluation Pending
30 May 2022 Editorial Decision: Revise Major
30 Jul 2022 1st Revision Received
29 Aug 2022 Editorial Decision: Revise Minor
05 Sep 2022 2nd Revision Received
18 Sep 2022 Accept

Translation:
20 April 2022 Submitted
22 April 2022 Assigned to Editor
03 May 2022 Reviewer(s) Assigned
25 May 2022 Review(s) Completed, Editorial Evaluation Pending
30 May 2022 Editorial Decision: Revise Major
30 Jul 2022 1st Revision Received
29 Aug 2022 Editorial Decision: Revise Minor
05 Sep 2022 2nd Revision Received
18 Sep 2022 Accept

IMZ 2022-09-13

Hello, may I ask how many days the pending recommend status lasted until the final return for repair? I gave it for minor repairs and it has been in this status for 8 days since it was returned.

ecoecoeco 2022-09-05

This journal is generally rigorous, with a first review taking about 2-3 months. I submitted two articles, and both took a long time for the decision made by the associate editor, resulting in a total of six months from submission to publication. The journal pays attention to the methods and writing of the articles, and even minor issues like referencing are reflected in the review comments. The reviewers and editors are relatively gentle, and their opinions are constructive. Overall, the experience of submitting articles to this journal is good.

Cavatina 2022-07-29

Submitted: 19-Feb-2022
Major Revision: 14-Mar-2022
Revision Submitted: 06-Jun-2022
Minor Revision: 20-Jun-2022
Revision Submitted: 07-Jul-2022
Accept: 12-Jul-2022

Overall, it was a good submission experience, with professional but not overly demanding review comments. To be honest, the publication fee is a bit expensive, but luckily it has been upgraded to the second tier this year.

sch125 2022-06-18

May 17 submission: Under review
June 17 reminder: They said one reviewer has returned, waiting for another
What are the chances in this situation??

Let's chat privately, add me as a friend and wait together.

埃尔法贝塔 2022-06-09

The first review takes about two months or so, but there is a Pending Recommendation in the later stage that is exceptionally slow. I don't know if it is due to the editor's issue. The efficiency of external review is much higher than that of editing.

z2325235 2022-06-09

Same question, there has been no progress on the investment I made at the beginning of last month. How is the progress of the main poster?

sch125 2022-06-09

Do you have any friends who have recently received it? If you have any questions, how long does it usually take for you guys to review it?

lixe 2022-05-13

The second submission was accepted, and the overall speed was acceptable. It was submitted in early December, underwent major revisions on January 9th, and returned in early March. It received basic acceptance in early April, and then went through minor revisions before being formally accepted on May 10th. In total, it took almost half a year, mainly because the revisions took two to three months. There are editors in China who are friendly and helpful. The reviewers' comments were constructive, and the quality of the article improved significantly after the modifications. This journal does not place too much emphasis on impact factor and will try to find the strengths of the articles for acceptance. The authors are friendly. Hopefully, the influence of this journal will continue to grow.

sch125 2022-04-26

Please agree to the friend request.

艳火 2022-04-25

Hello. I would like to ask a question about submitting an article. I have already submitted it, but it has been rejected by the editor every time. How can I resolve the following issue?

Prior to submitting, please ensure you have:
- Followed the Author Guidelines accessed via the Instructions & Forms tab above
- Consulted Wiley's Guidelines on Publishing Ethics.

艳火 2022-04-25

Hello. I would like to ask a question about submitting a manuscript. I have already submitted it, but it keeps getting rejected every time. How can I solve the following problem?

Prior to submitting, please ensure you have:

Followed the Author Guidelines accessed via the Instructions & Forms tab above
Consulted Wiley's Guidelines on Publishing Ethics

sch125 2022-04-25

What's the situation? My manuscript is still in the initial review. It has been five days.

sch125 2022-04-22

How long will this status of undergoing initial checking last?

哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 2021-09-22

Formally launched in July and received in mid-September.

lixe 2021-08-31

The speed is acceptable! After one major revision, it mostly consists of minor language errors. The reviewers no longer look at it, leaving it for the editor to handle. When making the revisions, it truly feels easier to write than to edit...

yangyang191 2021-06-22

After submission, the next day it became "under review." After more than 20 days, it changed to "waiting for editor recommendation," and then it changed back to "under review." I don't know what it means, please explain it to me!

Mexu 2021-05-20

Posted on November 20, 2020, rejected and resubmitted on January 6, 2021. The reviewers and associate editor provided many constructive comments. Revised as per the requirements and submitted on March 4, 2021. It was sent back to the original reviewer. Returned for major revisions on April 6, 2021, with two additional analysis contents added. Returned on March 27, 2021. Minor revisions made on May 4, 2021, and submitted on May 12, 2021. Accepted on May 14, 2021.

这是我的马 2021-02-22

Translated text: Transferred from DD, submitted in June. 43 days later, the review feedback was rejection with the suggestion to resubmit. The editor and two reviewers mentioned that the idea was good, but the article was not well-written and had several issues, providing detailed feedback.
After major revisions, it was resubmitted and accepted 24 days later.
Overall, it was relatively quick, and both the editor and reviewers were responsible. During the process, the editor gave me two opportunities to extend the submission deadline.

Jamesliuhd 2021-02-16

The first review was a bit slow. I submitted it on October 5th, and received the revised comments on December 16th. Due to personal reasons, it took me two months to complete the revisions. However, it was accepted directly 7 days later. Overall, the speed was acceptable, but the impact factor was somewhat low.