Verified Reviews - AIP Advances
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

小朋ovo 2023-07-19

1500美元 translates to "1500 US dollars" in English.

小朋ovo 2023-06-13

The review process was very fast, with only one reviewer, and the questions raised were not difficult. It only took 1 and a half months for the publication, but at that time, I wasn't asked to pay the publication fee yet, I don't know why. Still, I hope for continuous improvement and more people to submit their contributions.

发卡涡 2023-05-28

Transfer from another journal to this one.
Associate Editor Review 13-May-2023 22:50:09
Associate Editor Decision Completed 26-May-2023 21:24:13
Decision Letter Being Prepared 26-May-2023 21:24:13
Does this mean my paper will be rejected without external review?
Have you gone through the external review process after transferring?

rourou554 2023-04-27

I would like to inquire, can the ORCID of the corresponding author be manually entered?

Dr Li 2023-04-26

As an open-source project, the progress is relatively slow in my opinion. It is recommended to have reviewers, but if not, why bother recommending? Currently, a reviewer has not been found yet...

qb 2023-04-15

It seems there is no fixed format, just make the layout look good. I have submitted it for 13 days, and the review process started on the 10th day. I hope to be selected.

Dr Li 2023-04-15

It has been nearly a month since submission, and we are still looking for reviewers. The recommended reviewers were not used, so why were they suggested in the first place? The journal's time is being wasted on finding reviewers.

小朋ovo 2023-04-14

Do you know? I also want to submit, but I'm afraid my paper is too bad and will be rejected.

XXDBB 2023-04-11

Do I need to use a fixed submission template for submitting the manuscript to AIP? Or is formatting not required?

qb 2023-04-06

I quit, still assigned as an Associate Editor. Have you also quit before?

qb 2023-04-06

How many reviewers are there, please?

qb 2023-04-06

Excuse me, how many reviewers are there?

qb 2023-04-05

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers there are? How long does the review process take? Thank you.

qb 2023-04-05

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers are there? Approximately how long does the review process take? Thank you.

qb 2023-04-05

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers are there? Approximately how long does the review process take? Thank you.

qb 2023-04-05

Did you get hired later? How long did it take? How many reviewers? Thank you.

薛定谔的喵嗷呜 2023-03-01

The translation of the text into English is as follows: "The speed is quite fast, two weeks for review, one month for the first review response, accepted directly after 10 days of revision, and published two weeks later. It is a journal in the fourth zone of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, with a not high impact factor, and it is not difficult to publish. It is a relatively friendly journal."

太空挖矿 2023-02-22

The same script o(╥﹏╥)o

略胜一筹 2023-01-20

The POF submission had two referees: one rejected it, while the other suggested minor revisions. As a result, the editor recommended it to be directly accepted with minor revisions. However, it is in the 4th tier of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, so it is not useful. Therefore, let's just reject it...

鲨鱼辣椒油 2023-01-16

I hope for a good outcome.

xiaofive 2022-12-13

Second submission. The first submission spent three months searching for reviewers with no results and was eventually withdrawn. In the second submission, I wanted to try my luck again, and this time I found a reviewer within two weeks. The review took one week, and the results were obtained in the third week. After minor revisions, the editor decided to accept it directly, taking a total of 31 days.

22号 2022-09-09

After my little repair, I returned to this state again.

Lxihan 2022-08-26

Have you found the reviewer for the follow-up? Mine is the same.

Lxihan 2022-07-21

Looking for reviewers, the review hasn't started yet.

Steve 2022-07-20

Excuse me, is the status "Securing Reviewer(s)" indicating that the reviewer(s) are already in the process of reviewing?

Lxihan 2022-07-19

How long will the process of Securing Reviewer(s) take?

One_tiger 2022-07-15

After 95 days of waiting, the result finally arrived, and I was directly hired.

Glenn 2022-06-21

05.26 Submit
05.31 Under review
06.10 Minor revision
06.18 Revision submitted
06.20 Accept; In production

Relatively good, with only one reviewer. Associate Editor Michael Keidar has a fast processing speed.
It is strongly recommended that when submitting to AIP Advances, reference articles already published in this journal in the same field.

The self-citation rate is currently too low, and the editors do not require it. It is often seen that articles in AIP Advances have more than 30 references, but none from our own journal.

The impact factor (IF) can be increased by everyone's contribution!

Fly Free 2022-05-31

This review process is too slow. I submitted it on January 15th, and received major revisions on May 21st. There were three reviewers and 26 review comments. After revising, it was rejected. This is too slow and frustrating. I don't want to submit to this journal anymore. Other members of the research group have had their papers published in other journals, while mine got rejected. It's frustrating. I want to submit it to another journal, but I don't know when it will be accepted. It's depressing!

Science and 2022-05-28

Submitted on January 10th, received review comments on April 26th. There were three reviewers who provided a total of 29 comments. One reviewer recommended major revisions, another rejected the submission, and the third requested revisions and a re-review. Eventually, major revisions were made and the revised manuscript was submitted after 20 days. On May 27th, it was concluded that the modifications were incomplete. The expert pointed out that the answers to the questions were inadequate, there was a lack of innovation, the English language was poor, and there were several errors. Hence, it was deemed unsuitable for publication in this journal and was ultimately rejected. It's a tragedy, and I won't submit to this journal again. What a waste of emotions! Sob sob sob.

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript

Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.

Search