W_55 2023-05-15

It has been over a month since the second review. Does anyone know what's going on?

老实人小肥猫 2023-05-03

0321 Submission
0327 Now selecting and inviting referees
0505 Referees reviewing paper

winmler 2022-11-18

Editor Now Selecting and Inviting Referees, it's been almost a month in this status.

xxaxx 2022-11-17

Exceeded the number of pages, switched to IJRS.

xxaxx 2022-11-14

11.14 submission

rr1226 2022-03-15

Same question, brothers, any changes? I have been in the "Referees' Reports Received" status for almost a month now.

rr1226 2022-03-15

Hello, has your status changed now? I have also been in the "Referees' Reports Received" status for a month. Is this normal?

biekaiqiang 2022-01-25

9.31投，11.08 major revision based on reviewer's comments
11.24 resubmission, 12.13 minor revision based on reviewer's comments
12.17 resubmission, 1.12 minor revision
1.17 resubmission, 1.23 acceptance.

ks111 2021-12-08

A good journal, just with a low impact factor and average review speed.

Peter_Jun 2021-10-11

My "Referees' Reports Received" has been more than 20 days.

henrycheng 2021-10-11

After I made some minor edits and adjusted the formatting, I submitted the revised version. It has been almost three weeks, and the status has remained as "Editor Now Selecting and Inviting Referees." Have you made any new progress?

Peter_Jun 2021-10-09

Brother, have you been hired? The editor asked me to revise the format twice, and each time it took more than 20 days for review.

geminipp 2021-10-01

After the minor revisions, I also received the comments from the editor, but there is no outcome yet. Every time I try to contact the journal, I don't receive any response. How is everything going with you, brother?

geminipp 2021-10-01

Posted on March 20, 2021
Rejected and resubmitted on April 25, 2021 (with reviewer's comments for revision)
Revised and resubmitted on May 8, 2021
Rejected and resubmitted on June 9, 2021 (with reviewer's comments for revision)
Revised and resubmitted on June 11, 2021
Reviewer had no comments on July 1, 2021, editor made minor revisions
Resubmitted on July 5, 2021
Editor made minor revisions again on July 15, 2021
Revised and resubmitted on July 17, 2021
Current status: Referees' Reports Received has remained unchanged for two weeks.

I feel that this journal is mediocre and the reviewers' questions are not professional. I have also not received any responses when contacting the editor, so I can only leave it up to chance.

henrycheng 2021-09-16

August 21, 2021 minor repair
August 24, 2021 minor repair for rework
August 25, 2021 new round of review
August 26, 2021 editor received the review comments
September 16, 2021 still no results, it has been 3 weeks already, have any classmates encountered this situation?

henrycheng 2021-07-03

The first part is about this journal, and the second part continues to submit to it. The progress of the second part is as follows:
20210609 - Awaiting Checks Processed
20210614 - Immediate Reject with Resubmit (The word count is too high, exceeding the allowed limit)
20210615 - Awaiting Admin Processing
20210617 - Editor Now Selecting and Inviting Referees
20210625 - Referees Reviewing Paper
20210702 - Referees' Reports Received

Aye 2021-04-01

Here is my submission process, for reference only:
Submitted on September 6, 2020;
Returned on September 11, 2020: Rejected and requested resubmission;
Resubmitted on October 22, 2020;
First round of review requested major revisions on November 29, 2020;
Revised and resubmitted on January 13, 2021;
Second round of review requested minor revisions on February 4, 2021 (addressed a reviewer's comment on writing details and included feedback from the journal administrator);
Revised and resubmitted on February 13, 2021;
Third round of review requested minor revisions on February 20, 2021 (mainly regarding the previous response to the journal administrator's questions);
Revised and resubmitted on February 21, 2021;
Fourth round of review on February 23, 2021, where the editor requested abbreviation of the content;
Revised and accepted on February 24, 2021, on the same day.

X小石头 2021-02-04

It took half a year, with 3 revisions, and it has been accepted.
The reviewers were changed for the first and second revisions. Both times required major revisions, and the reviewers were very serious and raised professional questions.

X小石头 2021-02-04

If you do not choose OA, no page fee will be charged.