啦啦2222 2023-07-27

Very good journal, getting one article published is enough for a doctoral graduate. Having one article can already establish a good reputation in the academic field. Wishing the journal continued success! It's better to focus on quality rather than quantity, even with only 103 articles published per year!

fantasydyz 2023-07-19

The translation of the text into English is as follows:

"Person who is tough and speaks less, directly puts content.
Editor Decision: Accept As Is - June 10, 2023.
AE Recommendation: Accept As Is - May 22, 2023.
Revision Review Completed - May 7, 2023.
Revised Paper Submitted - March 17, 2023.
Recommended as Technical Brief - March 12, 2023.
AE Recommendation: Revise to a Technical Brief - March 12, 2023.
Paper Review Completed - January 31, 2023.
Associate Editor Assigned - August 21, 2022.
Paper Submitted - August 18, 2022."

飞~机器人 2023-07-08

Email notification: Each author will receive an email titled "Document Signature Request" which contains a digital signature link for the ASME copyright transfer agreement required for publication. However, if the link is not received, what could be the reason?

Southeast-wind 2023-04-17

Opinions of the three reviewers. The first reviewer expressed that the writing was good and suggested minor revisions. They provided detailed comments within the PDF manuscript. The second reviewer had some questions, such as the explanation of certain terms, and their attitude was neutral, making it unclear whether they recommended rejection or revisions. The third reviewer found the innovative aspects and contributions of the article interesting, but pointed out some issues with details and raised questions regarding the figures and formula derivations.

Then, the editor decided to reject the article without providing any explanation, only stating that they were confused based on the opinions of the reviewers and associate editor. Waiting for six months only to receive this outcome is mentally exhausting...

Southeast-wind 2023-03-24

Oct 25, 2022 submit
Nov 8, 2022 Associate Editor Assigned
Dec 28, 2022 AE Recommendation
Jan 2, 2023 Editor Decision (reject & resubmit)
Dec 28, 2022 Paper Submitted
Jan 3, 2023 Associate Editor Assigned
Jan 3, 2023 Paper under review
Jan 25, 2023 Paper review completed
Feb 2, 2023 Paper under review
Mar 23, 2023 Paper review completed
Mar 23, 2023 Paper under review
Apr 12, 2023 Paper review completed
Apr 15, 2023 AE
Apr 17, 2023 Reject

Translation:
Oct 25, 2022 - Submission
Nov 8, 2022 - Associate Editor Assigned
Dec 28, 2022 - AE Recommendation
Jan 2, 2023 - Editor Decision (reject & resubmit)
Dec 28, 2022 - Paper Submitted
Jan 3, 2023 - Associate Editor Assigned
Jan 3, 2023 - Paper under review
Jan 25, 2023 - Paper review completed
Feb 2, 2023 - Paper under review
Mar 23, 2023 - Paper review completed
Mar 23, 2023 - Paper under review
Apr 12, 2023 - Paper review completed
Apr 15, 2023 - AE
Apr 17, 2023 - Reject

Hayes Dut 2023-03-13

Hello, may I ask if the status "Paper Under Review" means that the AE has already sent it for external review?

voice_up 2022-12-11

Hello, may I ask, I just submitted my manuscript, but I haven't received the email with the copyright link. Will I receive this email before the review process?

专心搞科研 2022-11-22

It's very easy, just click on the link to sign the copyright agreement. I suppose if you don't sign it, it won't be reviewed.

zstu_pw 2022-11-21

Help: Why can't I sign the copyright signing email after submitting the manuscript? Does it mean that it won't enter the review (editorial review) stage without signing?

Southeast-wind 2022-10-29

How long does it generally take to submit to the assigned editor? Thank you.

Southeast-wind 2022-10-25

Just submitted my paper. The status is "paper submit (complete)". The submission website feels a bit simple, only requiring to upload a PDF manuscript file. It was quite troublesome when submitting to other Elsevier journals before, so I'm not used to this simplicity. Hopefully, it will be accepted.

jht5665 2022-10-21

In the field of institutions, it is considered a very good journal, the journal of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, which is also highly recognized in the industry. I wish the journal continued to improve!

我接工地 2022-10-19

Which editor? My minor edits have been completed and there has been no news until now.

Benson 2022-10-17

Submit by the end of February in 22nd year;
Repair by the end of June, minor repairs should be completed within two weeks;
Submit in early July;
Receive by the end of September;
Personally, I feel that the timeline for this journal is quite long, but still relatively easy.

wuyun123 2022-03-29

Hello classmate, how long did it take for the editor-in-chief to make a decision after your article AE was recommended?

wuyun123 2022-03-29

Hello classmate, how long did it take for the editor-in-chief to make a decision after your article was recommended in AE? How much time has passed since then?

梦想的奇点 2022-02-08

Indeed, it is very slow. I submitted my work in September 2021, and it has been almost five months since February 2022, and I am still in the reviewing process. During this period, I sent two emails asking about the progress, but I have not received any replies. The submission process is too long, so one must be cautious when submitting!

hsin 2022-02-07

Posted in early April 2021, the initial review was completed in early May, but the editor delayed until late June to give a rejection and request for resubmission.

The second draft was submitted in mid-July 2021, and the initial review was completed in early August. However, the editor again delayed until early October to provide feedback, and the article was changed to a Technical Brief.

After minor revisions in mid-October 2021, the article was resubmitted and the review was completed in late November. The editor further delayed until late January 2022 to finally accept the article, which was then published online in early February.

All in all, the process took a long time, resembling a ten-month gestation period. Upon acceptance, it evoked many emotions.

Furthermore, as mentioned above, after each round of submission, it took an additional one to two months for the editor to provide feedback after the reviewers completed their review. Sending reminder emails in between had no effect, as they were ignored. It is unclear whether this is an isolated case. Authors with limited time should be aware of the submission cycle issue.

木岑 2021-04-02

Design innovation articles of new institutions
Submitted on October 22, 2020
Review completed on December 21, 2020
Deputy editor decided minor revisions on January 14, 2021, and gave 2 weeks' time
Editor-in-chief decided acceptance on February 22, 2021
Currently in the publication process
Overall, the efficiency is quite high. Best wishes for the journal's continuous improvement.