luckywd 2022-10-15

Compared to other journals, it is relatively easy, but the review process is a bit long.

luckywd 2022-10-15

Posted on January 29, 2022
Received first review comments on April 13, 2022, with only one reviewer providing major revisions, but the comments were very constructive.
Submitted revised manuscript on May 9, 2022.
Received second review comments on July 9, 2022, with minor revisions.
Submitted revised manuscript on July 23, 2022.
Received acceptance email on October 13, 2022.

啥时候毕业啊烦死了 2022-05-27

Personal experience has shown that as long as one round of external review is required, it will take three months of waiting time. If there are two rounds of revisions and three rounds of external review, it will take a year from submission to acceptance. In terms of ABS1 journals, this speed is not considered fast.

淡淡的金叶 2022-04-12

The editor reviewed it first, provided revision suggestions, and then submitted it for external review. After 6 months of external review, it was returned and took 1 month to complete the revisions. The second review took 3 and a half months, and then it was accepted. The reviewer's comments were relatively mild but still professional.

qqcoom 2022-01-25

Submission in December 2020, feedback received after 3 months for the first review, major revisions were suggested by the editor. The editor allowed 2 months for the revisions. Due to being busy with graduation defense, an extension of one month was requested from the editor. Revised manuscript was returned on June 1st for further modifications. Feedback for the second review was received in mid-August. One reviewer accepted the manuscript while another suggested minor revisions. The revised manuscript was returned after 1 and a half months. Acceptance was received in early October. The difficulty of submitting to this journal is not high, but it has a good reputation. The editor has chosen responsible reviewers who provide professional suggestions. As long as the revisions are made seriously, there is still a great chance of acceptance.

Paper-maker 2021-10-21

May I ask how long does it take for AE's recommendation?

博君一肖点点滴滴 2021-10-12

It's very strange, they rejected me without even reviewing it. So why did they keep me waiting for a month? Is it because they have too many articles?

啥时候能毕业啊烦死了 2021-09-04

I can't understand why it takes so long for reviewers to review a manuscript. If they can review it, they should review it. If they don't want to review it, they should reject it. What does it mean to drag on for months without giving any results?

我要发paper 2021-08-30

The speed of paper review is relatively slow, but the comments given by the reviewers are very fair. As long as you make careful revisions, your paper can be accepted.

LeeHHU 2021-08-24

May I ask if your status is still the same? I have been waiting for almost a month and it has been consistently showing as "Awaiting Referee Selection."

我要发paper 2021-04-02

The review speed of the external audit experts is really slow, and the efficiency is too low.

Cherry Bubble 2021-03-25

Posted in early July 2020, returned for major revisions in late October 2020, revised and resubmitted in early January 2021, returned for minor revisions in mid-March 2021, and accepted in late March 2021. The people at AE are very nice and primarily consider the opinions of the reviewers. Once the reviewers provide feedback, the editorial department usually reaches a decision within a week.

北极星 2021-03-13

What is your change in status?

我要发paper 2021-03-13

I have already invested for 6 months and hope to receive feedback as soon as possible.

北极星 2021-02-25

I would like to ask, what is the current status behind you? Have you received any results?

北极星 2021-02-21

I want to ask, how are your results?