Verified Reviews - ARCHIVES OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS IN ENGINEERING
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

tyz 2021-12-13

2021.03.05 -- Initial submission
2021.06.30 -- Received first-round comments from 5 reviewers, with approximately 40 suggestions
2021.07.30 -- Submitted revised manuscript for the first round of review
2021.08.05 -- Editor assigned
2021.11.20 -- Inquired about the progress of the manuscript
2021.11.23 -- Editorial department replied that an editor has been assigned and is currently handling it
2021.12.12 -- Reject
Hehe

tyz 2021-12-13

Be cautious, be cautious. The review process is too long, waited for so long and in the end it was still a tragedy... sob sob sob.

zzz0812 2021-11-24

Are there any brothers who have recently submitted their work? Are there any brothers who have been taken advantage of? Let's share our experiences.

szn 2021-10-22

Be cautious before submitting... It took until now, from the end of last year, to receive the news, and it was directly rejected... It seems that there are more direct commissioned articles, and submitting articles is not very OK...

ginnie 2021-06-20

Last summer vacation, I submitted my work and went through nearly ten months of long waiting. In the end, it was rejected without any review comments. Be cautious when submitting!

HellHUHU 2021-05-13

Submitted for ten months, still a tragedy after revision!

明天早上吃什么 2021-03-24

Do you have any friends who understand the Travelling Salesman Problem? Could you please explain to me what is innovative about "Combinatorial Optimization: Comparison of Heuristic Algorithms in Travelling Salesman Problem" and why it was published in ARCHIVES OF COMPUTATIONAL METHODS IN ENGINEERING? I apologize for my lack of understanding, but all I saw in the paper was a simple comparison (which I don't think can even be considered a detailed analysis), and it seemed to be aimed at promoting the author's previously published Tree Physiology Optimization algorithm. Is this journal not reputable? I have never submitted to this journal before, so I am not very familiar with it.

奕小子阳 2021-03-15

The one sent at the end of August 2020, received an email in mid-March 2021 directly confirming the employment.

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started