自由的风 2022-04-14

Because it was my first submission to WR, and it also involved graduation, I checked the status almost every day and kept detailed records.

02 Feb 2022: Submitted to Journal
03 Feb 2022: Editor Invited
12 Feb 2022: Editor Assigned
13 Feb 2022: Under Review (the status of "under review" was updated several times, not sure why, but in the end, there were only two reviewers)
22 Mar 2022: Moderate revision
31 Mar 2022: With Editor
Returned due to formatting issues, removed images from the main text
01 Apr 2022: With Editor
02 Apr 2022: Editor Assigned
03 Apr 2022: Under Review
11 Apr 2022: With Editor
13 Apr 2022: Accept

Overall, the progress made by the editor was quite fast. The editor's name was Yan Zhou. It took a little over two months in total, which should be considered fast. Due to the niche topic, it took some time to assign an editor and find additional reviewers.

熊猫头 2022-04-13

Here you go~ After six months, the manuscript has finally been accepted and the long wait is over. I hope everyone will have a favorable outcome.
Submitted on 18th October 2021.
Major revision on 1st February 2022.
Revision submitted on 1st March 2022.
Minor revision on 6th April 2022.
Accepted on 7th April 2022.

苦草黑藻狐尾藻 2022-04-13

Has your submission been reviewed?

ZNZN 2022-03-19

I have come to fulfill my vow. Submitted on 25/9/21, accepted on 18/3/22, it's been nearly 6 months. The main delay was due to the overseas Christmas season, so I was getting a bit anxious. Fortunately, it was finally accepted. I hope everyone can receive it smoothly!

Prof.Oak's Muk 2022-03-02

How long did your editor assign for review? Mine has been almost a week.

毕业冲鸭 2022-02-28

2021/11/13 submitted
2021/11/16 editor invited
2021/11/24 editor assigned
2021/12/04 under review
2022/1/22 major revision, two reviewers in total
2022/2/22 response submitted, directly with editor
2022/2/23 returned due to formatting issues, then returned the same day
2022/2/23 editor invited
2022/2/25 editor assigned
2022/2/28 accepted

家有元小胖 2022-02-03

Four days after being invited, it became Editor Assigned.

云中小麻雀 2022-01-30

Is it just me or has the speed been quite slow recently? It has been over twenty days and it is still "Editor Assigned".

Peragh 2022-01-26

Did anyone receive a notification email after submitting their contributions? It has been almost a day since I submitted mine and I haven't received any email notification. I used to receive emails quickly after submitting contributions before. Does anyone know what's going on?

awdxzdawrawdsa1 2022-01-25

Hello, may I ask how long has your editor invited status lasted? It has been two weeks for me already...

毕业冲鸭 2022-01-25

It refers to the situation where an invitation is sent to an editor but the editor has not yet accepted it. Recently, I have been in this state for more than 10 days before it changed to "editor assigned" and then submitted for review.

光辉 2022-01-21

Hello, this editor invitation generally lasts for many days, I have been waiting for about ten days, and still have this problem.

MR萧 2022-01-17

It has been over a week since I submitted, and I am anxious about the Editor Invitation.

云中小麻雀 2022-01-16

It is normal to resubmit for review, and it is even more normal for WR.

ZNZN 2022-01-14

After the repair, it was sent for review again... It feels like it has become worse.

毕业冲鸭 2022-01-12

11.13 Submission
12.4 Under review
Still under review now

ECO_Zhou 2021-12-28

Initial Date Submitted: 19 Oct 2021
Under review: 13 Dec 2021
Waiting...

云中小麻雀 2021-12-22

Congratulations, the first article has not yet yielded results, so another one has been submitted.

ZNZN 2021-12-20

After a three-month review, finally, a major renovation was given.

Hydrogeologist 2021-12-13

First of all, thank you very much for the previous sharing of experiences from my fellow colleagues. I also submitted my WR with nervousness. Whenever I feel uneasy, I come to this forum to review past experiences to calm myself down. Therefore, I would like to express my gratitude after the publication of this article and hope that the shared experiences can help future colleagues. I look forward to everyone achieving good results.

08.04 Submission - editor inviting - editor assigned
08.10 Under review
09.07 Major revision (Two reviewers: one major, one minor; there were no major issues with the content, the major reviewer mainly wanted me to clarify the research problem and novelty of my study, specifically what problem my research is addressing and what conclusions are new compared to previous studies. This indicates that a WR article must clearly define the problem and have novel conclusions!!)
10.07 Resubmission after major revision
11.15 Accepted (The major reviewer proposed that after further review, the manuscript can be accepted. So, I asked another reviewer who agreed that the manuscript had addressed all the previous suggestions, and recommended acceptance.)
12.08 Published Online

云中小麻雀 2021-12-13

Urgently need the article to graduate.

jihuo892324 2021-12-13

Does "editor invited" mean that an editor responsible for pre-reviewing this article has not been found yet?

云中小麻雀 2021-12-13

It has been over two months...

毕业冲鸭 2021-12-08

May I know how to know if the minimum number of comments has been received?

白马狗熊 2021-11-26

8.12 Submission
9.14 Request to upload SI (Forgot to upload for the first time)
10.1 Major revision (One minor revision, two major revisions, one rejection) after one month of revision
10.30 Revisions requested
11.03 Received email about minimum review comments, then under review again
11.18 Minor revision
11.21 Returned
11.25 Accepted
Oh, this paper is so important to me. It proves that I can still do it. I'm deeply moved by its acceptance. Sharing it with everyone. Good luck to everyone with their submissions.

毕业冲鸭 2021-11-25

It has been 12 days since submission, and it is still in the "editor invited" status. This is too slow! People in the same group submitted one month earlier and got reviewed on the second day. Is there such a huge difference between editors?!!!!

账户名 2021-11-24

After 20 days of submission, ur begins.

账户名 2021-11-18

2021.10.30, Submitted
2021.11.03, Editor Assigned (deadline is the 18th, no updates yet)

The efficiency is too low! It took more than five months for the first submission and the first review.

云中小麻雀 2021-11-15

The submission has been under review for a month and a half, hoping for an opportunity to make revisions.

zf519 2021-11-09

Submitted a paper at the end of June, received a rejection email in early August with two major revisions required. The reviewer was very professional and provided constructive feedback. After making the suggested changes, the paper was resubmitted to EP and received high praise from the reviewer. Currently, there is another paper on hand, planning to submit it to WR by the end of December, hoping for a smooth process this time.