Verified Reviews - URBAN FORESTRY & URBAN GREENING
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

丹丹思密达 2023-07-20

After 8 months of review and revision, it is finally accepted. The overall speed is relatively slow, but the two reviewers provided great suggestions that greatly improved the article! The editing speed is also slow, hoping UFUG will get better and better! Aim for the top 1 area of the Chinese Academy of Sciences next year!

小小轩 2023-03-10

Will also be rejected directly after reviewing with the editor.

LITUANTUAN 2022-04-16

Is this journal reviewed directly or will it be rejected without review?

LITUANTUAN 2022-04-16

Hello, will this be rejected without being reviewed?

LITUANTUAN 2022-04-16

Hello, may I ask if this journal accepts direct submissions for review? Or will submissions be directly rejected without review?

nllyb 2022-04-10

The journal quality is good and it has a good reputation in the field of urban ecology and landscape architecture! It is one of the top journals~
However, the speed is extremely slow!!! If you are in a hurry to graduate, please refrain from submitting!
I am researching the impact of nature environment virtual reality on the perception of health in the population. In terms of speed, it takes about a year to receive the first review comments and six months to receive the second review comments. For doctoral students waiting to graduate, it is really difficult to bear. This is for reference.

sxh 2021-12-21

How did the latest subdivision, the forestry subcategory, drop down to Zone 1?

VincentGIS 2021-10-15

That's quite fast! I saw your article on RG, it's very interesting!

lukaluka 2021-09-06

2020.10.13 Submission
2020.11.27 Minor revision with 2 reviewers
2021.01.19 Accepted

After reading other comments, I realized that I may have been lucky with my submission experience as the processing of my article was relatively fast.

扬大彭于晏 2021-09-04

The speed is so slow that it makes me doubt life. It's already halfway through, but the first review hasn't come back yet! Students who are considering submitting to this journal, please be extremely cautious!!!

yuxinyang 2021-08-19

Posted on February 9, 2021; Received reviewer comments on April 1, major revisions; Revised on July 1, accepted on August 19.

zionye 2021-05-21

2020.09.05 First submission
2020.11.24 Rejected, can resubmit after revision
2020.01.21 Resubmission
2020.05.19 Accepted
The journal's review process is very slow, usually taking two to three months. It took a total of nine months from start to finish. If you're not in a hurry, you can submit it.

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started