lixiao 2023-07-24

Hello, may I ask if there is a "revise" first before an "accept with minor revision" in the second review? I did not see any minor revision.

lixiao 2023-07-24

May I ask, is there a revision first and then followed by a second review for major and minor revisions? I did not see "accept with minor revision".

DongY 2023-07-15

May I ask if all authors must register and click confirm in order for the editor to see it? It has been a week since submission, but it is still in the Manuscript Submitted status.

曹 2023-06-20

How many times has the date for "under review" changed before receiving the review comments? It has changed three times already. I wonder if it will be rejected.

贯众 2023-03-30

It is normal for time to change multiple times.

雄安本地 2023-03-18

Finally got hired after 10 months, the process was very slow. I do not recommend submitting applications in a hurry to those who are about to graduate.

阿诺 2023-03-17

Okay, thank you very much!

雄安本地 2023-03-17

It means that there are reviewers who have accepted the review or submitted review comments. Usually, after about 4 or 5 rounds of review comments, the review will be returned.

雄安本地 2023-03-17

I would like to ask how long it usually takes to be accepted after receiving a minor revision decision in the second review. Will it still show as "under review"? In my second review, I only had one reviewer, who recommended acceptance with minor revisions. However, after submitting the revised version, it went back to "under review" after a week. It's frustrating, and I'm not sure if there will be an additional reviewer in the third review.

阿诺 2023-03-15

The "under review" status has been updated multiple times, with the latest update being from 2.27 to 3.14, taking a total of 28 days. Can anyone who has had a similar experience please tell me what might be the reason for this???

阿诺 2023-03-08

Have you experienced situations where the under review period changed multiple times?

贯众 2023-03-08

Online publication in about six months.

yi 2023-03-06

The reviewers are very professional and rigorous, basically all of them are professional peers. They provided more than 40 comments in the first review, which greatly improved the quality of the manuscript. It took more than 3 months for the first review (revision). The second review took about 1 month (Accept after minor revise). It took about 40 days from receiving the final draft to the final version. The entire submission process takes approximately 8 months. Lastly, I would like to give a big praise to the journal manager of TRR, who is very conscientious and responsible. They carefully read through the entire manuscript and even help polish the language.

阿诺 2023-03-05

Hello, I would like to ask how long it took for your article to be published from submission?

贯众 2023-03-03

The reviewer is very professional, overall they are a peer in the same field, and they provide a lot of detailed comments. The review speed is relatively fast, which may be related to their research direction.

阿诺 2023-02-18

The review time for "under review" has changed three times. Comrades, what kind of situation is this? Is there a high probability that it will be rejected next?

mjc 2023-01-19

The advantages of TRR are good industry reputation and high recognition among foreigners, while the disadvantage is a relatively low impact factor. The acceptance rate is approximately 1/4.

阿诺 2023-01-05

Hello, how long did it take for your submission status to change from "submitted" to "under review"? I have also recently submitted and would like to know the cycle of changes in submission status.

chainsccc 2023-01-01

The first change in date for Under Review is from Dec07 to Dec27.

chainsccc 2022-12-08

It has been a month since the submission, and finally, it is under review. I cried, thank you. Next step, I can only guess it will be rejected.

chainsccc 2022-12-02

After I submitted my manuscript, it has been showing "Manuscript Submitted" all along. Does this mean it hasn't been seen by the editor? What should I do? It has been many days without any changes.

chainsccc 2022-12-02

Hello, does "Manuscript Submitted" mean that it has not been seen by the editor after I submitted it?

鼬 2022-11-26

Hello, I would like to ask, does this journal require each author to confirm by email before submission? Or can co-authors proceed with the review process without confirmation?

hui8727 2022-10-13

Today, the internet released a post to share my article. My paper was submitted and transferred to TRB in 2021 (July 31st). The first version manuscript, revised according to TRB's review comments, was formally submitted to TRR on December 22nd, 2021 (last week given). There were three rounds of revisions. Initially, there were two reviewers, but later it was increased to three. Each round of revision for both authors and reviewers took 40 days, which is equivalent to 240 days (7 months) in total. The final acceptance was on August 24th, 2022, and one week later it was submitted to the publishing editor at SAGE. Over a month later (October 1st), the galley proof was received, with one week for revisions. On October 2nd, the revised proof was sent back (via email), and today (October 13th, 2022) it was released on the internet.

In other words, it took over a year from submission to publication for this paper, and there will not be a proof of publication provided after acceptance, only an email notification.

If you urgently need results, I definitely do not recommend submitting to TRB. It is much better to submit to other journals after being accepted by TRB. However, TRR does not require page charges, and they have high standards for improving the paper. I believe these are the two best aspects of TRR.

Starry 2022-03-13

From the TRB annual meeting recommendation to TRR, both reviewers have a very high efficiency in reviewing. The deadline for submission is December 1st, the first round of revisions will be completed on January 20th, the second round of revisions on February 22nd, and the final manuscript will be received on March 11th.

icecream1111 2021-12-08

May I ask how long it took for the first review of your paper?

helieyun 2021-12-07

Just the peer review process is a bit slow, everything else is fine.

duke99 2021-12-06

May I ask if the first trial has ended now?

duke99 2021-12-06

May I ask about the current situation?

peter 2021-10-08

The first round of review was slow, but the second round was acceptable in terms of review time. After the first revision, the paper was accepted for publication, which made me quite happy. The impact factor is relatively low.