Verified Reviews - THIN-WALLED STRUCTURES
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

CC仗剑走天涯 2023-08-07

There is a mistake, 8.6 Decision in progress.

CC仗剑走天涯 2023-08-07

I hope to give an opportunity for modification!

xingjinbit 2023-07-24

Great journal! I wish you all the best and continued success!

badromance 2023-07-23

Thank you SUN editor for processing the manuscript very quickly, it's excellent.

badromance 2023-07-23

14/04/2023 Submitted to Journal
14/04/2023 Under review
23/04/2023 required review completed
10/05/2023 Major revision (The status changed three times during the required review completion period. There were five reviewers and over sixty review comments.)
09/06/2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
25/06/2023 Major revision (Two reviewers still had questions, totaling six issues. After the status changed to RRC, the editor returned the review comments on the same evening.)
14/07/2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
19/07/2023 Minor revision (Three issues in total)
23/07/2023 Revision Submitted to Journal Accepted on the same day.

可以了duo 2023-07-22

Overall, it went relatively smoothly except for the initial review being somewhat slow, but overall, I am very satisfied.

高产冠军 2023-07-21

It feels difficult, who succeeded? I have submitted twice and both times were rejected, while others were well received. What could be the reason?
Please contact me as soon as possible, Tednott. Thank you.

CC仗剑走天涯 2023-06-24

6.24 under review translates to "6.24 is currently under review" in English.

CC仗剑走天涯 2023-06-24

Hope to enter the editorial review.

CC仗剑走天涯 2023-06-18

Submitted on June 11, 2023, it is still in the hands of the Journal and has not yet reached the editor. Compared to other civil engineering journals, the speed feels much slower.

Nixi 2023-06-09

May I ask how many days it took for your article to be submitted?

Nixi 2023-06-08

May I ask how many days have you submitted for maintenance? The submission has not been accepted so far.

我爱北京 2023-05-25

Why haven't I received any updates on my status DIP since May 21st until now, even though all 7 reviewers have completed their reviews?

Yukiki 2023-05-18

Excuse me, after receiving your article, has it been proofread yet? I submitted mine on May 4th and I haven't received the proofreading email yet.

wsc 2023-05-13

It has been 15 days and it is still submitted to the journal, why is it taking so long?

nickname 2023-05-10

May I ask if the deadline for the second review of the thin-walled structures is 20 days or 30 days for the reviewers?

spear 2023-05-09

Seven reviewers? Scary.

我爱北京 2023-05-08

Hello, how many reviewers are you? I submitted on April 25th and I am also a SUN editor. They have invited 12 reviewers for me, and 7 of them have agreed to review.

星星的力量 2023-05-05

Personally, I think the speed is very fast. I appreciate the efficiency of Sun editor and reviewers for promptly providing review comments and producing results on the same day.

2023.3.22 Submitted to journal, With editor
2023.3.22 Under review
2023.4.2 Reviews completed
2023.4.2 Major revision
2023.4.20 Revised, With editor
2023.4.24 Under review
2023.5.2 Accepted

franthy 2023-04-20

2022.12.5 Submitted to Journal, With Editor
2022.12.6 Under Review
2023.1.4 Reviews completed: 1
2023.1.5 Reviews completed: 2
2023.1.25 Major Revision
2023.2.5 Revision Submitted to Journal
2023.2.7 Under Review
2023.2.9 Under Review
2023.3.13 Reject
After careful revision, it was rejected. Speechless.

SCI写作交流 2023-03-29

How long does it usually take for the editor to process a submission? It has been 8 days since the article was submitted to the journal.

SCI写作交流 2023-03-29

Same question, it has been 8 days since it was submitted to the journal, why hasn't the editorial department accepted the manuscript yet? Can someone knowledgeable please answer?

Wang_C 2023-03-26

Does not belong to the scope of the journal, the associate editor rejected it directly, the entire cycle took 8 days, without wasting time, and there is still time for revisions.

大表哥 2023-03-16

I think the speed is very fast, and the editing efficiency is also high. Basically, the results will be available on the same day that the review comments come back.
- [ ] 2022.12.21 submitted to journal
- [ ] 2022.12.27 Under Review
- [ ] 2023.01.28 Required Reviewers Completed
- [ ] 2023.01.30 major revision
- [ ] 2023.02.20 submitted revision
- [ ] 2023.02.21 with editor
- [ ] 2023.02.24 under review
- [ ] 2023.03.15 accepted

yingling 2023-03-11

It has been a week with the editor, does anyone have any understanding?

学术小阳 2023-03-10

Is there any news? Receiving a question is no big deal. Waiting for good news! By the way, who is the editor?

yingling 2023-03-09

I have been in the hands of the editor for almost a week.

请大佬高抬贵手 2023-03-09

01/03/2023 Submitted to Journal
It has been 8 days already, and there is still no progress. Does anyone know what's going on?

UURSELF 2023-03-08

Reply to the previous post, one round of review takes 15 days.

学术小阳 2023-03-08

20230307 2nd Revision submit: This means that a second revision was submitted on March 7, 2023.
20230308 Accept: This means that an acceptance was made on March 8, 2023.

Publish scientific posters with Peeref

Peeref publishes scientific posters from all research disciplines. Our Diamond Open Access policy means free access to content and no publication fees for authors.

Learn More

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now