AA137435 2021-12-20

Where did you see it?

桂浜之龙 2021-12-20

Oh, it's the third district again, isn't it?

桂浜之龙 2021-12-20

Downstairs mentioned the third district.

dawang 2021-12-20

I didn't expect to hit the target and then be sent back to the second zone again.

咩小力 2021-12-20

Just released is the upgraded version of the 2021 Chinese Academy of Sciences division, with a major category of Zone 3 and a minor category of Zone 2.

AA137435 2021-12-19

12.05 submission
12.07 with editor
12.10 under review
12.12 required review completed
It has been seven days already, sigh.

苦13基层民工 2021-12-10

The topic is about coatings.
Submitted to the journal on December 7, 2021.
Transfer pending as of December 9, 2021.
The assistant editor directly requested a transfer without providing any reasons, stating that these two journals, Corrosion Science and Progress in Organic Coatings, are more suitable.
What!?

咩小力 2021-12-10

October 20th, submitted;
November 14th, received the reviewer's comments for major revisions, given 20 days;
December 3rd, revised and resubmitted;
December 6th, continued the review process;
December 9th, accepted.

This journal is good in the field of coatings, but it cannot compare to pure material-based energy and environmental journals. Those purely focused on characterization and showcasing skills, so their impact factors are increasing rapidly.

MUYYZ 2021-12-09

2021-11-5 Submitted to Journal
2021-11-8 With Editor
2021-11-9 Under Review
2021-11-17 Required Reviews Completed
2021-11-21 Required Reviews Completed
2021-11-22 Major Revision
2021-12-3 With Editor
2021-12-6 Under Review
2021-12-7 Required Reviews Completed
2021-12-8 Required Reviews Completed
2021-12-8 Accept
The editor is very efficient and responsive. It took only a month from submission to acceptance. Keep up the good work!

烟雨霓裳 2021-11-19

From November 10th to November 19th, this status has been "Required Reviews Completed". Does anyone know what this situation is? Help!

烟雨霓裳 2021-11-19

2021.10.3 Submitted;
2021.10.22 Major revisions;
2021.11.03 Resubmitted for revision;
2021.11.10 Required reviews completed;
2021.11.19 Still Required reviews completed.
Does anyone know what is going on? I feel really upset.

GG233 2021-11-18

I submitted my work in September and it was reviewed in November.

hubugeorge 2021-10-26

2021.10.25 submitted
2021.10.26 with editor
It's a top journal in the first district.
I hope it can be reviewed.
Good luck!!

超越自己 2021-10-26

Posted on October 25th.
Arrived in the hands of the editor on October 26th.
First time submitting to this magazine, hoping for beginner's luck~

hubugeorge 2021-10-26

submitted 2021.10.25
How long does it usually take for this journal with the editor?
Ah, AMT (5 weeks) and CEJ (1 week) are not externally reviewed,
I transferred to SURFACE & COATINGS TECHNOLOGY.
The impact factor of this journal is not high, but it is also a top journal in the first quartile. Is it difficult to get it reviewed?
I hope it can be reviewed!

大头宝 2021-10-24

Submit 17 August 2021,
Major revise 9 September 2021,
Submit revised 27 September 2021,
Minor revise 19 October 2021.
Accepted 19 October 2021.

Translation:

Submitted on August 17, 2021,
Significant revision on September 9, 2021,
Submitted revised version on September 27, 2021,
Minor revision on October 19, 2021.
Accepted on October 19, 2021.

Strive 2021-10-22

Submit 7 September 2021,
Under review 8 September 2021,
Major revise 23 September 2021,
Revised 8 October 2021,
Accepted 14 October 2021,
Available online 20 October 2021.

Translation:
Submitted on September 7, 2021,
Under review on September 8, 2021,
Major revision on September 23, 2021,
Revised on October 8, 2021,
Accepted on October 14, 2021,
Available online on October 20, 2021.

LL 2021-10-15

25 Aug 2021 submit
06 Sep 2021 reject (Editor requested a resubmission, primarily for language and writing issues)
10 Sep 2021 resubmit
14 Sep 2021 under review
28 Sep 2021 major revise
14 Oct 2021 accept
Thank you, Editor Claus G. Rebholz, PhD.

LL 2021-10-15

A very good journal in the field of metal materials coating, focusing on innovation!

xizhao148 2021-09-22

The first SCI paper of a non-double degree master's program, in the field of thermal barrier coatings, was submitted on July 10th and accepted on September 20th. After submission, it underwent major revisions for one month, with 20 questions from two experts. After the revisions, three additional questions were given during the resubmission, and it was accepted after further revisions. The journal's handling speed was very fast. Thank you, Editor Samir M. Aouadi.

zrrrleo 2021-09-16

2021.7.30 submit
2021.8.4 under review
2021.8.24 major revise
2021.9.15 accept
Field of laser cladding. Received major revisions three weeks after submission. Three experts raised a total of 24 questions.
Resubmitted for revisions on 9.4. Accepted directly on 9.15.
The journal's processing speed is very fast. Thank you to Editor Professor H.C. Man.

Weldon Qiao 2021-09-08

Excuse me, senior, do you have the manuscript template for this journal? Can you please help me share it? QQ email: 2216734875. Thank you.

Z邹小田 2021-09-06

2021/09/06 submitted to journal

Translation: Submitted to journal on September 6, 2021.

Weldon Qiao 2021-08-18

Excuse me, senior, do you have the manuscript template for this journal? Can you share it with me? QQ email: 2216734875, thank you.

余生欢喜 2021-08-10

The research direction is in the aspect of surface coating. A total of 30 questions were raised by three external reviewers, with only three of them related to core issues, while the others were minor issues. The external review process lasted for three weeks, and the revised manuscript was accepted directly after 10 days. The experts' opinions have greatly contributed to the improvement of the article's quality.

jianjianli 2021-07-15

Although the quality of the articles is mostly considered entry-level, the popularity of the articles included is high, with a relatively low citation rate and an increasing impact factor year by year. I feel that it is still possible to maintain a position in the first-tier.

jinx的微笑 2021-07-15

What you said is not divided according to the impact factor.

咩小力 2021-07-14

It's estimated to be tough. The impact factor is too low, and the quality of the article can only be considered as an entry-level in scientific research. It's still very difficult to maintain a first-tier ranking.

戴眼镜的科研汪 2021-06-22

I'm sorry, let me correct it. The submission period should be 5 months.

戴眼镜的科研汪 2021-06-22

20210121 Submitted to Journal - Submitted to the Journal on January 21, 2021.
20210127 Under Review - Under review since January 27, 2021.
20210228 Major Revision - Requires major revision by February 28, 2021.
20210415 Minor Revision - Requires minor revision by April 15, 2021.
20210515 Minor Revision - Requires minor revision by May 15, 2021.
20210609 Minor Revision - Requires minor revision by June 9, 2021.
20210611 Accept - Accepted on June 11, 2021.

We conducted research on the direction of metal coatings, and this journal is a top journal in this field, so we have always wanted to be published in it. The editor showed great interest in my article, and it went through one major revision and three minor revisions. The reviewers were very diligent and responsible, and the last two minor revisions were more like proofreading. I have been eagerly waiting for this article to be accepted, but unfortunately, it didn't coincide with the evaluation for my doctoral interview and academic scholarships. However, I am very happy to have published a top-tier paper in the first area during my master's degree. I hope the journal continues to thrive!